Mini 931: Supreme Court Mafia (Game Over post 682)

[DarkLightA]

1) How much experience do you have playing Mafia?
About 4 months worth.

2) How would you describe your playstyle?
Used to be pretty anti-town as town, but I'm deciding to change it and give some extra effort from now on.

3) What do you value the most in making decisions in Mafia?
It depends. Much about if the player's just trying to blend in.

4) Do you expect the Spanish Inquisition?
?

5) Do you prefer playing as mafia or as town?
Mafia! So much fun =)

6) How many games are you playing in at the moment?
2, and modding 1

7) What do you consider to be your greatest strength as town? As mafia?
Town - active, free-thinking
Scum - tend to (at least used to) have an anti-town playstyle, so that would help disguise it

[DarkLightA]

Setup is interesting I think. The CIA agent is the serial killer obviously, but who are the mafia?

I'm sorry, where did it say that there is a serial killer?

Interesting point there, The set up has not been listed as this is not an open.... So how can Jack know the setup is interesting... unless he actually means the theme...

but yea, nothing on a SK either...

very weird post, Jack care to explain?

You're choosing to hold your comment, Jack?

[DarkLightA]

Setup is interesting I think. The CIA agent is the serial killer obviously, but who are the mafia?

I'm sorry, where did it say that there is a serial killer?

I'm still curious where you determined the CIA agent is "obviously" the serial killer?

I'm afraid you guys are on a need to know basis. And right now, you don't need to know.

You only think you do. I'm (apparently) the only one who sees that you don't.

So how do you know it's CIA?

It seems like this is from a role PM.

If you don't wish to comment there's only one thing to do =(

Vote: Jack

[DarkLightA]

Proof that it wasn't a scumslip, basically.

Not saying it was a scumslip. Saying that it's a SK-slip.

-.-

[DarkLightA]

How can there actually be a CIA agent

in the setup when the write up confirms that there isn't?

Setup is interesting I think.

The CIA agent is the serial killer obviously

, but who are the mafia?

As I said, a conversation starter.

*HEAD DESK*
*HEAD DESK*
*HEAD DESK*
*HEAD DESK*
*HEAD DESK*
*HEAD DESK*

[DarkLightA]

Dark on Jack:
Dark thought that CIA was a SKslip. Ok, that was possible. But there's no (...) [CIA agent] in the game. What is your vote now based on, Dark?

What I'm saying is that our roles have names, and I believe that Jack got a role based on Serial Killer under the name of "CIA agent".

[DarkLightA]

Guys, can't you see that Jack has practically

claimed

SK? IMHO it's a good bet.

[DarkLightA]

@DLA: why is Jack scum? In particular, which of Jack's posts benefit scumJack more than townJack?

NO NO NO NO NO!!!!
He's not SCUM! He's 3rd party SERIAL KILLER!!!

The CIA agent is the serial killer obviously, but who are the mafia?

Here, he says he has knowledge of a CIA agent in the game, who is "obviously" a SK.

So, going on, he refers to:

(...) but the only people in the room that are not justices are the two attorneys and the secret service agent.

And points to the SS agent being his SK.

So, here's my read:

Jack got a pm like this:

"You are a serial killer. Your role name is a CIA agent."

He goes on to accidentally post this in-topic.

He realizes his mistake, and keeps it "undisclosed" for a while, and then finds an excuse in the mod's post.

Understandable?

[DarkLightA]

Where did the mod state that there isn't a CIA or SK?

[DarkLightA]

DLA: Reread the thread.

I have, and can't find that flipping thing. Where has the MOD stated that there IS NOT a CIA agent or a SERIAL KILLER?

[DarkLightA]

Okay, I wouldn't think you'd base it upon that, but anyway:

"a secret service agent"

Jack interpreted THIS EXACT STATEMENT as:

"the CIA agent is obviously SK"

Now compare those to my case posted above.

[DarkLightA]

Tbh I see bub as town.

[DarkLightA]

LYNCH JACK HE'S SERIAL KILLER!

Isn't it OBVIOUS?

[DarkLightA]

Welcome camn =)

[DarkLightA]

Vote: Jack

/goes back to lurking

[DarkLightA]

Can you unkill me please, Jack?