Ircher's Large Normal Review, May 2018

[Firebringer]

I would highly suggest limiting the amount of confirmed town roles here.
This looks laughably broken in many respects to things like masons, friendly neighbors and innocent children.

I couldn't pass this in good conscience as is.

[Firebringer]

There is potential for 12 confirmed town on day 3. VERY UNLIKELY, but that is a POSSIBLITY.
And frightening too.

I really think diversifying your town power instead of all these confirmed roles would be good. I think starting with removing friendly neighbors and maybe one innocent child.

Then giving town something else instead.

[Firebringer]

I went through everything but the rules.
All the role pms are fine and everything is considered Normal.

The problem you have is still the balance portion which I need your input on in order to get this game the way you want and we can sign of on it.

[Firebringer]

mean, it is a large, and I’m not sure where you two are getting the # of conf town going up from.

Friendly Neighbor
Universal Back up.


These roles up the already confirmed Town.

You have way too many confirmed Town.
Like I think 4 is too much. You 7 day one and it only has potential to go up higher.
Friendly neighbor confirms two players

And adding a vigilante does not really help this.
You need roles that won’t be confirmed Town just by their existence.
There’s possibility I guess town thinks vigi is SK but that is remote.

Here are some suggestions:
Scenario 1
Remove all masons
Take out Town Universal Backup
Add in a power role for town that isn’t confirmed

That might be fine
Scenario 2
Remove both Friendly Neighbors
Take out one mason or innocent child
Add in a power role for that that isn’t confirmed

[Firebringer]

I think either replacing the universal back up town or the innocent child would be best way to make this as close to my acceptable range of balance.

I think I might fine with RC suggestion on innocent child to Friendly Neighbor.

[Firebringer]

I am fine with this

Radiant, thoughts?