Mini 736 - The Masonry Game Over!

[Max]

Vote: Empking

Restaferma I was under the impression that at night (if you felt certain about somebodies alignment) you could found a masonry and invite people. I sadly am mistaken but where was I...

Yes, Empking, RestaFermata has not done anything anti-town.

[Max]

I'm at awe with the pace of this game, in short, I have now been prodded twice for the same prod! I've re-read day one and I think the following about each of these people:

RestaFermata: post 108, it seems suspicious that she used wifom in such an obvious way and no-one called her up on that
I don't really like the current, "let's lynch Reecer" attitude, I understand some things done aren't that town like, but I wouldn't say scummy.
I would like to see more of skitzer, normally his posts jump off of the page but they blended in Day 1.
Nightfall is most likely town, but I don't think I've ever seen him play as scum.

Honourable Mentions:

Caboose, mainly posts of agreement, not really providing individual arguments.
dislike some of Zwets posts, all in all it was a very disappointing day of discussion

[Max]

Wow, I return and make a post log out then an hour later Reecer votes for me, any explanations?

Zwet, from what I can tell from nightfall's play is that it isn't scummy, and definitely not vote worthy, is there any reason you feel the need to vote him other that your crap logic reasons.

[Max]

Ah, those were the days, nowadays I restrict my use of gambits.

[Max]

I disapprove of the "Reecer is going to harm town anyway" vibe I'm getting from rest's post just above. So I'm going to name one reason why we should not be lynching reecer today:

Because if he has a brain he will change his play style. If he doesn't we lynch him tomorrow.

[Max]

Reecer, You will be dead by tonight if you don't stop actively lurking

[Max]

Reecer Claim, or you will be lynched.

[Max]

I am not entirely sure about reecers claim by the looks of it he's desperate and he needs a claim to keep him alive, which is what I used to do.

[Max]

I think that he's hinting he's a cult. Not pro-town and not pro-scum. It's anti-everythingbuttown

[Max]

Say what?
He's not pro town and yet he's anti everything but town?

I mean anti-everythingbutcult

I think that reecer is lying he said he wasn't pro-town earlier and how the hell could you forget that?

Also I'm intrigued that zwet says that Reecer is town while he votes him.

[Max]

I don't think so because of the flavour there was in sign-ups

[Max]

Fos: Zwet

Reecer hasn't cared about the game full stop, never mind about being lynched

Vote: Reecer

To keep the pressure there

[Max]

Bye Bye meaning you are going to die because it's a cult?

[Max]

Interesting Jahudo brought up lylo, I find that suspicious, I'm saying this now because I don't think Darox put a scum of 3 in a game with recruiting masonry. I don't think it warrants a vote, but worthy of a fos.

I suggest someone unvotes because I think Zwet may self hammer

[Max]

Zwet who do you think is scum and why?

[Max]

I've been ill for the weekend and today so consider this is really just a filler post, I'll catch up tomorrow

[Max]

Zwet never said Reecer was confirmed town, just that he had mason recruiting powers (see: post 281). This interpretation does not sit right with me. Why did you think zwet thought Reecer was town?

Practically every post that Zwet made said something bad about Reecer but he didn't vote, I read that as him thinking Reecer was town

[Max]

@Max: Who do you find suspicious and why?

Besides zwet.

Jahudo, especially this line of his second to last post.

I'm stalling? I'm joking around that this discussion is useless and you say I'm stalling?

You have said a number of people are scummy but you aren't voting anybody or expanding on why they are scummy.

He himself has been doing exactly what he is criticising and that just reaks scum. I don't have anything against people not voting but criticising someone for something that they do themselves

FoS: Jahudo

[Max]

I'm sick of you zwet, I think you're town and you've given up on this game. Make your final post outlining your view about each person then the hammer will fall

[Max]

I want to know about that quote before I hammer, explainations?

[Max]

And why was juls posting it?

[Max]

Why the last minute change of heart?

[Max]

Hmm, I'm not entirely convinced, but I'll take your word for it.

[Max]

On the balance side of this game I would like to say I'm disappointed that it was designed in a way which a few crap town players ruin it

[Max]

If you can design a game that is "stupid townie"-proof, I'd love to see it.

If we ignore day 1 (because that's practically always random).

We had 2 shots to hit scum with no real power given to the town: these are the only 2 town powers that I can see:

A mason pair
and
confirmed townie (if recruited)

VERSUS

Night Delayed SK

VERSUS

A multiple Mason Scum
1 Goon
1 Traitor