Open 11 - Pie C9 (Game over) - before 400

[Fircoal]

Vote: Ernie

. That's for voting for me.

[Fircoal]

Nope, nothing.

[Fircoal]

Are you scum?

Scum please tell as if your scum.

[Fircoal]

My was because you voted for me.

[Fircoal]

I think you only have 2 votes on you Ernie

[Fircoal]

That drunken kangaroo looks like its ready to kill someone... -_-'

Not unless you steal it's beer.

*steals the Kangaroo's beer.*

[Fircoal]

Mmmm, maybe we could have a random lynch(jk)

[Fircoal]

Maybe we are all town set up to lynch eachother by scummy mod!

That must be it, but I can't vote to lynch the mod, or esle I'll get modkilled.

[Fircoal]

Maybe we are all town set up to lynch eachother by scummy mod!

That must be it, but I can't vote to lynch the mod, or esle I'll get modkilled.

No you won't don't worry we can safely lynch the mod.

Vote: Mod

Go to know.

Vote: Mod

[Fircoal]

So let's not Walk to Jersulam guys.

Yeah it's so much easier to go by car.
Why Walk with big W?

Excatly.
*get's into a car*

[Fircoal]

Vote Count

Twito (2): Nightfall, Shadowlurker
Nightfall (2): Ripley, Patrick
Fircoal (1): Ernie
Ernie (1): Fircoal
Shadowlurker (1): Twito

Not Voting: No one

7 alive, 4 to lynch.

What happened to my mod vote.
ANd I forgot to

Unvote: Ernie

[Fircoal]

Any votes for me will be ignored

AW, fine.

Unvote: Mod

[Fircoal]

...yeah okay... Pat, I liked how you were thinking in our last game, eventhough we were on opposite sides. If you can think up some kind of idea to put into action in this game, I'm more than

not

willing to follow your lead.

So we're still going nowhere.

I think this post by Nightfall is the closest anybody's been to acting suspicious. Offering to follow another player on the basis of his play in another game - that's slightly odd if for all you know he could be scum in this one. Also there's something a bit lazy and responsibility-dodging about it. Probably if there was a good plan, somebody would have thought of it by now, so any plan devised by Patrick is unlikely to be great. None of this is such a big deal, but everyone's being so careful still, there's not really been anything else to comment on.

But I was voting Nightfall anyway, so it doesn't change anything,

HE said NOT willing, so it doesn't look that scummy to me, more just a post in a joking matter. Though Patrick's switch is kind odd, but we don't want a bandwagon lynch, so it isn't that odd. Just think it's something worthy of notice.

[Fircoal]

HE said NOT willing, so it doesn't look that scummy to me, more just a post in a joking matter. Though Patrick's switch is kind odd, but we don't want a bandwagon lynch, so it isn't that odd. Just think it's something worthy of notice.

Fircoal, you misunderstood it. He said he was more than not willing - that means he is willing. What do you find kinda odd about my switch?

O, yes, I guess I didn't understand it. I find it odd, that once claiming comes up you switch, also that if you thought he was mafia, why didn't you want him lynched.

[Fircoal]

Fircoal and Patrick are both not voting, therefore, they are both scum.

What type of logic is that, what if I want more proof before I vote?

[Fircoal]

Vote: Ernie

. That's for voting for me.

You didn't seem to want proof here.

And you didn't unvote through all your posts until the mod ignored your vote for him.

It was a random vote at the beginning, you don't need to vote with proof until it gets more serous. As for not unvoting, that was an accident. I meant to unvote Ernie went I voted for the mod.

[Fircoal]

Ernie, do you want a repeat of Game 298?
Regarding that, your looking a bit suspicious.

[Fircoal]

There are only 7 players in this game. 4 votes is a lynch.

[Fircoal]

I REALLY hope that isnt 4...

same here.

[Fircoal]

I REALLY hope that isnt 4...

I just checked it's only 3.

[Fircoal]

WEll, I think it's either scummy actions on Ernie's vote, or that he really is confused.

[Fircoal]

Patrick and Ripley prodded.

I'll seen both of them on other threads. hmmm.

FOS: Patrick, Ripley, Ernie, Bird1111

[Fircoal]

*shrug* Vote for me if you want to, but I'm not unvoting Nightfall, there's as many good reasons to vote for him than for voting for anyone else.

Like what?

[Fircoal]

You still didn't explain it.

[Fircoal]

Well if that's his opinion it's good reason to vote anyone. Especially ones close to lynch. Then again that opinion is completely fucked up if we were just random voting and it would be as likely to lynch town or scum based on read then town would lose all the games.

So are you saying all pro-town players should follow that strategie?

Fos: Ernie

[Fircoal]

Well if that's his opinion it's good reason to vote anyone. Especially ones close to lynch. Then again that opinion is completely fucked up if we were just random voting and it would be as likely to lynch town or scum based on read then town would lose all the games.

So are you saying all pro-town players should follow that strategie?

Fos: Ernie

I'm saying that's a terrible protown strategy which shouldn't be followed.

You couldn't tell that I was being sarcastic? I get your point. Notice my Fos.

[Fircoal]

Ripley nice post. Your probably protown.

I think Ernie and Nightfall are team scum.

[Fircoal]

Interesting. So why did Ernie place a third vote on his scumbuddy and encourage a hammer? It's not the scumteam that would come to my mind first.

To trick us, woouln't that be an excellent plan to excellent plan to not accuse either of them.

[Fircoal]

I didn't much like post 152. It felt off.

Why just my thoughts, but you do bring up a good point about why they wouldn't be scum together.

[Fircoal]

Actually I'm not so sure about Ripley after all as he seems to have tendency to make posts like that in games.

I've seen that too, so maybe it's like Yos, a null tell.

[Fircoal]

I'm curious as though why you didn't ask Nightfall anything as he has been much more inactive than me.

You're the one who said you'd reread, that's why. I did it myself so I know it doesn't take long because of the dismal lack of content. I've already commented on Nightfall's failure to contribute. And noted the total lack of response. This game really doesn't need people looking for excuses not to post.

I am willing to contribute more, but honestly I am at a little loss for ideas.

Same here.

[Fircoal]

Twito is back! WHOHOOO!! PAAARTYYY!
/me is tired and will read new posts tomorrow.. hey wait a secound..?

So, we have a party.

[Fircoal]

Prodded Ernie, Patrick, Ripley, and Shadowlurker.

And thank Twito, as if he hadn't posted, you guys would have been deadlined.

4 people.

[Fircoal]

Prodded Ernie, Patrick, Ripley, and Shadowlurker.

And thank Twito, as if he hadn't posted, you guys would have been deadlined.

4 people.

And thank Twito, as if he hadn't posted, you guys would have been deadlined.

FoS: Fircoal

for not thanking Twito.

Thank you Twito.

[Fircoal]

2 re-skimmed today this has to wait. Luckily it ain't moving anywhere. Don't expect too much from that re-skim.

I don't.

[Fircoal]

You've prodded everyone but me and Twito.

[Fircoal]

*highfives back*

Neither shall I

[Fircoal]

SL is on vacation until around next Sunday with limited access, with limited access.

I guess it's the mountains just you had an echo.

[Fircoal]

Twito and Fircoal have added nothing of any meaningful content with all these posts so there is nothing to respond to. They're just increasing the percentage of rubbish posts in the thread, which was already enormous. I already went through this game and managed to find stuff to say (post 147). It probably needs somebody else to do the same.

Already did, it died, now it's spam land. WEeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[Fircoal]

The mod has to be the mafia, what other opinion is there?

[Fircoal]

The mod has to be the mafia, what other opinion is there?

I'm sure of it but he doesn't let us vote him.
It's just logical. Anyone who knows who is all the scum in the game at this point of the game would have to be scum himself aswell.

exactly.

[Fircoal]

how can I help, I don't know. But my ideas about Ernie are the same as most, I wish the scum did something real scummy. And the scumteam thing was an idea, the praising thing was basically a copy, but with the fact he does that a lot more, is now more of a null tell.

[Fircoal]

Wait to talk about? Hmmmm

[Fircoal]

Exactly.

[Fircoal]

We can't really do anything until Ernie responds.

We could spam.

[Fircoal]

Ok, Welcome ChannelDelibird

[Fircoal]

The 1st post of mine was a joke, but I don't think I phrased the last sentence right.

My 2nd post that you quoted doesn't really prove anything, about me being scum.

The 3rd quoted post of me, I thought at the time Ripley was pro-town, which now I realize that it's a null-tell since he does it in other games. The scumteam was just an idea that I had that until disproved made sense.

[Fircoal]

Fircoal, where are you from if you don't mind my asking?

I live in the United States. And I'm from there.

[Fircoal]

The 1st post of mine was a joke, but I don't think I phrased the last sentence right.

Which is why I said it wasn't really any big factor.

My 2nd post that you quoted doesn't really prove anything, about me being scum.

What, your defense is "that proves nothing"? Tell me

why

it is not scummy at all. Of course it doesn't "prove" anything, nothing can be proved in mafia until a lynch. I was just pointing out how it could be interpreted as scummy, and your response isn't really inspiring.

The 3rd quoted post of me, I thought at the time Ripley was pro-town, which now I realize that it's a null-tell since he does it in other games. The scumteam was just an idea that I had that until disproved made sense.

No, it didn't make sense, for reasons made clear. I don't know if it's a null tell or not either...a helpful post that looks seriously at trying to find possible scumtells is always more helpful to town than scum, therefore it is always more of a town tell than scum.

2) I didn't really see anything that you said about that quote as evidence, or really something that really would be scummy.

3) What reasons were made clear that they couldn't be scum buddies. Wouldn't it be better if they were known as a group that isn't likely to be buddies together. So they furthered themselves apart. So if one of them is lynched then, the other won't be under as much suspicion. I know that trying to find scum-tells is a pro-town thing.

[Fircoal]

What I meant by that was at the time, what reasons. AFter it was disproved, then there were reasons.

[Fircoal]

I'm confused about that. Your last post doesn't make sense. It seems that you first said that you were disproved, then 5 posts later you asked what reasons there were for Nightfall/Ernie not being scumbuddies. Those two things don't make any sense together.

I gave some reasons for not thinking they're scumbuddies in my post 155.

My theory was posted on Post 152.

You disproved it on Post 155 or some post around there.

Until you disproved it, I believed in my theory.

[Fircoal]

You sure, I am you have to click a button, it can't be that easy.

[Fircoal]

Unvote, vote: Fircoal

because I've had a few bad vibes from him and CDB does seem ok at this stage.

I'm pleased that we're getting a replacement for Shadowlurker, since at the moment I don't have the slightest idea about his alignment. Twito may also need replacing since I think he's having all sorts of problems with his connection.

I'm pleased for replacements to, maybe we could get more chatter. And Patrick what about the other 4 people in the game?

[Fircoal]

Welcome, Skruffs.

[Fircoal]

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
THE LIGHT IT BURNS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Fircoal]

Fircoal on the other hand seems to have enough time to make posts, and believably enough time to make them semi meaningful, however he has chosen to more lurk in plain site, Right now he is at the top of my list.

I've been starting to do that on a lot of Mafia scum games. Sometimes, it's because of the argument or the inactivity in the thread.

[Fircoal]

^Ernie Skruffs is replacing Shadowlurker.

I agree with your suspicions of Ripley. And so the game I'm playing is called Follow the leader?

[Fircoal]

I in no way meant to defend fircoal. I think it's likely that fircoal is tagging along behind goofy twito to seem innocent - because twito is more likely than him to get lynched for spamming and such.

If I misrepped ripley, it is because I am misunderstanding the way he isportraying himself, in which case, an explanation will ease my concern and i'll continue looking elsewhere.

Twito has been acting the best so far. And also you haven't the claim which I claimed Wolf on Night 1 (or 0). (But that was after that a bit.) Also, I don't think Twito will get lynched for that.

[Fircoal]

I'm here.

My role is a townie.

[Fircoal]

GG, I was watching it sometimes, when I was dead. Wish I was there.

[Fircoal]

All the scum shoulda claimed townies.

lol, or maybe both of the scum should of claimed cop.