Okay, in catching up, several things struck me as strange.
(Also, if you read this thread while listening to this song, it's surprisingly fitting:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q1YABGdai5k)
Nathanael wrote:2.)horrordude0215: I find it legitimate to try and start a wagon early. nothing else there, so null-tell
4.)Erinyes: nothing to comment on.
8.)Mitsuru Kirijo: Nothing really scummy or townish to note. What she says feels genuine, but I think she would post the same thing regardless of alignment. so null-tell
9.)bv310: Nothing to commento on. null-tell
First thing I want to comment on, what's the difference between these? Since you have basically the same comment for all 4, why are three of us null-tells, while Erin gets no opinion whatsoever? To me, this looks a lot like someone trying to avoid giving a concrete opinion. Whether on purpose or by accident, this is something I need to keep an eye on.
Next up, Slowsilver's 82. Meta excuses are not valid. You took an opportunity to throw down a completely pointless statement about something that has absolutely no bearing on the game. To me, meta excuses deserve rope (/bitterness about a recent game), and this is no different.
Then we come to the scummiest thing so far. Kanashimi's 85. His argument against Neto is, quite frankly, bizarre. It's full of WIFOM and fluff (also mixed metaphors, but that may be a language thing), and ultimately tries to argue that Neto is scum because only scum would defend another player (who has to be their scumbuddy), which is, quite frankly, a gigantic logical fallacy.
vote: Slowsilver
And coming in a close second for sheer vote-worthiness, we come to Nexus. He throws down an EXTREMELY weak Parama vote, then backpedals instantly once someone questions him. Then he throws up his
awesome
opinion list
which does nothing except say he finds just about everybody town-y or null, except Neto (who he finds scummy for disturbingly weak reasons.)
So yeah, TL;DR: I want either Slowsilver or Nexus dead today, and then we can go from there.
