post in this thread to get criticism[read post 0]

[Shirou]

I suck, especially as scum.
Plz help.
You don’t even need to give me constructive criticism about how to improve. Just roast me.

My humble opinion on scum!Norwe:
I think first you need to recognize that you generally, or at least often in my opinion, don't enjoy playing scum a lot. Many people don't, including me nowadays, which means you probably need to adapt a strategy to make your scum game easier on your shoulders rather than aggressively try to replicate your town meta, because that either highlights to people notice how different than usual you're being, or it makes you've apathy towards the game/lurk it out/not enjoy it.

If I was in your shoes, I would try to make my scum game about subtly buddying people/slipping into the townblock rather than actively try to miseliminate players or control the thread. It's a much less stressful playstyle, and you could do all but engage players with questions, commentaries about their reads, and minor discussions with them about the difference in your "reads".

I can't say about whether this would result in higher winrates, I only theorize it may feel easier/more fun for you to play, and that's what should count probably?

If people ever get to classify your meta as "Norwe does this X as scum", you can simply mess with them and mix a bit with your older style as you see fit. Replicating your meta as either alignment is a bit overrated, because meta reads aren't very good in average without properly datamining stuff.

About town!Norwe, I don't have any recommendations to say.

(Disclaimer: just my opinion)

[Shirou]

still want to get reviewed, mostly on how to not flake out

I think actively/forcibly engaging with a few players that you like in the game, be it for alignment or non-alignment reasons, would make the game more fun to you therefore making you more engaged?

It's hard to get into a game where you don't feel your voice is being heard, or people are all against/biased on you, so finding a few people to work with from the first few days/pages may make the game more enjoyable in my opinion. Looking for games with playerlists you enjoy is also good advice probably, the game is much more enjoyable when you're playing with people you feel comfortable be it for their personality or playstyle.

(Disclaimer: my opinion, and honestly I don't have figured out how to enjoy mafia games at all, although the above did help towards it).

[Shirou]

/in just in case anyone is interested on saying anything to me as well I suppose.

(Fumuki's alt, and I added in Fumuki's signature all my most known alts).

[Shirou]

tfw you use an alt to criticize players

(would still like some insight btw peoples)

I mostly play in alts, I would post this on a popular main if I had one, but most people that know me, know me as an alt player.

I don't know what difference it would make to post in any of my accounts.

(80% of people that know me, also instantly recognize my alts).

[Shirou]

Damn Mena you don't have to rub it in so hard, I have some variety

Sorry guys, posted in the wrong account