Scummies 2013 - Nomination Thread

[Mehdi2277]

I'm assuming policy 5 should have both years one ahead.

[Mehdi2277]

Sanjay replaced in day 2. Day 3 scum slip with day 4 incorrect guilty on someone. Day 5 and Day 2 not being lynched was his play but day 5 he was basically the person everyone wanted sk'd and if philla hadn't been bp then he'd likely trump philla lynch wise. He fits most enjoyable more with things like the scratch action and generally being fun to listen to then best replacement.

The rest nth though (yeah I realize it doesn't make a difference past a second).

[Mehdi2277]

Any player that's improved whether from nothing (as in new and is doing great) or just meh to great. So combination of most improved and best newbie. Of the two I'll do

Nominate Bumi for Rising Star for Mafiastuck

[Mehdi2277]

As for why he basically took over a null slot, made it one of the strongest town reads people had that even after guiltying a town he was fine (although role stuff was connected, but main thing he was trusted a lot), and generally tried to take control of the game full of a lot people arguing.

[Mehdi2277]

3rd

Continuing the game started out a bit slow but it got really interesting even early on with matt fake claiming QT investigator and it was nice to see how the set up worked (9 scum in one game) and while it had some lurking the discussion was fun to follow.