RR D1 ISO (I should probably note that I am only capturing posts that I view as significant - it is possible that there is meat in fluff somewhere that I haven't included in this post)
54 Vote Jingle for rephrasing their mech question/accuses the rephrase of being a shade cast
65 wgeurts performative in posting, NAI
79 Doens't liek voting Jingle, doesn't know where to go
96 Votes CSF, accuses of pocketing
114 Klick TR Adorable, Porkens, Jingle, RR TR Jingle Null Porkens Adorable
132 Explains CSF is defending wgeurts too strongly, implies they think wgeurts is town/CSF scum there
164 asks wgeurts for reads wall details
210 Asked because wgeurts having comprehensive reads on every slot feels forced, notes all reads except CSF are leans
223 HPE play is town-meta
305 Cerb is not passing vibe check, no details/ability toi give details
345 Fate town, genuine and self-interested, would be 3p if it was an option
368 Fate is emotional and reactive, and stream of consciousness, and that makes them genuine
370 Deliberated posts are easier to fake, adn it's hard to fake fluid and spontaneous stuff, but deliberate does not equal fake or scummy, comfy with jingle town
399 Response to meta knowledge of a players style that must have come from someone who is teammates with someone who knows them, was also suspicous of peta for avoiding doing content
405 Still thinks peta's scum, meta situation is not as strong
573 townlean on HPE personally, doens't care to appear about how it's posts appear, but this is not a meta read
612 feels peta is waffling on HPE
632 Questions HPE on their lack of reads
646 Tiered reads Jingle/Wgeurts; Adorable/Fate; HPE/////Porkens; Cerb/Peta; CSF, okay with anyone after the ////, except maybe porkens because SR is the push origin
649 CSF SR still comes from the wgeurts defense, only "clearly scummy" thing they've seen, other just aren't doing "town" things
657 CSF defense does not match the way RR perceived the wgeurts interaction
719 Votes Cerb, E-1
763 Post cerb claim, unvotes cerb and is going to go to porkens most likely
770 Votes Porkens, teammates disagree on CSF read which was only reservation(perhaps prior reads were lower than the rating I gave them? below town may be scum, ratrher than null)
819 Cerb verifiable claim(reading as null), wgeurts off the table, CSF and peta scum(team opposes)
829 wgeurts scum due to overanalysis early game, but logic was reasonable and meta upheld, HPE "catch" looked genuine
875 Questions fate about difference between settling for HPE and policy voting Porkens
903 fully in favor of porkens lim
This feels kind of like a cop-out, honestly, but I don't see any scummy behaviors from RR's ISO. At all. I see consistent questioning of many game relevant details. I see progression on slot reads based on their posting, and those progressions are reasonable. I see multiple scum-reads, and a very town reluctance to pursue the push on the weaker SR because the stronger one is the source of the other support for that wagon. The closest thing to scummy, overall, is the overall characterization of most of D1's actions as simply not being town enough - but honestly, that's basically the sort of waffling/lack of real commitment to reads that I get SR for on D1 constantly, and I can see it being a town mindset and read on the game.
Doing towny things, responding in towny ways, not doing scummy things, solidly town.
RR: I really should have asked this yesterday, but for clarification - does "fluid and spontaneous" equal town to you? You said the opposite doesn't equal scum, but didn't really clarify fully. This is obviously a bit late in the day, but what effect did CSF flipping town have on your reads? That was your only confident SR(alongside maybe Peta, it's kind of unclear whether Peta has sunk down to the level of CSF in your end of D1 posting), even though your team disagreed.