Mini 1091 Mafia Mania -- Game Over

[werewolf555]

welcome gentlemen

[werewolf555]

and beefster, your mafia game is over

[werewolf555]

Iso Beefster:
1) confirm, nothing wrong with this, perhaps too simple
2) boberz summed up your argument "Beefster surely if anything I was overattacking? How can I be overdefensive in attacking someone?
Fail accusation."
3) Don't really see where he is going here.
4) Assault based on his reaction to the votes on him. However the logic here is bad.
5) Claims that it is chainsaw what he didn't like. Boberz counters this point however.
6) Assumes that boberz thinks he is scummy. Possible over-reaction.
7) Claims that he hasn't really read pages 2 and 3 when he clearly has to make his point against boberz. LAL anyone?
8) I don't really get this.
9) Valid point. Could be start of possible band-wagon.
10) Tells boberz to be specific when he hasn't been.
11) 1. legit point. 2. Ok.. 3. I disagree, anti-town and scum are two somewhat related things.
12) meme use instead of analysis
13) 1. ok 2. He did call him scummy many times before 3. Telling us your scum-hunting strategy.
14) Asks what he is hiding, wants claim.
15) Doesn't want claim. Major contradiction right here.
16)ok
17) Ouch, this is bad. 1. He might get night killed, but if he is scum, it will turn out better. 2. Realized he made a scum-slip, trying to hide from it. 3. Wants more answers from brokenscraps. 4. Seems like a clear cut argument against him, but beefster waves it away. 5. You didn't think the full claim was unnecessary

before

. You said

possible

.
18) Please excuse Beefster while he tries to backpedal away.
19) Dekes had reasoning there.
20) major WIFOM. Scum-tell?
21) That could be seen as having not too much time. Active lurking is when you post a lot, that doesn't mean anything.

His contradictions and bad excuses make me feel that he is scum.
VOTE: Beefster

[werewolf555]

Everyone says that I am scum.
Why?
Generally people should not be judged by their predecessors actions.

[werewolf555]

You want contradictions?

Just let me do my thing for one night and if I am alive you lynch me fast. No argument from me.

Cut the crap. What are you hiding?

He wants to see his role.
However,

]There's no need for him to claim at this point. He's softclaimed a power role and that's enough. I just want him to stop his "I hate having a power role" crap. If he hates it so bad, why doesn't he replace out instead of screwing with the game?

He tries to backpedal away from it, obvious contradiction right there.
Also, when you said

And what boberz said.

, I thought you meant this as well

Of course you are scum unfortuanately

[werewolf555]

- After his predecessor is being called scum by two persons (and one of 'em was a misunderstanding), he immediately resorts to that awfully scummy "Don't judge me by my predecessor"

Actually, when you said

@werewolf
Welcome!

And what boberz said.

I thought you meant

Can I ask you to sum up your main bif of case (contradictions particularly) with a couple of quotes and such like please.

I am not a massive fan of PBPAs without exlanation afterwards.

But I like your entry.

Of course you are scum unfortuanately.

(I am going to post tonight or tomorrow morning, my time)

I think that clears up my response.
In addition, you vote me using logic that others "already used" and not being in depth enough. Then you snub me after. This seems like rather poor reasoning.
My ideas on Moose
- he seems quite fed up with the game, but is now determined to kill his harrasers
- however since he is not bothered, I believe he might be terrorist or 1-shot vig
- perhaps we should wait for night to get a confirmed townie

[werewolf555]

no.

Love the fucking insight. Way to detail your thoughts.

[werewolf555]

How about no?
It really bothers me that you have only been voting me based on what Hiraki has done.
Also, the only other person that voted me hasn't been on in some time.
Also Seeks had some blatant sheeping

*insert facepalm pic of your choice in here*

Unvote; Vote: moose

Moose, replace out.

Dekes, dont let him annoy you, moose will die in this game at some point. Werewolf might not we need to get rid of werewolf today.

Right after my paragraph. Can you fucking believe that?
If he's a vig though rather than 3rd party or scum he will become a liability rather sooner than later.

Unvote; Vote: Werewolf

This is quite obvious sheeping.
After boberz says that he should change his vote, Dekes does, even though his statement seems to contradict itself. It seems like he is following someones orders.

In addition
this is what he said at first

This moose alive to test him idea,

wont work

. He could be an anti town killing role, he could be a pro town killing role who breaks his promises (i have seen this before), he could be anything testing him will get us nowhere. I will prbably now move to a mosse lynch rather than a beefy lynch, just no quite getting the beefy stuff.

He suggests that we lynch Moose first because there is no way of finding out.

Hello, town wake up. It wont work, even if the right person dies we cant prove whether moose is town or not, but we wake up tomorrow with some dead people. Whats the point other than meaning we cant evaluate as much from today.
ust everyone wagon werewolf now please. That is all you need to do. Let's not set moose a little task. If there is a vig out there hit him. If he is a vig he should hit the most scummy player (probs beef but mariyta if werewolf is scum). Fine done, whateer happens moose is considered as the lynch the next day.

I mean, it's not like you are starting to bandwagon me already.
Scum this game is boberz, beefster, and substrike
Beefster is being defended by you, you claim to "not understand" his wagon
Substrike blatantly sheeped you.
Leading me to believe you are scum. However, this hinges on beefster being scum.

[werewolf555]

Edit: Said Substrike and Seeks instead of Dekes

[werewolf555]

Also I nascent aheeped anything this game

please clarify

[werewolf555]

Conflicted between him and Beef, but his later play is

just as bad

.

In this quote, it sounds that I was not as bad as beefster, but because of my later play I appeared just as scummy. Would it not make more sense for you to lynch the person who has been scummy all the time?

[werewolf555]

I wouldn't be so sure about that.
If you look at the reasons for voting me, they are relatively weak compared to the reasons for voting Beefster.

[werewolf555]

that's why i'm suggesting we vote beefster

[werewolf555]

Bah! go town