Scummies 2015 - Nomination Thread!

[Aneninen]

I want to nominate

T S O

for his excellent scum performance

[Most Cunning Manipulator]

in The Masquerade.

Some really great manipulation there. He wouldn't be lynched if three more days went by, that's how solid his scum game was, here.

+1 that

[Aneninen]

Although I wasn't there I checked the game a couple of times, so,

7th Mod Error

[Aneninen]

Nominating

RadiantCowbells

as

Best Scum

for this game:
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=64284

Here's the short story. It was a Role Madness game. There was a Mass-claim (at least categories) on Day1, we lynched Mafia. RadiantCowbells claimed Bodyguard. At Night1 Mafia Nightkilled Randomidget who was a Bus-Driver. They buried him and from that point RadiantCowbells "impersonated" Randomidget: he told he was the Bus-Driver... and noone ever questioned him.
From that point the whole game turned into a guessing-madness. Everyone set up theories about all the events, roles, alignments – the same happened in the Death Thread too –, but noone got even close to the answer.
It was so obvious that he had to be the Bus-Driver that we doubted everyone and everything... and in the end there was only one single townie left amongst all the different scum factions who had the same WinCon.
I still have no idea what we could have done. ^_^

[Aneninen]

Also, I would like to create a category for Scotmany for his performance as the SK. I don't feel like it fits most cunning manipulator but at the same time I feel like the play deserved some sort of scummy none the less. There are many games each year that a player has great play but is a victim of circumstance. I feel this was it. If there can't be a category for great play in a loss, so be it. I feel at least he should be nommed though.
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=63662

I second the category itself. Sometimes certain players are doing it exceptionally but they fail in the end because of something silly. (Another example for this is Egg in NewYork #181, he was the SK, Nightkilled two Mafiosos, got to LyLo (the Mafia was out of the game after Day4) and somehow he got lynched.) <-- Although this category shouldn't be only for SKs.

[Aneninen]

I 3rd Varsoon

.
Although I haven't been in any of his games, I know the feeling (*) when I work very hard to do something cool, useful or necessary, and in the end noone even seems to realize all the effort I have made.

(*) These feelings are not MafiaScum-related.