Seriously, with 12 players, probably only one mafia group - maybe also a SK, but that would mean somebody got lucky last night in a way that I don't normally associate with this film and roleblocked him or healed his victim.
Anyway, that being said,
vote: Narnianian
for jumping on Carmine so quick, and because random voting him/her was so much fun in Newbie 25, I thought I'd do it again.