Mini 684: Quacks and Masons Mafia- Game Over

[Porochaz]

why?

[Porochaz]

ok my thoughts on day 1 without looking at the rest and deliberately avoiding the first post:

Rofl is scum or clammy is
as clammy was lynched, rofl is obvscum
almost all his posts day 1 were terrible
What the worst thing was that everyone chose to target springlullaby, could someone explain what possible reason there was for that? It wasted doc protections etc. Particularly because I didnt fund springlullaby scummy at all but nevertheless it was a free kill for the scum providing she wasnt,(which turned out to be the case).
The best idea was to hypodoc by far.

Reading day 2

[Porochaz]

Day 2

There is quite an interesting dynamic between rofl and militant
Pacman is beginning to annoy me, which is interesting, in games together it would usually be a lot earlier.
RBT is not looking good early today
Good catch with Sun I personally didnt notice.

Day 3...

[Porochaz]

Right having read day 3, I think its quite clear there is a rofl-militant connection.

As for what should happen, I am the quack I will reinforce pacmans stupid claim. Really he has played terribly. Now my plan would be for the masons to claim. We lynch militant, the doc remains unclaimed (because it would be useless) and protects one of the masons. This will force the remaining scum to kill me or the doc (as it will be obvious to him) I wont target anyone tonight. If we're wrong we know who the scum is on the final day.

Of course thats only if you believe Im really a quack. Which I am. I idiotically targeted springlullaby night 1 and even more stupidly I targetted dattebayo night 2.

Im not sure of the vote count currently so will not place a vote but it is effectively on militant.

[Porochaz]

Well doctor was the only thing you possibly could have claimed. So it really doesnt help you. Considering the claiming things happening I think the best thing to do now is massclaim.

First I want to know what your positions on me is.

[Porochaz]

This should be the plan for an easy town win.

Masons should claim. Militant should be lynched, even if you are a doctor it doesnt matter now. If militant shows us scum we have won. If militant shows up town then the quack targets the last non-mason. If my night action (or if your not convinced Im the quack) the quacks night action goes through above the scums then the scum dies, town has won. If the scum kill goes over the quacks kill then I (or the quack) dies in the night, 3 players left, the 2 masons are confirmed town and lynch the remaining scum. If scum chooses to kill a mason during the night then the quack will kill the scum.

Providing we know who the masons are this is an auto win for the town.

[Porochaz]

so masons need to claim now

[Porochaz]

Damnit. I still recommend we carry along the same lines though, if it comes down to it (which I doubt) the remaining mason can decide between myself and the other person

[Porochaz]

Thats what I was saying in 491

[Porochaz]

I dont know what 486 has to do with anything, I think there's a strong connection between you and roflcopter. Most of it coming from him so its not something you can defend. That is main reason no. 1, main reason no. 2 is that your a doctor, you can afford to be lynched at this point. The people who arent are the masons. I think we're on quite a safe bet with you. I currently have no problem with jazz's voting pattern as we decide what to do.

[Porochaz]

Net, why are you voting Porochaz?

I think he's the last scum, but he has given me a pro-town vibe since he replaced in...

I can see the logic behind a mass claim, but I don't think it's the best option atm.

why not? Our chances improve greatly with a massclaim. Without a massclaim if we hit town today, and scum hit mason in the night then its going to be a flip of a coin, we need as much info as we can now.

[Porochaz]

no its not, they have to say doctor no matter what.

[Porochaz]

no its not, they have to say doctor no matter what.

if there is a claim that is. If there isnt they have the choice of saying either.

[Porochaz]

Sigh... then it turns into a guessing game... if we claim then it actually involves skill...

[Porochaz]

Ok ive thought about this. Im now 50-50 about the mass claim. Time to lynch militant I think

vote militant

[Porochaz]

Because my plan only worked if I could act as a vig, which I cant because I cant kill scum. It doesnt matter now whether the masons claim or not, im indifferent.

[Porochaz]

Urgh... not what I need atm. I will decide later tonight hopefully. It would be useful instead of both players shouting "your scum" to give me reasons why the other person is scum and they aren't. I have an idea who Im going to vote for but it would be unwise to until the reread.

[Porochaz]

Thanks Jazz, I apologise for taking so long 3 of my other games are at deadline and Ive just taken on modding a second mini theme. I would like Netlava to respond/make a case for Jazz though.

[Porochaz]

Wow apologies my birthday got in the way of this game. You are on my list of things to do today, although Im quite sure already.

[Porochaz]

Reading when I wake up. Im sorry Ive been bogged down with work. I have 2 days of uni this week though so its all good.

[Porochaz]

ok this vote is mainly for the following reason, for the voting patterns to be correct I would of needed RBT and raider to have thrown suspicion on each other to misdirect scum, they didnt. As far as Im aware Jazzy RBT and raider never looked at each other making Jazzys story ring true. This what pushed me to

vote Netlava

however I was always fairly sure I would do this. Netlava hope your scum, good game people.

[Porochaz]

You could tell me...

[Porochaz]

If you were town you would of said well done, not drum roll...

[Porochaz]

Yes! I want to go to bed...

Ok, you know what, Im going to stop bullshitting, im the last remaining scum, fooled you!

[Porochaz]

Ok Im telling you I am scum, I felt like playing the day out longer for the laughs. You;ll find that I do that as scum in endgame. Netlava is the quack.

[Porochaz]

1)- How much did you enjoy this game compared to other mafia games you have played on mafiascum or elsewhere?

Its been good in comparison, I usually dont do open games and was suprised that I enjoyed it more than I thought I would

2)- Did you enjoy the roles in the game including doctors, quacks and masons?

This game suits the simpleness. Therefore its fine

3)- Do you think the set-up was equally fair for the town and the mafia?

Felt it was slightly in the towns favour. However it was close and I dont balance games so...

4)- Where/how do you think the game could've been improved?

I dont know, this game personally I have a few suggestions. The game in general no.

5)- Could you play in another game involving quacks and masons?

Maybe open game not large, this is because its better suited as a smaller game, I think it could get fairly repetitive for those involved if lasted longer.

Now the reason I ask this is because this was meant to be my last game here and to finish off by modding one game. However since I enjoyed modding this one so much I might mod another quacks and masons normal with around 14-17 players

IF

I get enough intrest.



Ok now for anyone intrested here are the night choices

Night 1-
militant protects springlullaby
light-kun protects springlullaby
porochaz

pacman281292

at the time protects/KILLS springlullaby
Dattebayo protects springlullaby
Netlava tracks Jazzmyn

sotty7

at the time
Mafia kills light-kun

Night 2-
porochaz

pacman281292

at the time protects/KILLS Dattebayo
Netlava tracks porochaz

pacman281292

at the time
Mafia do not submit kill

Night 3-
militant protects riceballtail
mafia kills raider8169

Night 4-
mafia kills riceballtail

Still to come from me
- my personal summary of the game
- The story behind the setup