Cirno wrote:@Hopp
: The eyeroll smilie leads me to believe that you don't actually believe that "mothrax & KC are scum". Is there anybody in particular you
do
believe to be scum?
Actually, they are my top two candidates for scum at the moment. I was just being ironic.
I don't think I've seen enough of tylerjarvis, HwaG or CrackHead (obviously) to say for sure, but my opinion of each player so far is:
Cirno: Mixed feelings. My gut feeling is strongly town though, however some of your characteristics are a bit odd (you tend to be a bit too abrupt/blunt/harsh for my liking).
CrackHead: Bit concerned about his first post. He claims that Cirno's behaviour could be a scum strategy that he doesn't understand due to him being a noob, however from that viewpoint it could surely also be town strategy that he doesn't understand. He may be being sarcastic though as well, it's hard to tell.
drmyshottyizsik: I was suspicious at first, but more recently he's had some good points. Likely town imo.
HwaG: He was extremely defensive of KC when Cirno attacked KC regarding the V/LA. Possibly buddying in my opinion, but it's not enough to go on really. Lack of posts prevent me having a clear scum/town viewpoint on HwaG.
KC: A bit too off-hand for my liking. Seems quick to dismiss others' posts/attacks/general play, without any real meat behind it. Top candidate for scum in my eyes as I'm not exactly sure what he's contributed. Admittedly I am also slightly guilty of this, but I don't have as many posts as KC (who when ISO'd goes onto 2 pages) and in that number of posts it feels like he's achieved nothing.
FoS: KC
Mist: Not convinced by her case on Cirno, but I have a tentative town read on her.
mothrax: Not really sure what to make of mothrax yet. No real opinion on him atm. However, seeing as he has the most posts of the people whom I have a 'neutral' feeling about, I'm inclined to think he could be scum.
tylerjarvis: Not enough content for me to form a justified opinion quite yet. Needs to post more though.
I completely disagree with Mist (and shotty's) case/opinion on Cirno.
Mist7676 wrote:1)Cirno tried to push a lynch on Mothrax
What could that mean? Maybe she was trying to get herself killed and make it look like Mothrax is clear. Being pushed to lynch by scum. Also it could make everyone NOT want to lynch Mothrax because of her annoyingness and pushness and just lynch someone else and save them both for a day.
2) she was all over lynching Mothrax in the beggining than stopped.
What could that mean? She could have just say that no one is jumping on it than stopped trying. Or she never really wanted him lynched. Notice how in the beggining she was only posting to push the lynch on Moth. What happened now??
3) At the beggining she tried to buddy with as many people starting that Central Time Buddies.
What could that mean? Maybe she was trying to risk getting lynched or make her lynches stronger with her backup.
4) she doesn't provide good reasons when trying to push a lynch on someone.
What could that mean? She doesn't have any reasons she just wants someone to die besides her. When she pushed on Mothrax she posted Tarot Cards. When she wanted me dead all she said in 1 post was "Mist is Mafia"
If you haven't voted Cirno yet I advise that you should soon. She has many scumtells and isn't a very good SE.
(1) is a possibillity, however with (2), I am satisfied with Cirno's explanation that the early mothrax wagon was to fast forward RVS. (3) I feel was just something that came with the mothrax wagon, and (4) - she did justify suspicions of Mist, and also, she had no paticular reason to justify the mothrax wagon given its existence only to fast-forward RVS.
@ shotty: Could a mothrax-Cirno connection not be Mist's point (1)? Or do you disagree with this?
@ mothrax: Previously, you described a FoS as a "weak vote placeholder". What is the point of you FoS'ing shotty if that's your opinion?
@ Cirno & KC: What are your opinions on "FoS"?
Benmage: First, for the sake of irony. I'm going to illustrate how completely idiotic and hypocritical scumhunter is.