StefanB wrote:Hurristat: Okay tell me which of my points are forced? If anyone has something that shows that I made a mistake, please speak. I'm convinced that AP is scum, if there is something that doesn't match up, tell me before a mistake is made. I am pressing you at the moment because you are the only one who said that there is something wrong with it.
Mostly 1 and 4 stuck out to me -- but I guess it just seemed to me that you and AP had begun focusing on each other and no one else. I guess that's all.
I was going to tell you to vote for me if you think I'm scummier, but I don't know if you want someone at L-1 just yet.
Nocmen wrote:76: hurristat pointing out that WIR is L-2 seems suspicious. We knew he was at L-2, why would you ask? Trying to have you and your buddy double hammer?
There's a reason this is a "newbie" game -- where I had played mafia previously, it was customary to ask questions like that if you didn't entirely remember what the scenario was.
79: Hurristat again, why do you want to vote for WIR at this point? I haven't seen too many original suspicions from you, sounds like you're joining the wagon.
I really hadn't read the entirety of the thread when I posted that, just the first couple of pages, so at that point I thought WIR was the scummiest.
106: Hurristat actually posts good content. I find it interesting that he gives a lot for AP though, and little for anyone else. Seems like he's tunneling on AP.
I guess it would seem like I was tunneling on AP for the first day, you're right.
I find it interesting that WIR and AP are in a lot of these lists as the most scummy, and Ghost at the bottom. Hurristat's list (140) seems a lot like he's following people.
The reason for that -- I haven't played a game on mafiascum before, and I'm not acquainted with all the things that are considered scummy here (even though I read a lot of the wiki). So I read what others said, weighed it in my mind, and placed it in the order I thought appropriate.
Hurristat's lurking and tunneling both seem scummy, especially when I have a feeling hurristat will use the fact that others suspect AP as reason to lynch him, and if he's scum, get town cred. That's where I see the game right now, with hurristat/AP as the most likely to be scum.
Fair enough.
AwesomePoe wrote:hurri’s comment, which was first, tells me he would have been watching the thread pretty closely during the night and would have an idea when the night would be over.
I knew when night would be over because GLaDOS announced it at the end of Day 1.
That coupled with his doctor comment, leads me to believe his post was fishing for the doctor.
Where I played mafia before, it was customary to congratulate the doctor after a successful save. Again, I have to learn what to do and what not to do here.
That and his behavior and vote have not changed much day two.
I don't see how me not changing behavior makes me scummy, (but I can see how the vote not changing is scummy.)
hurri seems the most undisturbed by how the night went, and reacts more to the nokill than the WIR lynch.
Of course I was undisturbed -- no one died (which was good). But w/r/t the nokill vs the WIR lynch, I was gone when WIR self-voted, and therefore could not comment on the WIR vote. I figured there wasn't really much for me to say about it when the day started, so I didn't comment upon it
One more point on hurri, he did not consider that both me and SB being town and has since demoted SB to the same scum status as myself. There really isn’t a point for SB to be below Haylen or Deer. The SB vs AP fight reflects more my aggression on SB than SB’s defense.
Ya, I honestly have to agree with these points.
(If only I knew German...)