mini 231-Daily Show with Jon Stewart Mafia Game over

[Pie_is_good]

Wow, things have started fast.

Although AniX's sanity is far from proven, I certainly think that a Blackberry lynch would be best for the town. Gives us the most info on a basically-random day 1 lynch. It's at LEAST worth a claim from BB.

Pressure

VOTE: BLACKBERRY

[Pie_is_good]

My role is arguably not that qualified to be in the game, either, so I'm willing to believe that part.

UNVOTE: BLACKBERRY

for now.

...I would like to hear the reasoning, however.

[Pie_is_good]

My role is arguably not that qualified to be in the game, either, so I'm willing to believe that part.

UNVOTE: BLACKBERRY

for now.

...I would like to hear the reasoning, however.

[Pie_is_good]

In normal person games, cops can't investigate themselves.

...Is Bob Odenkirk friends with the other guy?

Well, the way I see it, IF there is two killing groups (and there usually is) [not saying I know something here; purely speculation] , then Blackberry will be dead tomorrow. Mafia/SK or doctor, another KG would want Blackberry dead either way.

...so, I'm willing to wait on that one.

[Pie_is_good]

Ok, I'll let Blackberry officially slide. It's kinda a risky lynch at this point.

By the way, I am mildly suspicious of AniX, just because it seems like him to bust out the whole "I play by sense of smell" thing in his first forum game in awhile. I also don't see why he'd claim so early.

...but, I will

VOTE: STEVIE

, because of his last (and only) post. Adds almost no content, puts a RANDOM vote on when the game is significantly underway, and then "believes Thumper" because of me. I made no argument to believe Thumper/BB; I'm not so sure I believe Blackberry myself. Blindly following me is awesome, but scummy.

All that in 3 short sentences.


I'd also like to

officially request

that we try to refer to each other by our forum names instead of our AIM names. Contrary to popular belief, this game is not 100% people who regularily play on scumchat, so let's try to make this less confusing for them.

[Pie_is_good]

FoS: Bamboomancer, Bigger FoS: Stevie.

It really just makes this game a WIFOM. The scum could just not kill Blackberry, and we waste a lynch tomorrow. Following your plan means that no scum in their right mind would kill Blackberry tonight, and so it completely defeats the purpose of not lynching Blackberry. Blackberry staying alive means absolutely nothing.

...but, a bigger FoS to stevie for buying that logic. Seriously, he just blindly accepted what Panda said without contributing anything of his own.

I challenge you all to find an original idea of Stevie's posted in this game.

Ohh, and looking back on his 3 posts, you'll notice he goes from trusting Blackberry because of me to wanting to lynch blackberry because of panda.

I'm not buying it.

[Pie_is_good]

Stevie has done nothing to make me feel any better about him (besides voting somebody after saying they had a good defense... what the hell?).

Still waiting on the claim.

[Pie_is_good]

I think AndrewS said it best-- I seriously don't believe in a backup self-protecting doc who inherits the previous doc's abilities. That makes absolutely no sense, and doesn't make sense with the role, either.

I've heard enough.

VOTE: BLACKBERRY

[Pie_is_good]

I am indeed John Kerry, a mason

...however, I'm gonna have to guess at this point that we have 3 cultists and 1 (?) mafia. Meaning the town is in trouble, and it's certainly lynch-or-lose.

...meaning I'm not up for following a cop claim. At this point, he could have just as easily been a recruit who was either recruited tonight, or fabricated the last results.

Right now, the town is better off working WITH any scum still alive and working against the cult.

I'm not going to reveal my mason yet, and I'd recomend that my mason doesn't reveal themselves (fabricate a claim if needed).

My priority right now is to have someone take responsibility for the kill. AFTER, (and only after), we should mass-claim.

Once someone does that, I can *probably* get Pie's Masterful Plan o' Screw the Mafia/cult in action.

I have many more thoughts on the game that's probably better to leave for later.

[Pie_is_good]

I'm very close to voting AndrewS here.

You are making some VERY dangerous assumptions...

-Windslicer is NOT neccesarily telling the truth, and he could be a cultist. I'm not so sure I believe him.

-We should NOT neccesarily lynch the mafia. If we do, the cult may overwhelm the town. No assumptions until we get a plan and more claims.

If anyone would like to fess up to being the scum (or otherwise taking care of Stewie's death), I would like to work with them. The cult is the real threat to the town, IMHO.


Continue mass claiming! We need more info to go on before we can do anything here.

[Pie_is_good]

Ok, it's time for the moment you've all been waiting for...

Pie's Masteful Plan o' Screw the Mafia!

(the first)

We have 6 alive at the moment, leaving us 2 lynches.

Today, we lynch WindSlicer. If he's cult, then we did the right thing. If he's roleblocker, we know he was telling the truth, meaning the only scum left is Bamboomancer. We lynch him, town wins.

[Note: The only assumption made is that the mod didn't stick us with 3 scum and a cultist. I, personally, am fairly confident that he's not that stupid.]

Assuming Windslicer is a cultist (because otherwise, town wins so no need for discussion)...

Andrew: Your homework is to investigate Iba or Chuckelz, and tell me which one is my mason partner (proving that he's either not cult, or it's a totally broken cult that lets people keep their roles when recruited).

Everyone else: Don't do anything stupid, don't use any special abilities that completely screw up the game (such as viging people), and don't suck.

More scheming shall come tomorrow.

VOTE: WINDSLICER

[Pie_is_good]

Uuh, pass.

FOS: Anyone who cannot see that AndrewS is cult.

I hope you don't expect me to believe the mod gave us 3 Mafiosos AND a cult leader. One cult is at least as powerful as a 3-man mafia group.

Besides, he doubted Pie's Masterful Plan o' Screw the Mafia. He's

obviously

guilty.

I don't believe AndrewS or Windslicer at the moment, but I'll stick with lynching Windslicer. It's slightly safer.

At the worst, we force a NL, which forces the mafia to kill a cultist (or town and mafia would lose).

We just need 2 more votes, from the mafia and town.

There's really only 1 person I'm sure is not in the cult right now, and that's Bamboomancer. I can't even trust my mason *paranoid*

Soo, yeah. Mafia and town, unite!

(Bamboomancer: I understand your suspicions of Andrew, but we can deal with him later )

[Pie_is_good]

Yet you still don't answer my question nor recognize my request.

Your question-- It varies based on the mod, but I *think* that investigations would usually go through. No idea about cop's results, but given that we're dealing with a rolePM cop, I don't see that it influences this game.

As for recognizing your request, I thought that was made clear by the fact that I didn't unvote you. Of course you don't want to be lynched (who would?). But it's the right play for the town, and given that I think AndrewS is BSing as well, I'm not so concerned about the 3 mafia thing.