Player Awards
- Body of Work
- Best Mafia Catcher- "Paragon of Mafia Hunters" Award
- roflcopter in Legends of Literature Mafia - nominated by Caboose
- Caboose in Legends of Literature Mafia - nominated by roflcopter, seconded by Tenchi, thirded by PokerFace
- Porkens in Mini 756 - nominated by Knight of Cydonia, seconded by Juls, thirded by Trumpet of Doom
- OhGodMyLife in Silent Mafia 3 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by charter, thirded by Slicey, etc.
- camn in Open 122 - nominated by VP Baltar, seconded by Kmd4390
- Vi in Mafia 91 - nominated by Shanba. seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by alexhans, etc.
- inHimshallibe in Mafia 95 - nominated by Xylthixlm.
- Spolium in Newbie 705 - nominated by Santos
- BloodCovenent in Mini 801 - nominated by AshMC1984, seconded by Empking, thirded by ortolan, etc.
- ryan2754 in Mini 829 - nominated by DeathRowKitty, seconded by RedCoyote, thirded by alexhans, etc.
- DTMaster for Battle Mafia - nominated by BloodCovenent.- nomination retracted by DTMaster
- roflcopter in Legends of Literature Mafia - nominated by Caboose
- Most Cunning Manipulation- "The Don Corleone" Award
- LlamaFluff in Mafia 86 - nominated by Claus, seconded by Mr. Flay, thirded by Kison, etc.
- Wall-E in Open 100 - nominated by ThAdmiral
- don_johnson in mini 737 - nominated by Rhinox, seconded by Spolium
- Casey in Mini 740 - nominated by Juls, seconded by Budja
- Zorblag in Newbie 749 - nominated by Mirth, seconded by Albert B. Rampage, thirded by Mitey Mouse, etc.- declined by Zorblag
- Imaginality in Mini 779 - nominated by AshMC1984.
- Vi in Mini 792 - nominated by Elmo, seconded by Zorblag.
- ryan2754 in Mini 761 - nominated by Kise.
- J-scope (Jahudo and KaleiÐoscøpe) in DHSDSM Alpha and in DHSDSM Beta- nominated by PokerFace, seconded by Adel, thirded by ortolan, etc.
- Xylthixlm in Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by MafiaSSK, thirded by Seraphim, etc
- Khamisa in Open 154 - nominated by Kise.
- Goatrevolt in Advertising Mafia - nominated by OhGodMyLife, seconded by Faraday.
- Mirth in Mini 699 - nominated by farside22
- q21 in War in Heaven II - nominated by Mr. Flay, seconded by DrippingGoofball
- benmage in Battle Mafia - nominated by Vi, seconded by BloodCovenent, thirded by Maemuki, etc.
- UncertainKitten in Mini 853 - nominated by malthusis, seconded by Tarhalindur, thirded by Boxman.
- Thok in CT III - nominated by Papa Zito, seconded by CSL.
- LlamaFluff in Mafia 86 - nominated by Claus, seconded by Mr. Flay, thirded by Kison, etc.
- Most Outstanding New Player
should have joined the site no later than ~Oct. 2008- VP Baltar in Newbie 696 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by Incognito, thirded by Stef, etc.
- Gwynplaine in Newbie 707 - nominated by julienvonwolfe, seconded by Tenchi
- Papa Zito in Newbie 762 - nominated by Mastin, seconded by sirdanilot, thirded by OhGodMyLife, etc.
- Agar in Newbie 792 - nominated by Khelvaster, seconded by Indigo Heron, thirded by Wickedestjr, etc.
- SerialClergyman in Mini 836 - nominated by Kublai Khan, seconded by Kison, thirded by Empking, etc.
- Ojanen in /in-vitational 4 and Newbie 764 - nominated by SerialClergyman, seconded by charter, thirded by mith, etc.
- Raskol in Newbie 818 - nominated by Debonair Danny DiPietro, seconded by Pomegranate, thirded by KittyMo.
- ODDin in Newbie 845 - nominated by Zorblag, seconded by KittyMo.
- VP Baltar in Newbie 696 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by Incognito, thirded by Stef, etc.
- Most Improved Player
- Best Replacement
- ZONEACE in Family Guy Mafia - nominated by farside22, seconded by populartajo, thirded by LlamaFluff, etc.
- Xylthixlm in Phables: Death Note Mafia - nominated by LlamaFluff.
- Ether in Boost Mafia 2 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by OhGodMyLife.
- Ether in Mini 728 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by OhGodMyLife.
- ZONEACE in Family Guy Mafia - nominated by farside22, seconded by populartajo, thirded by LlamaFluff, etc.
- Best IC
- Thesp in Newbie 792 - nominated by Khelvaster, seconded by Indigo Heron, thirded by Wickedestjr, etc.
- Incognito for Newbie 700, Newbie 775 and Newbie 798 - nominated by Haylen, seconded by nhammen, thirded by VP Baltar, etc.
- Thesp in Newbie 792 - nominated by Khelvaster, seconded by Indigo Heron, thirded by Wickedestjr, etc.
- Funniest Player- "The Coffee on the Monitor" Award
- Jahudo for this post and this post - nominated by Pokerface, seconded by OhGodMyLife, thirded by shaft.ed
- Raging Wishbone (Walt Wishbone and Raging Rabbit) - nominated by Pokerface.
- Korlash - nominated by Kublai Khan, seconded by dramonic, thirded by Pokerface.
- Spyrex - nominated by Slicey, seconded by Papa Zito, thirded by Faraday, etc.
- PookyTheMagicalBear for this post - nominated by mith, seconded by charter, thirded by populartajo, etc.
- VP Baltar - nominated by DrippingGoofball, seconded by Papa Zito, thirded by Zachrulez.
- Jahudo for this post and this post - nominated by Pokerface, seconded by OhGodMyLife, thirded by shaft.ed
- Single Game/Thread/Post
- Best Performance Pro-Town Team
- The Town of Crackers! Mafia - nominated by Korts
- The Town of Open 118 - nominated by SliceyRecinded by Slicey.
- The Town of Mini 773 - nominated by afatchic, seconded by Kublai Khan.
- The Town of Crackers! Mafia - nominated by Korts
- Best Performance Scum Group
- The Mafia of Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by MafiaSSK, thirded by Stef
- The Fallen Angels of War In Heaven II - nominated by shaft.ed
- The Mafia of Mini 740 - nominated by Juls
- The Mafia of Open 151 - nominated by Kise.
- The Mafia of Open 154 - nominated by Kise.
- The Mafia of Advertising Mafia - nominated by OhGodMyLife, seconded by MichelSableheart, thirded by TDC, etc.
- The Mafia of Mini 838 - nominated by dramonic, seconded by Chaco, thirded by EriktheRed
- The Japanese Mafia of Mafia 86 - nominated by nhammen, seconded by animorpherv1
- The Inquisitors in Mini 853. - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by Boxman.
- The Mafia of Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by MafiaSSK, thirded by Stef
- Best Performance Third Party
- Xylthixlm in Phables: Death Note Mafia - nominated by LlamaFluff, seconded by Pokerface.
- Sabrewolf for Large 99 - nominated by Empking, seconded by tubby216.
- Haylen for Mini 851 - nominated by xofelf, seconded by J-Fox, thirded by KittyMo, etc.
- Haylen for Mean Mod LoveFest - nominated by xofelf, seconded by J-Fox, thirded by KittyMo, etc.
- The Outsiders of Legacy of the Ancients mafia - nominated by Boxman, seconded by Tarhalindur.
- Xylthixlm for Legacy of the Ancients mafia - nominated by Tarhalindur. seconded by Boxman.
- EtherealCookie in Perfectionist Mafia - nominated by Max.
- Xylthixlm in Phables: Death Note Mafia - nominated by LlamaFluff, seconded by Pokerface.
- Best Role Claim- "Johnny Cochrane" Award
- Llamafluff in Mafia 86 - nominated by The Fonz, seconded by Jahudo, thirded by BlakAdder, etc.
- mykonian in Mini 707 - nominated by q21, seconded by animorpherv1
- q21 in War in Heaven II - nominated by Simenon, seconded by Adel, thirded by Giuseppe, etc
- ZONEACE in Family Guy Mafia - nominated by PokerFace
- Fishythefish in Mini 801 - nominated by AshMC1984, seconded by Kise.
- ryan2754 in Mini 761 - nominated by Kise.
- UncertainKitten in Mini 853 - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by Boxman, thirded by malthusis.
- Llamafluff in Mafia 86 - nominated by The Fonz, seconded by Jahudo, thirded by BlakAdder, etc.
- Funniest Role Claim- "George W Bush" Award
- Xylthixlm in Medieval Mafia - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by Kairyuu, thirded by nhammen.
- imaginality in Mini 733, nominated by Mirth, seconded by destructor
- PookyTheMagicalBear in /in-vitational 4, nominated by mith, seconded by populartajo, thirded by Slicey.
- Xylthixlm in Medieval Mafia - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by Kairyuu, thirded by nhammen.
- Most Enjoyable Game
- Adel for Crackers! Mafia - nominated by Raging Rabbit, seconded by Korts, thirded by destructor
- Tarhalindur for Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Seraphim, seconded by populartajo
- Mr. Flay for War in Heaven II - nominated by populartajo, seconded by shaft.ed
- OhGodMyLife for Medieval Mafia - nominated by Tarhalindur
- Tarhalindur for Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Mafia - nominated by Kairyuu
- Kinetic for Wheel of Time Mafia: Rip in the Pattern - nominated by Sajin, seconded by Faraday.
- The Players for /in-vitational 4 - nominated by mith, seconded by charter, thirded by SerialClergyman, etc.
- forbiddanlight for MtG: Parallel Universe Mafia: Kamigawa - nominated by Starbuck,seconded by Boxman.
- MafiaSSK for MtG:Parallel Universe Mafia: Weatherlight Saga - nominated by Starbuck,seconded by Boxman.
- Tarhalindur for MtG: Parallel Universe Mafia: Time Spiral - nominated by Starbuck,seconded by Boxman.
- Mirth for Mini 733 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by imaginality, thirded by destructor, etc.
- Machiavellian-Mafia for Prisoner's Dilemma - nominated by The Central Scrutinizer
- Jahudo for Mini 783 - nominated by Juls. seconded by Vi, thirded by PokerFace, etc.
- Porkens for Mini 819 - nominated by Locke Lamora, seconded by VP Baltar, thirded by SpyreX, etc.
- PsychoSniper for Mini 807 - nominated by xRECKONERx, seconded by Starbuck.
- millar13 for VENGEFUL 5 Version 2 - nominated by Drench, seconded by Empking, thirded by Stef, etc.
- Newbie 830]Newbie 830 - nominated by CSL, seconded by Mr Flay.
- Tarhalindur for Legacy of the Ancients mafia - nominated by malthusis, seconded by UncertainKitten, thirded by xRECKONERx, etc.
- Adel for Crackers! Mafia - nominated by Raging Rabbit, seconded by Korts, thirded by destructor
Moderator Awards
- Best Setup
- Tarhalindur for Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Seraphim, seconded by populartajo, thirded by Stef, etc.
- Mirth for Mini 733 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by imaginality, thirded by destructor, etc.
- Tarhalindur for Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Mafia - nominated by Kairyuu
- Kinetic for Wheel of Time Mafia: Rip in the Pattern - nominated by Sajin, seconded by Faraday.
- Saunt Adelaus (Adel and Claus) in DHSDSM Alpha - nominated by PokerFace, seconded by Jahudo, thirded by Slicey.
- Saunt Adelaus (Adel and Claus) in DHSDSM Beta - nominated by PokerFace, seconded by Jahudo, thirded by Slicey.
- Patrick for Mini 692 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by OhGodMyLife.
- Patrick for Boost Mafia 2 - nominated by Incognito, seconded by Kmd4390, thirded by OhGodMyLife.
- Tarhalindur for Legacy of the Ancients Mafia - nominated by malthusis, seconded by UncertainKitten, thirded by xRECKONERx, etc.
- Tarhalindur for Mind Screw Mafia 3 - nominated by Seraphim, seconded by populartajo, thirded by Stef, etc.
- Best Role(new or adaptation) - "Flying Pumpkin That Shoots Lazers Out Of Its Ass" Award
- Tarhalindur for Townie Speaker for the Dead - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by populartajo
- OhGodMyLife for Charlemagne, Town Vehmgericht Master - nominated by Tarhalindur, seconded by Slicey, thirded by Stef, etc.
- SensFan for Mason-Neighbour - nominated by xofelf, seconded by hitogoroshi.
- Vi for Mentor - nominated by Kublai Khan, seconded by VP Baltar, thirded by Amished.
- Tarhalindur for Townie Speaker for the Dead - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by populartajo
- Best Flavor Text- "Paperback Writer" Award
- farside22 for Family Guy Mafia - nominated by pacman281292, seconded by Kmd4390
- kloud1516 for Mini738 - nominated by Wizardcat
- Mirth for Mini 733 - nominated by Kmd4390, seconded by imaginality, thirded by destructor, etc.
- BridgesAndBaloons for Mini 714 - nominated by alexhans
- Prof. Guppy for Mini 779 - nominated by AshMC1984
- alexhans (co-mod) in Mini 791 - nominated by Mastin, seconded by Kairyuu
- EmpTyger for Mini 793 - nominated by veerus, seconded by Furry, thirded by MafiaSSK, etc.
- Porkens for Mini 819 - nominated by Locke Lamora, seconded by VP Baltar, thirded by SpyreX, etc.
- SensFan for Mini 788 - nominated by xofelf.
- Korts for Advertising Mafia - nominated by OhGodMyLife, seconded by Goatrevolt.
- Korlash for Korlash Town - nominated by dramonic, seconded by Trumpet of Doom, thirded by yellowbunny.
- mith for /in-vitational 4 - nominated by ekiM, seconded by Amished.
- Haylen for Open 177 - nominated by SaintKerrigan, seconded by CSL, thirded by Maemuki.
- farside22 for Family Guy Mafia - nominated by pacman281292, seconded by Kmd4390
- Best Mechanic/Mutation
- Vi for Vi Pod's battery powered deadlines (also found in Border of Touhou and mafia) - nominated by Sotty7, seconded by dramonic, thirded by tubby216, etc.
- Tarhalindur for Legacy of the Ancients mafia - nominated by malthusis, seconded by UncertainKitten, thirded by xRECKONERx, etc.
- KaleiÐoscøpe for Realistic Mafia II - nominated by animorpherv1
- Yosarian2 for Lynch all Lurkers Mafia - nominated by Xylthixlm, seconded by Mastin, thirded by hitogoroshi.
- Vi for Vi Pod's battery powered deadlines (also found in Border of Touhou and mafia) - nominated by Sotty7, seconded by dramonic, thirded by tubby216, etc.
- "Smooth Operator"- for the "moderation" part of modding: vote counts, prodding, generally keeping the game running smoothly
Site Awards
- Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion/The wiki- "Professor Mafia" Award
- Behind the Scenes- "Name Should Be In Orange" Award
- MishMash User (Player or Mod or Both)
- Cybele - nominated by animorpherv1.
- MishMash Game
- General Discussion Award
- Quagmire - nominated by Sopianae
Accurate as of post 643.