Scummies 2011 Nominations

[Scummies]

Scummies 2011, second half.

Player Awards

• Body of Work
  • Best Mafia Catcher
    - "Paragon of Mafia Hunters" Award
    • xRECKONERx, nominated by MagnaofIllusion, seconded by gandalf5166, thirded by Starbuck,
      
    • PranaDevil, nominated by lewarcher82, seconded by Parama, thirded by brokenscraps
      
    • andrew94, nominated by [Low Key], seconded by DeathRowKitty
      
    • Yosarian 2, Nominated by Magister Ludi, seconded by mastin2, thirded by Amrun
      
    • Mastermind of Sin, nominated by StrangerCoug.
  • Most Cunning Manipulation
    - "The Don Corleone" Award
    • DTMaster, nominated by xRECKONERx, seconded by Kdub, thirded by DrippingGoofball, etc
      
    • xRECKONERx, nominated by dramonic, seconded by mastin2, thirded by Demonhybrid, etc
      
    • TwoHeadedBoy, nominated by GreyICE, seconded by Mastin
      
    • iamausername, nominated by RedCoyote, seconded by Xalxe, thirded by mastin2
      
    • Faraday, nominated by AlmasterGM, seconded by Parama, thirded by Katsuki, etc.
      
    • SleepyKrew, nominated by ReaperCharlie
      
    • Mith, nominated by SleepyKrew, seconded by UncertainKitten, thirded by Llamarble, etc.
      
    • Yosarian2, nominated by Kinetic
      
    • Shadow Dancer, nominated by Pokerface.
  • Most Outstanding New Player
    
    
    should have joined the site no earlier than ~Oct. 2010
    • *Andrew94, nominated by Chronopie, seconded by ThAdmiral,
      
    • *Lady Lambdadelta, nominated by MagnaofIllusion, seconded by Xalxe, thirded by CSL, etc
      
    • Amrun, nominated by LlamaFluff, seconded by Sotty7, thirded by Seraphim, etc
      
    • Feysal, nominated by VP Baltar, seconded by Nicodemus, thirded by xRECKONERx, etc
      
    • sandchocolates, nominated by Incognito, seconded by Voidedmafia
      
    • SleepyKrew, nominated by ReaperCharlie
      
    • gbevilchaos, nominated by Espeonage, seconded by Nobody Special, thirded by Morthas, etc.
      
    • Hikari Link, nominated by Junpei, seconded by The Fonz, thirded by Twistedspoon
      
    • Hoppster, Nominated by Twistedspoon.
      
    • GreyICE, nominated by UncertainKitten, seconded by Llamarble, thirded by Packbat, etc
      
    • ToastyToast, nominated by Danakillsu, seconded by bvoigt
      
    • zMuffinMan, nominated by Magister Ludi, seconded by SleepyKrew, thirded by Sotty7, etc
  • Most Improved Player
    • Andrew94, nominated by Lateralus22, seconded by gandalf5166, thirded by Equinox, etc
      
    • Andrius, nominated by MagnaofIllusion, seconded by ReaperCharlie, thirded by DemonHybrid, etc
      
    • Faraday, nominated by populartajo,
      
    • Lady Lambdadelta, Nominated by GreyICE, seconded by Katsuki, thirded by xRECKONERx, etc
  • Best Replacement
    • PranaDevil, Mini 1101, nominated by lewarcher82,
      
    • Setael, for Mini 1161, amongst others, nominated by Quilford, seconded by DarthYoshi, thirded by Faraday
      
    • Beck, nominated by Beck
      
    • Mastermind of Sin, nominated by Banshee, seconded by Porochaz, thirded by Katsuki, etc
      
    • Andrius, nominated by Faraday
  • Best IC
    • Thor665, nominated by Chkflip, seconded by Ythan, thirded by Equinox, etc.
      
    • zMuffinMan, nominated by Sotty7
  • Funniest Player
    - "The Coffee on the Monitor" Award
    • Hasdgfas, nominated by Faraday, seconded by Chkflip, thirded by ReaperCharlie, etc
      
    • Korlash, nominated by Kublai Khan, seconded by RedCoyote, thirded by Xalxe, etc
      
    • zMuffinman, Nominated by Twistedspoon
      
    • Thor665, nominated by Mastermind of Sin, seconded by Faraday, mastin2
      
    • SpyreX, Nominated by xRECKONERx, seconded by Gandalf5166, thirded by MagnaofIllusion, etc
    
    
    
    
  • Best Performance in a Losing Cause
    • MagnaofIllusion, nominated by SaintKerrigan,
      
    • Rayfrost, nominated by silavor, seconded by Me=Weird, thirded by I Am Innocent,
      
    • Mastermind of Sin for Chuck Season 1, nominated by Ooba, seconded by Thor665, thirded by PeregrineV
      
    • Thor665, nominated by Robocopter
      
    • CrashTextDummie in NY136: The Death of RC, nominated by mastin2, seconded by Amrun, thirded by Iecerint
      
    • LordChronos, nominated by ToastyToast, seconded by Andrius.

[mykonian]

introduction.

I'd like to nominate Empking for Best setup or best role (whatever seems to fit this the best) for his setup in mini 1097: simple mafia, or the role of the mafia don

This role allowed him to have a near vanilla nine player game, which balanced itself. With that I mean that if the town was doing well, they would have it a little bit more difficult then normal, and if they had trouble they would get it a bit easier. This, without actually making it the best play to mislynch (as they would still be better off if they tried to lynch succesfully). The game was perfectly balanced, and this all makes it a extra-ordinary mafia setup. The role that made it all possible, the mafia don which had a weak heart, was a brilliant idea.

[q21]

Second Empking

Never thought I'd be supporting Emp getting a scummy, but I read most of the game and the role PMs at the end and I think he deserves it.

[gandalf5166]

Third

I think it should be a role, if only so that CEBM can still win best setup.

[Nachomamma8]

Nth Empking

(role)

[xRECKONERx]

Nominate DTMaster for Don Corleone

for Reckamonic's Ocarina of Time

He had everyone completely fooled, used the mechanics to organize a masterful plan, ALL WHILE keeping the confirmed masons alive, just for a challenge. He seriously blew me away with his play this game.

BTW, what is the General Discussion Award?

[Kdub]

2nd DTM for Don Corleone

[DrippingGoofball]

Heck, DTM fooled her own buddies at the very end.

Thirded.

[DTMaster]

I should change my gender. I'm a he!

[Faraday]

Yeah, that's an error. I nominated him for Best Replacement, Best Performance and Don Corleone ("Most Cunning Manipulation").

I hope they get to fix that.

P sure Don Corleone is just for Mafia performances, hence the seperation for the 3rd party award.

[Ythan]

Nominate Reckamonic for Smooth Operator

in Reckamonic's Ocarina of Time Mafia

The most complex game I've ever played and it went start to finish without a single hitch that I can recall. Someone else come up with a better blurb.

[diddin]

Nominate Reckamonic for Smooth Operator

in Reckamonic's Ocarina of Time Mafia

The most complex game I've ever played and it went start to finish without a single hitch that I can recall. Someone else come up with a better blurb.

seconding this and whatevering DTM's nomination

[mothrax]

second third and nth

Oot
Even with a questionable endgame it still went off exceedingly well, especially since with all of the redirection it had the opportunity to go so badly

[Ythan]

Let us not speak of the endgame. This is why I only nominated for Smooth Operator.

[gandalf5166]

Nominate DTMaster for Don Corleone

for Reckamonic's Ocarina of Time

He had everyone completely fooled, used the mechanics to organize a masterful plan, ALL WHILE keeping the confirmed masons alive, just for a challenge. He seriously blew me away with his play this game.

BTW, what is the General Discussion Award?

Seconded

I was 100% convinced he was town until the mods TOLD me he was scum. And then I cried, because I knew town would lose.

[Ythan]

I knew town could still win with DTMscum. I didn't know town was fucked until I heard about MODscum.

[gandalf5166]

I knew town could still win with DTMscum. I didn't know town was fucked until I heard about MODscum.

Yes, but only because he CLAIMED scum.

[Katsuki]

I knew town could still win with DTMscum. I didn't know town was fucked until I heard about MODscum.

Yes, but only because he CLAIMED scum.

No. DTM was confirmed scum the moment ythan claimed.

[Katsuki]

Nominate Reckamonic for Smooth Operator

in Reckamonic's Ocarina of Time Mafia

The most complex game I've ever played and it went start to finish without a single hitch that I can recall. Someone else come up with a better blurb.

seconding this and whatevering DTM's nomination

Thirded

[xRECKONERx]

Can I just say that finding replacements for 100+ page games was nigh impossible >.>

[Mr. Flay]

Yes, yes you can.

[gandalf5166]

I knew town could still win with DTMscum. I didn't know town was fucked until I heard about MODscum.

Yes, but only because he CLAIMED scum.

No. DTM was confirmed scum the moment ythan claimed.

Oh, was he? I must have skimmed over that part. Why was he again?

[tanstalas]

Just noticed Dram is nominated 3x for Most enjoyable game, if he doesn't take it I will be a sad panda

[Ythan]

I knew town could still win with DTMscum. I didn't know town was fucked until I heard about MODscum.

Yes, but only because he CLAIMED scum.

He seems to have made some sort of mistake though. I'm still not exactly sure what happened.

[xvart]

Nominate Ythill's Of Rogues and Curses for best flavor

due to the obvious research and integrated roles and flavor scenes.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 23&t=15748