Open 9 - Basic Twelve Player (Game Over!) - before 400

[Fircoal]

Ripley brings up a really good point. Battlemage has some reasons to be scum. Though, I think he just said that as a joke. I also argee about the bad logic, so just to see how he ressponds

Vote: Battlemage

[Fircoal]

Ripley brings up a really good point. Battlemage has some reasons to be scum. Though, I think he just said that as a joke. I also argee about the bad logic, so just to see how he ressponds

Vote: Battlemage

I just watched a newbie vote protown just to see how the protown responds.
I find this particular vote as scummy.

If Battle Mages vote was serious he looks scummy to me. I still have the feeling it wasn't. I mean c'moon who seriously thinks MC could be town?

I want to see what Battlemage responds. WE can't be sure if Battlemage is protown or not, and right now he is our best lead.

[Fircoal]

Fircoal's jumping on the Battlemage wagon seems a little opportunistic to me. Does anyone else think so?

I'm not trying to jump on a wagon, it's just that he is the most scummy looking at this present point.

[Fircoal]

I think I'm beginning to believe that Battlemage is not scum. Even though, he did claim too early.

Unvote: Battlemage

I don't think any one esle is that scummy.

Also, I didn't jump on the bandwagon, because of nothing, I thought, Ripley's post was good, and argeed with it.

[Fircoal]

WEll, I argee about the bad logic, now that I look at it. It doesn't really add anything to the discussion of what happened. Battlemage has done some bad logic, through, this whole game.

[Fircoal]

WEll I see that there wasn't any difference, about the other posts but 1 thing added that really didn't add much importance. I argeed about the bad logic, and thought he was the scummiest so that's why I made my vote that way.

[Fircoal]

because Lowell seems happy to go for Masterchief, i can assume he is not Mafia.
Therefore i change my vote to Lowell, in an attempt to save a citizen.

1) This bad logic. But I think I got confused with the fact that I thought, he said Lowell is not scum, and he had no reason for Lowell not being mafia, when he only posted one thing. Then he votes Lowell. Which got my confused. I think I got the meaning wrong.

[Fircoal]

I'm here, I'm looking at the game and it doesn't seem like Andrew S. is scummy. Though, people are bringing up a good point about IH, but I don't think there is enough proof to lynch him.

[Fircoal]

I'm here, I'm looking at the game and it doesn't seem like Andrew S. is scummy. Though, people are bringing up a good point about IH, but I don't think there is enough proof to lynch him.

You can choose people who others don't feel like wagoning aswell.
I'm so so happy coz today I found the scum. Liking my vote.

I don't want to wagon, I just don't see much proof on anybody in this game to lynch, I just think that IH, seems to be the most scum like.

[Fircoal]

Not really, what's why I haven't been posting, and I think there are other people too that haven't been posting.

[Fircoal]

Ripley wanting a fast lynch is what a scum would want.

Vote: Ripley

[Fircoal]

3. Continuing the day would presumably lead to more bandwagons and more claims. By lynching at this stage we avoid any more townie claims and. most importantly, avoid outing the cop. This is really an argument for a prompt lynch rather than a lynch of BM specifically, but since he's my preferred candidate it is also by extension an argument for lynching him.

Also, here he points out that continuing the day would be bad.

Fos: IH

[Fircoal]

3. Continuing the day would presumably lead to more bandwagons and more claims. By lynching at this stage we avoid any more townie claims and. most importantly, avoid outing the cop. This is really an argument for a prompt lynch rather than a lynch of BM specifically, but since he's my preferred candidate it is also by extension an argument for lynching him.

Also, here he points out that continuing the day would be bad.

Fos: IH

An "FOS" on IH? Avoiding placing the vote, are we?

IH and Fircoal are scum. Man, I'm so smart.

It's an FOS, because I voted Ripley because he seems more like scum then IH does. It still seems that Ripley wanted a fast lynch. Ripley said that having a longer discussions is bad, and having everyone point out who is suspisous is bad too. That's what I got from one of your newest posts, and to me more discussion is good. It gives us many possibitlies to consider. It gives us more proof before we lynch. You just don't want the discussion to go onto your scum buddies.

FOS: Lowell

Lowell, why are you pushing for IH, so much? It's looking like you want a fast lynch too.

[Fircoal]

Lowell is the 2nd most scum like, after Ripley, I'll give him a chance to defend himself.

[Fircoal]

The scumgroup of the day is AndrewS and Lowell.

Votes on either would be appreciated.

Is that the same AndrewS as this:

I'm fairly certain AndrewS is town by the way. All votes should be off him, look over his posts in isolation, he dropped an extremely strong town tell.

?

Very interesting. But what were the post #'s for those posts.

[Fircoal]

Game 298 was a page 2 day 1 lynch, that I was in. But I do not want to head down that road again.

[Fircoal]

Newbie 298 was a page 2 day 1 lynch, that I was in. But I do not want to head down that road again.

Sorry, that's Newbie 298

[Fircoal]

@TCS Time out! You are convinced IH is scum. And now you've added Shadowlurker to the list. But, instead of keeping your vote on a "scum" with 4 votes on him, close to getting convicted, you unvote and move your vote to the "scum" with no votes on him?

Whats wrong with this picture?

Because SL deserves my vote... though, you've got a point. We should lynch IH first to validate my theory.

unvote, vote: IH

Your changing your vote when you got pressured too.

FOS: TCS

[Fircoal]

I'm extremely wary of the way TCS is jumping through hoops held by Akbar.

FOS: both of them

Scum buddy leading scum buddy.

FOS SV

for framing.

You conveniently left out the part about me threatening to lynch TCS if IH is town.

Why isn't IH lynched yet?

Ok, I'll help ya bandwagon. Of course, if he turns out to be town, this combined with my earlier suspicion of you, will confirm your scum.

Vote IH

That post is so suspicious.

Fos: Akbar

[Fircoal]

Oh, come on, we all know in our hearts, that Ripley is scum.
Maybe, Lowell is his other scum, with Akbar
Ripley/ Lowell

Just think Lowell has tried to keep all suspicion away from Ripley and Akbar, with his unexplained suspicions.

[Fircoal]

Ripley, Ripley is the most like scum. Now he brings another person up, trying so hard to get a lynch while yet appearing innocent. Lowell too, has acted scummy, and trying to defend his fellow scum, and counter claim.

[Fircoal]

LAWL, have you even read the last few pages?

Not only that, but you have now entered the realm of lurker hunting. = )

Ok, I'll give you a pass for being ill. Now focus on the second part of what I wrote. What have you contributed to the town?

When did he say he was still ill?

Ripley, Ripley is the most like scum. Now he brings another person up, trying so hard to get a lynch while yet appearing innocent. Lowell too, has acted scummy, and trying to defend his fellow scum, and counter claim.

I really don't see what you're seeing.

Ripley first had his scummy response on Bm, and now he sees it as a lost cause. So he's trying to pin the blame on someone else, and try to keep the suspicion away from him by keeping him vote on BM, so he's not called a vote hopper. He really wants the day to end.

[Fircoal]

Ripley is always appearing so useful. Framing more innocents is a good way to play when you are not even changing your vote along with your case.

He's done the same thing in another game, I think, I could be wrong.

[Fircoal]

Ok, I'll give you a pass for being ill. Now focus on the second part of what I wrote. What have you contributed to the town?

May I repeat. Have you even read the last few pages?

Are we playing the question game?

What do you think?

[Fircoal]

Should I

FOS: Fircoal

?

Why should you?

[Fircoal]

Ok, I'll give you a pass for being ill. Now focus on the second part of what I wrote. What have you contributed to the town?

May I repeat. Have you even read the last few pages?

Are we playing the question game?

Why aren't you, or your scumbuddy, lynched yet?

I have a scumbuddy?

who says you don't?

[Fircoal]

I'm still set on Lowell and Ripley being scum, but since Lowell has been protecting Akbar, I'd have to say that he is a bit more scummy then IH.

Vote: Akbar

[Fircoal]

It's all down to Spectrumvoid

[Fircoal]

Lowell your second quote of my doesn't prove anything. Just because I think that the lynch vote is in Spectrumviod's hands doesn't prove anything. And if I was scum, wouldn't I vote IH, because less suspicion would be on me.

[Fircoal]

SL, why are you voting me? Nothing in your post besides your vote even mentions me.

Lowell, why wouldn't a townie say what I said in post 369. I said it and I'm pro-town. Also, just because I think one person his more scum then the other, and I'm not too sure, how is that scummy.

To all of those who trust Ripley:
How in the world can you trust Ripley?

[Fircoal]

Akbar, that is a good case on Bm.

Fos: Battle Mage

[Fircoal]

Akbar scum appears to be alive.

Trying to get others lynched instead of defening yourself. you didn't even post your reasons. that's kind of scummy.

I voted Azkar because he was more scummy at the time. How was I to know that IH was scum, I'm not the cop or the mafia. I voted based on who I thought was more scummy out of the 2. The 2 people who are scum could of been on the IH wagon.

[Fircoal]

Lowell not paying attention to the setup is disconcerting but a point in his favor.

Vote: Fircoal

And how does that result in my vote?

[Fircoal]

BAH!

We all know who'll win in the end. (scum)

[Fircoal]

Yay town! And thank you guys for saving me from hours of rereading for the second day in a row.

(waits for Fircoal to arrive and blame TCS and IH...)

Na, It's not their fault we lost. I will take some of the blame, but overall gg town. One mistake was voting Akbar when I knew that the lynch probably wouldn't go though. I probably made other mistakes too.