Mini 964: Another Story - Over!

[RealityFan]

Hey guys, reading through, will post in a bit if I don't get distracted.

[RealityFan]

First off I'll random

Unvote Vote: Deer

because I replaced into two of his games.

Unvote

It seems I missed RVS.

As for Red Star's questions:
1. I'd prefer a faster paced game with discussion, but that doesn't seem to be an option. I'd say a slow-paced game with discussion, because I don't want any quick-lynches happening.
2. It's a logic game, trying to figure out who can possibly be scum with who, and what is suspicious and what isn't.
3. Neither is good, there has to be SOME information to lynch on. However, a random lynch would be better than a No Lynch, because it has a small chance of catching scum, and gives a little information.
4. No, but it's not a good argument.
5. A very small scum-tell, nothing to base a case off of, especially if they had good reasoning.
6. I don't really know how to classify my play. I guess it's kind of laid-back; if I see something that doesn't seem right, I'll post about it.

My thoughts on players so far

Chevre
- Not much to go on, has done very little to contribute.

Deer
-The unvote on your first RVS vote seemed unnecessary. There were two votes on yabba, with seven needed to lynch. A little pressure never hurt anybody.

Dr.Cyanide
-Only thing to go on is your vote on Empking, which seems to only be because he was trying to scum-hunt.

Elias_the_thief
-A little to quick to jump on yabba to me in post 23.

Empking
-It seems like your initial argument on yabba was WIFOM, because you were trying to guess what he would do as scum.
-Why were you suspicious of Dr. Cyanide's OMGUS, but not mine/Cuet's?
-Other than that, you have been trying to scum-hunt a lot, so that earns you some town points.

Jag Johan
- I don't like how he asked questions right after VB told him it was the pro-town thing to do.
- Also seems to be going with the other two popular suspicions, Emp and Yabba, not really providing any of his own reasoning.

Red Star
-Asked questions at start of game, and information is always good.
-Voted Yab without providing much reasoning. If it was a pressure vote, don't say it was a pressure vote, it ruins the point. :/

sorasgoof
-Absolutely nothing to go on. At all. I know CoD is fun and all, but pay attention to this game a little more.

Thief
-You've only discussed your thoughts on yabba, I'd like to hear your thoughts on some others.

VibeBox
-Made valid arguments so far. Haven't noticed anything scummy. So far-town read.

yabbaguy
-I haven't really seen anything scummy from you, but as Thief said, I'd like to see some of your thoughts on others, since you've been forced to only defend yourself up to this point.

All that said and done, I'm going to

Vote: sorasgoof

.
This vote will come off when you:
A) Get replaced
or
B) Post

original

thoughts on people in the game.

[RealityFan]

@Jag
Why vote for RedStar if he isn't one of your top two suspects?
As a matter of fact, why

is

yabba your second suspect? You didn't give any reasoning...

[RealityFan]

And I'm beginning to agree with you, depending on Jag's answers to my questions.

[RealityFan]

Wow, we need a lot of prods/replacements. Dx

*pokes mod*

Vote Jag

Lurking now. Either that or they abandoned the game. Either is a scum-tell. :/

As for RS's post, what exactly qualifies a post to be fluff? Don't see anything suspicious about the post itself though.

[RealityFan]

Unvote

Please claim Jag. Just don't want someone to hammer before the claim.

[RealityFan]

Mod, I unvoted soras.
Hope the prods speed the game up DX

Right, sorry. I really need to start paying more attention to these things.

[RealityFan]

@SSBF
Good post, haven't read it's entirety, but I'll respond to my part now.

As for the contradiction, I really just said that I wouldn't take it off in order to put some pressure on them to post. Once I realized that they weren't going to no matter how many votes they had on them, I voted someone else.

[RealityFan]

The only real point I made is that I didn't like RealityFan asking for JJ to claim after he unvoted and made him just L-2.
---
I did that so someone wouldn't quick-hammer him before we got a claim. I still wanted to vote him, just was taking precautionary measures.

[RealityFan]

Thief isn't reading.

?

[RealityFan]

Mod:

I'm going to be away the next three days.

I see that Pie is town

What?

and he has shown me the error of my ways. If he thinks Yabba is as much of a fail wagon as I am (which I am) then I'll bow down to his experience.

Unvote;
Vote: SSBF
WARNING L-1

To be honest I took my vote off him because I saw he posted a few walls and figured that anyone that actually POSTS in this game was worth keeping around. I now see what Pie is talking about with the defensiveness though.

Seems like buddying to me/a quick-swap. Didn't seem to need that much convincing.

Post 216 seems weird too...

Note to self: Avoid replacing into a scummy slot until you become more experienced at Mafia.

That was exactly my reaction when I was scum last game. o.o

Vote and Hamma: SSBF

For both that comment and JJ's previous scumminess.