Post
Post #1775 (isolation #200) » Sat Dec 19, 2015 9:57 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
In a Nacho/Pie both being scum scenario, then the RB doesn't exist. I still don't think Marquis makes extreme sense as a kill. Most likely Tammy, me, or Mara.
In a Nacho-scum, Pie-town scenario I think it makes some amount of sense to kill Marquis. Makes pie look bad and removes a town PR.
Post
Post #1777 (isolation #201) » Sat Dec 19, 2015 10:02 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
Also potentially of note is that Marquis really wanted to lynch Empire. I've been waffling hard on Empire, currently a bit town on him. Killing Marquis for that reason would make sense if Empire is scum but thats only one of many possible reasons for Marquis dying.
Post
Post #1783 (isolation #203) » Sat Dec 19, 2015 10:14 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
Yes. I just don't see some of these Mala posts coming from scum.
Her ISO is wayyyyy too confident to be scum. And I don't mean that as a dig on Mala's scumgame, I mean that shes got some of that good town don't-give-a-shit going on. 802 absolutely does not look like scum-Mala unless maybe shes scum with NS and knows he is being scummy but thats the only way I see scum-Mala making that post. And yes I realize that everyone's favorite pet team is Mala/NotScience right now. But there was also talk earlier in the game about how Mala never busses and I remember Nacho and BRO throwing that around. So I'd love to hear what came of that opinion that Mala and Notty on the same team doesn't make sense.
808 is really a great example of what I see in Mala's ISO. She just doesn't seem to care that shes getting suspected at all aside from a personal pet-peeve vantage which really screams town to me unless Mala's scumgame has gotten shameless in recent days. Also Mala is being a bit pot-shotty to come from scum and none of her posts really feel directed or otherwise awkward. Not voting Mala this game.
Post
Post #1881 (isolation #211) » Sat Dec 19, 2015 6:32 pm
Postby AngryPidgeon »
In post 1879, pieguyn wrote:I don't think this has been brought up, correct me if it has: why does everyone think the team is noddy/Mala when Mala has an established meta of never bussing?
Post
Post #1899 (isolation #213) » Sun Dec 20, 2015 11:05 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
Yes, but im scrambling to do some Christmas shopping atm. Haven't been home in over 24 hours. So I'll be on in an hour or so. Aren't you concerned that mala interactions with gm are TOO obvious?
Post
Post #1905 (isolation #214) » Sun Dec 20, 2015 11:17 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
Well I don't think that shes too scummy to be scum, I think the opposite of that. Or something.
Mala was getting wagoned hard. As scum, I dont think she's double down on the "GM and I always get ML'd" bit. It would make GM look bad after she flipped and I think Mala would avoid doing that out of respect for GM. I think she'd make more of an effort if GM were in fact a buddy. The whole interaction is -lazy- and I think that points to it being town more than anything.
Post
Post #1907 (isolation #215) » Sun Dec 20, 2015 11:25 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
I think she would have ignored GM as much as possible or maybe done what she is doing to NS now (lol). I just think her defense of GM was far too casual to come from someone who was thinking of the consequences of either of them getting lynched and flipping scum. Cause if Mala got lynched of course people would start going after GM like there is no tomorrow and I think Mala wouldn't want that to happen. Its also that she was so proactive about defending GM. Going after Cephrir for it, talking about how they are always mislynched. I think it just makes more sense that she thought GM was town. I could be wrong but Im seeing Mala town here.
Post
Post #1938 (isolation #218) » Sun Dec 20, 2015 7:09 pm
Postby AngryPidgeon »
Tbf, your case on GM had me wondering if you could be scum with her before she flipped. Not saying I am buying into that thought atm but it looks kind of like you realized GM was going to be lurk scum and decided to take advantage early.
Post
Post #1939 (isolation #219) » Sun Dec 20, 2015 7:11 pm
Postby AngryPidgeon »
That said, im having trouble figuring out who I think is a plausible buddy for you at this point. You are sort of leading the charge on Mala so that seems not extremely likely. Probably not pie. Notty maybe.
Post
Post #1941 (isolation #221) » Sun Dec 20, 2015 8:02 pm
Postby AngryPidgeon »
In post 1913, Cephrir wrote:@AP; I don't think this is exactly the same as what you're saying, but what happened is:
Uhhhhhh? You said you'd be 9/10 confident that you only got one scum. I left that conversation originally with the impression you thought it as just one scum in that group and I'm still seeing that on this revisit, but ok. What about the setup didn't make sense? Mala was the only claim and GM has jut made a vague claim of not B/G at that point.
In post 1730, Empire wrote:So looking at the role PM, unless I'm reading it wrong, it seems like there's only one scumbag left. Maybe we should massclaim now?
What the hell is this.
In post 1741, Nachomamma8 wrote:I don't really think my townread for Nati could get any stronger at this point, which is nice.
I really don't get this. Like. I can see townreading Nati, that would make sense. But hailing her as obvtown and leaving her to do whatever is just ???
Why are people hard townreading Nati so hard. Nothing in her ISO is really THAT town.
T->S at the moment:
Tammy
Cephrir
BRO
Nacho
Mala
Pieguy
Natirasha
Empire
NotScience
Post
Post #1955 (isolation #225) » Mon Dec 21, 2015 8:49 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
In post 1951, Tammy wrote:What did you think he was softing and why did you think he could back out of it?
I also want to know what you thought Mara was softing. Cause thats the weird part. It looked like you were trying to soft B/G and then Mara came in and was like oh no you don't" and you were like "are you CCing me?!?". And then claimed Bodyguard. The whole situation was just strange. It was not clear what you were softing and frankly it looked like you were softing Bride/Groom since that is the only open role in the game. I don't know how you thought Mara was CCing a bodyguard claim or that you were obviously softing that.
But then again its possible that all the confusion was just a result of general ego'ing in the thread and little concern for understanding other people's posts. On all fronts. So IDK, it might be worth revisiting again but my better sense is telling me that its going to be a wash to attempt to reread that.
Post
Post #1997 (isolation #233) » Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:33 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
I don't want to do this characterization misjustice, but from what I recall:
Cabd's dad is extremely conservative, fairly racist/sexist, and rather unpleasant. So basically what BRO just said. I actually thought that he could be a Mafia role in the game, but it looks like the Mafia flavor is literal demons so that wouldn't make sense. Doesn't mean that it couldn't be provided to the scumteam as a fakeclaim though, -shrug-.
Sorry I haven't really paid attention and still won't til tomorrow afternoon, but deadline.
This is the first time Nati addresses GM aside from an awkward post to Pieguy in which Nati mentions awkwardly that she would lynch GM but maybe not Mala/Mara. The progression is pretty hollow to me and yes I realize that might just be because Nati isn't reading or doing much participating but thats a pretty poor excuse for town.
The whole bit about Bride/Groom claiming looks awkward as well. Nati is showing a lot of interest in them with setup spec out the gate and then following through on the original idea that they should claim on D2.
It makes this post read weird to me since Nati is devoting most of her content to the Bride/Groom spec. Yet she doesn't actually care about a detail that might be very important to them claiming or her game spec?
90% of Nati's reads are just carelessly suggesting that GM is scummy and not talking about much else. Thinks Mala is town but won't do anything about that other than vote NotScience and be snooty to Nacho for asking about why Nati would vote NS over Mala. And if anyone read Nati's ISO, it'd be clear that she was going to do just that Today barring some actual ...something.
I'm just not seeing why this is town to so many people cause I'm not seeing anything in the ISO that makes me want to townread her.
Post
Post #2004 (isolation #238) » Tue Dec 22, 2015 8:08 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
Ya well.
Before we lynch Mala, I want everyone to know that I'm going to be a completely insufferable douchebag about it if she flips town. But if shes scum I'll prolly just hold Nacho's hand the rest of the game.
Post
Post #2132 (isolation #248) » Mon Dec 28, 2015 8:08 pm
Postby AngryPidgeon »
I can't believe you guys lynched Pie
I mean ya I'm one to talk with Mala in my don't lynch reads. But she was kinda middle of the line opposed to legit townreads like Tammy. but enough apologetics for me. I came here to lynch scum and eat chili. And I have a giant bowl of chili next to me.
Post
Post #2174 (isolation #252) » Tue Dec 29, 2015 7:15 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
In post 2153, Empire wrote:Like, I almost want to get mislynched just so I no longer have to be in this game and I never thought I'd feel this way, ever.
Well we can still win this shit seriously. I think we are really getting down to solving this game. But ya I think pie was pretty town.
Post
Post #2176 (isolation #254) » Tue Dec 29, 2015 7:18 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
In post 2156, Nachomamma8 wrote:I'd expect him to try harder, yeah.
Not science feels pretty prelynched but he is also pretty confident in his ability to obvtown/people usually acknowledge that he's very town when he channels that so it wouldn't be too much effort for notsci to push a wagon off him. As scum, he doesn't really know where to start digging himself out of a hole and thus I expect more apathy in this situation from scum than town.
I actually sort of agree with this. I've seen notty be town before and when he is, its like screamingly town. This is like a loud whisper version of that.
Post
Post #2182 (isolation #256) » Tue Dec 29, 2015 7:37 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
Four scum is plausible and it makes me uncertain enough about setup spec to really try and dive into it. If it is 3 scum, then bodyguard/bodyguard/delayedkillcop/tracker seems excessive.
Post
Post #2184 (isolation #257) » Tue Dec 29, 2015 7:38 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
Although BG is a relatively weak role and having two of them is sort of negative utility due to setup spec. And the delayed kill cop and tracker are average strength roles at best so meh.
Post
Post #2191 (isolation #259) » Tue Dec 29, 2015 7:46 am
Postby AngryPidgeon »
In post 2189, Cephrir wrote:@ap: the sole possible reason is because gm. i'm assuming that doesn't convince you?
Was there some interaction they had that makes people think it unlikely? I do recall seeing Natirasha push for GM more than anyone else. Nacho far and away made the best case on GM though.