Anyway, I'm going to read through the first four pages and give my thoughts. I'm guessing that by page four we're out of RVS (hopfully; I don't really like RVS). That being said, I will post my suspicions below and then place a vote at the end.
Here it comes, although hopefully notdramonic wrote:If that's supposed to be long, wait until someone makes a Mastin post
Alright, so I will begin by analyzing everyones' votes. I have included a few teaching points in here as well, so I suggest you at least browse it.
- Cirdua (do you mind if I call you Cird for short? I'm too lazy to type "ua") votes pancakes (random vote).
- EB Votes Adel (for OMGUS, although I don't see how it's OMGUS; Adel had not posted yet)
- Dramonic votes EB (for voting the IC) interesting note: "weneed him to mind-control the newbies " Who is we?
- Steve (aka me) votes no lynch. (teaching point: DO NOTsuggest no lynch because it CANNOT help the town. At least, not in this case. Usually, it's not a good idea in Newbie games. It can be helpful in LyLo when you have certain roles still alive. But that's for discussion elsewhere.)
- EB votes Steve (for suggestingvoting no lynch)
- TF votes himself (because he's not mean) (teaching point #2: do not self vote. Unless you're scum, it does not help the town in any way.)
- Steve votes Cirdua (assumably because he provided reasoning for not doing a no lynch... not a good reason)
- HF votes LL (no reasoning)
- pancakes votes HF (b/c of "best avatar"--btw I like it too, but that's not good basis for even a random vote)
- LL votes no lynch AFTERit has already been explained why you shouldn't. (because that's how they do it at epic mafia... well, that's not how we do it here. )
- EB votes LL (for "bandwagoning" a no lynch after explanation) (teaching point #3: a bandwagon is when people begin to pile votes on, one after the other. I usually consider something a bandwagon at the 3rd vote, not the second. I would not necessarily consider this bandwagonning, because Steve had already unvoted no lynch)
- TF votes EB (because "glasses are for loser") (teaching point #4: ok, that can be considered a personal attack, which I think is modkillable, so please be careful. also, we've had some good semi-serious discussion going on, so I think at this point we were getting out of RVS, so why the random vote this far into the game?)
- TF votes Cird (because of "trippy picture")
- Adel votes Steve (b/c no avatar. agreed that having an avatar is very helpful. if anyone else doesn't have one, I suggest you get one)
- Cird votes Dramonic (b/c of signature... ok I guess we weren't out of RVS. Close though!)
- LL votes EB (for pure OMGUS... why?)
- Adel votes pancakes (once again for no avatar)
- Adel votes EB (...I guess trying to prove a point. but why'd you put him at L-2? if there are scum that aren't voting him, they can quick lynch!)
- Dramonic votes Adel (for putting EB at L-2)
- LL votes Cird ("i fell like it"), btw LL and everyone else who doesn't have a gender icon set, would you mind doing so? I won't want to say "he" when you might be a "she".
- EB votes Adel
- Dramonic unvotes (at L-1 too soon)
- pancakes votes no lynch. (wtf!? tomorrow ingame, we'll be at the same place we are today ingame, except with one less townie. dude... it's already been explained twice!)
- EB votes pancakes (for even thinking about no lynch again)
- Dramonic tries to vote pancakes (it has to be in your own words.)
- Cird votes pancakes (same reasoning)
- Dramonic votes pancakes (same reasoning)
- HF votes pancakes (same reasoning) (you know he's now at L-1?)
- EB unvotes b/c that built up too fast (agreed. there has to be at least 1 scum on that wagon! As I said before, a bandwagon starts imo at the 3rd vote, so I would have to suspect Cird there)
- TF votes pancakes (more bandwagonning.. very suspicious... did you know you put him back at L-1?)
- Adel votes HF (b/c of wagonning)
- EB follows Adel and votes HF
That bandwagonning was very suspicious in my mind. Since 5/9 people voted on that wagon, I'm willing to bet that one or even both scum are on that wagon.
Right now, because he put pancakes BACK at L-1, I'm going to
However, since Dramonic was 3rd on the first wagon, I am going to have to put my
In any case, it's still pretty early on. I suggest that unless you actually have real suspicions of pancakes (besides the suggesting no lynch) that you unvote him. There's no need to bring someone this close to a lynch on page 4.