Mini 459 - /cows Mafia - GAME OVER, YAY!

[Hadhfang]

Lets see what the dice say then:

Original Roll String: 1d11

1 11-Sided Dice: (5) = 5

[Hadhfang]

Random vote: Atticus

[Hadhfang]

Would it not be better for people to roll an 11 sided dice so they don't end up voting themselves?

[Hadhfang]

FoS: All math geeks

QFT


Speaking of which I have a maths exam on monday, where they shove all the maths questions you will never need to ever answer in your life apart from that exam.

[Hadhfang]

I don't hate maths geeks, I just hate the math geeks who become examiners and make up pointless problems which we will never have to solve agian in our lives.

[Hadhfang]

How can you not love set theory? I mean, it's like drugs, except free, and legal!

WTF?

HoS:xyzzy

Anyone with that mindset must be scum!

[Hadhfang]

I'm getting rather suspicious of Hadhfang for being suspicious of my ideas about set theory. If he's not afraid of the Fish Monkey God, he may have immunity from nightkills: a relatively common trait of SKs.

A suspicion that far out has to be true. Anything to say Hadhfang?

Well for a start I never voted Xyzzy, you however did, even if you did unvote.

unHoS

However, I will say this: Xyzzy, drugs are bad.

[Hadhfang]

Well that's the most bizzare reason to vote someone yet!

Unvote,OMGUS Vote: Occult

[Hadhfang]

Hadhfang, I wasn't saying I like drugs. I was saying I like set theory, and that set theory is like drugs.

So you like set theory which is like drugs t you because it's addictive?

Each to their own, i never said I had anything against set theory I said I had something against all the stuff i only ever need if I'm going to become an examiner, a maths teacher or am going to sit a maths exam. This vicious circle is a bad thing.

And Drugs are a bad thing so likening something good to drugsis a bad ting to do.

Your attempts at making us forget your antimathematical escapades are long over!

What!?! I never tried that at all!

I would liek to know why Jordan decided to random bandwagon, even thoguh the nature of this game is a very random one.

[Hadhfang]

Justifiably so. Hadhfang angered the Fish Monkey God.

WTF?

OK, shall we actually find a more serious reason to lynch someone rather than because they are rubbish at maths?

Methinks BlueZebra needs to talk a bit more, because piling on a 4th bandwagonvote seems slightly scummy to me.

[Hadhfang]

By forcing someone into a -2 (or was it -3?)

-3 i think. I had 4 votes on me.

anyway,

Unvote

That vote is a random one and hasn't proved very productive. That and it was an OMGUS vote anyway making it even less productive.

[Hadhfang]

By forcing someone into a -2 (or was it -3?)

-3 i think. I had 4 votes on me.

anyway,

Unvote

That vote is a random one and hasn't proved very productive. That and it was an OMGUS vote anyway making it even less productive.

Why not vote for someone else?

Because I don't know who to vote!

I'll throw a couple of FoS's out if that makes you happy though.

FoS:Blue Zebra
FoS: Xyzzy

[Hadhfang]

unvote, vote: Hadhfang

care to elaborate?

[Hadhfang]

OK, I've been away for a while because of exams. but I'm back now, I wasn't lurking if that is wat has made a lot of people suspiciou of me.

[Hadhfang]

I'm thinking Atticus and possible Spambot.

unFos

FoS Atticus

[Hadhfang]

Yes but him disappearing for a few days and then choosing the two people who are currently in the spotlight, so to speak, doesn't do him any favors in my eyes. He could be just as easily scared to vote for fear of a backlash.

Well I'm sorry I was away but liek I said I had exams all week and the week before.

[Hadhfang]

Well you won't get any titles changed by killing me I'm afraid.

[Hadhfang]

Atticus clearly took my comment way out of context.

Well you won't get any titles changed by

killing

me I'm afraid.

Clearly that shows that I am lynchable, but I am pro-town as well. Atticus took it way out of context, no Idea why though.

FoS:Atticus

[Hadhfang]

I didn't make a mistake, I was trying to point to Hadhfang the dumbness of his statement. Apparently, everyone understood his comment except for me.

What "dumbness of statement"? If everyone bar one person understands something how does that make the statement dumb?

[Hadhfang]

That argument is very WIFOM for one.

Next I've only been lynched once (I was town) and I remained calm about it b/c freaking out did not seem like the best thing to do for the town.

Also, Ive seen more scum freak out then town when about to be lynched. Him acting calm about is not a scum tell. Neither is it a townie tell. Its just a personality thing. Along with the fact that this is a very lurky game may add to the fact he is not taking it a seriously as usual.

Although, his calmness might be him playing WIFOM. he's acting calm because he is town, but if he is town then scum would act calm to try and be town, so acting calm is scummy...

[Hadhfang]

I don't think he's a jester. A claim that early would make people suspicious of what his motives behind it is. I think he's (Putting it nicely) a moron.

Even if he needs to get himself lynched a claim without any provoking is very suspicious. It could be that he's scum and is claiming this so we think he's a jester or something and people don't vote for him. It's a very WIFOM situation.

FoS:Panzerjager

[Hadhfang]

I'm also convinced that either way (thruth or lie) there is no real reason to keep him alive, except for the jester theory.

Which if he is a jester we all oose and suck. I would like to here him say a bit more in case we've got this all wrong and screw up royally.

HoS:panzerjager

[Hadhfang]

Firstly, Why vote spambot first, tehn change your vote?


Secondly, the nature of tis gme is a fairly random one, how do you know that if you are cop and mod has confirmed sanity that mod was being truthful?

[Hadhfang]

Well played MoS!


Whilst It woud be a good idea to leave more time for discussion what else is there to discuss at the moment?

Still, in case there is something else I'm not going to vote yet.

[Hadhfang]

Hmm, this is interesting, I wonder why they didn't target MoS, since he's claimed his role already and the blame can't be pinned on him.

[Hadhfang]

Hmm, this is interesting, I wonder why they didn't target MoS, since he's claimed his role already and the blame can't be pinned on him.

Because they assume the Doctor protected me, obviously.

That's assuming there is a doctor of course. It's not an open set-up.

[Hadhfang]

I'm still here!

I'm going to make use of this period of inactivity to go over the game again methinks. Else I'll get up to here and everyhting will have moved on by a couple of pages.

[Hadhfang]

Hmm, It seems to me that Atticus has been distancing himself from jordan a fair bit throughout the game.

Vote:Atticus

[Hadhfang]

Hmm, It seems to me that Atticus has been distancing himself from jordan a fair bit throughout the game.

Vote:Atticus

I saw no such thing. Quotes, maybe?

Very well:

Before we start lynching and random bandwagonning people who don't like set theory...

Can we get a vote count?

Page 2: This was right after jordan started a "random bandwagon" as he put it. I might be reading ito this too much, but this looks as if he doesn't want to follow Jordan's bandwagon.

Is it just me, or has Jordan placed actions based on anyone else's thoughts this whole game? *goes and looks*

Well, at least, Spambot wise, he has placed his request for replacement and removed it on the whim of anyone else's posts.

FoS: Jordan

Both on page six, he points out something he thinks is scummy about Jordan and then goes and places an FoS on him. At the time Jordan only had one vote on him, and there were 3 others with 2 votes each. Atticus had previously voted occult, but he was the only one who had voted for him.

I doubt both Atticus and Spam are scum, unless they're trying some uber-distancing tactic.

Here's Jordan suggesting that Atticus can't be scum unless he is distancing! Is this Jordan trying to further help Atticus distance himself from him?

FOS: Atticus

Jordan throws out a FoS rather than a vote. Maybe I'm reading too much into it again here, but it could be him not wanting to help lynch his scum partner.

Bloody hell, I hate Day 1,

I agree that Occult and Atticus are suspicious, but I can't help thinking that the scum might infact be sitting back enjoying the fireworks.

This is Jordan once again mentioning atticus as possible scum.

Does anyone have objections to lynching Jordan? He's admitted to being scum, so I'd happily place another vote on him.

Actually,

Vote: Jordan.

I just counted and saw that that only puts him at lynch -1. Unless someone wants to milk the day for anything else...

He starts off asking if he should wait before Lynching Jordan, for some reason, then five minutes later changes his mind and votes for him, before asking if we want to milk the day for anything else, whihc is a bit like Zebra suggesting we keep discussion going for a bit.

[Hadhfang]

So you admit that you've been trying to distance yourself from Jordan?

There really isn't much to talk about guys, we should just lynch Atticus already.

It would appear so, but lets not be too hasty.

[Hadhfang]

The only thing his comments serve to do is help the scum and fish for a doctor roleclaim. It's

not

an open setup, so there is no reason to assume there

isn't

a doctor. My point was that the scum

assumed

that there was a doctor, and therefore didn't target me. All his post serves to do is tell the scum that they should try to kill me, which isn't helpful at all.

Fair point, That was a bad move on my part. Of coure there is still chance that there is a doctor in the game, as so far the doctor hasn't been lynched, So really trying to kill you this night would be as productive as it would have been last night.

[Hadhfang]

Well, instead of watching Occult's attack on xyzzy...

How about this. Anyone who isn't voting Hadhfang, should, so we can lynch scum.

I would like to know what has suddenly made me scum as well.

[Hadhfang]

Atticus, I wasn't desperate to lynch you at all, I suggested that you might have been distancing, but I wasn't adamant that you did.

[Hadhfang]

I have to find something to do while I'm being unhelpful to the town.

And is there a particular reason why you are being unhelpful to us?

[Hadhfang]

Well even if spambot is a townie he has so far been far from valuable to us.

[Hadhfang]

Riht, I'm assumin gthat MoS has a good reason for not wanting Atticus lynched, possibly due to something to do with his ability. I can't remember seeing a valid reason for lynching Atticus from spambot though, so perhaps he could tell us again why he wants Atticus lynched so badly.

[Hadhfang]

is there a reason you aren't sharing your hunch with us MoS?

[Hadhfang]

Interesting theory there Atticus, though I do remember that jordan wasn't under suspicion and it was a day 2 lynch, which is very soon for someone who wasn't suggested to be scum.

It will be intersting to see what the mafia's NK is tonight.

[Hadhfang]

Look the way

I

see it is that mos has already netted us one scum. He seems to have a plan to net more. If tomorrow comes and his master plan doesn't work, or he explains his plan and it's a really bad plan,

then

we may put some pressure on him.
Until then I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt.

Plus atticus is as good a choice as any in my opinion
(Plus the spambot thing - it's win-win-win!)

But you're ignoring one crucial question: What if he's scum?

I believe the reason you're ignoring this is because you're his partner.

The way MoS puts his argumnt he has either seen something that atticus has said or done that no-one else has yet, or he is scum. He has said that he's not overly confident in his plan, which gives him a scapegoat should Atticus turn up town. I can't at the moment see what it is that MoS can't share with us, if he is a watcher. If Atticus targetted Tony montana last night then he's scum and I don't know why MoS would keep that from us, If Atticus targetted anyone else then he doesn't have a night kill, and it's pointless lynching him.

The more I look into this the more I think that MoS is scum.

unvote,Vote: MoS

[Hadhfang]

I never said you did claim you were confident with your plan, in fact I pointed out that you werent and how that could be used as a scapegoat.

However, from that last post, it looks as if you have nothing on atticus, but think that someone else might be scum due to how they have reacted towards him. Am I right?

[Hadhfang]

Hadhfang, Occult, Spambot have been prodded.

no I haven't.


Good thing I check the thread though.

I don't think TheAdmiral is scum, though I do have suspicions on MoS.



Also, I'm on holiday as of the 24th, so will probably need a replcaement.

[Hadhfang]

One question: getting nightkilled as a vanilla townie is a good tactic isn't?

I don't see how that can be classed as a tactic since if you're a vannila townie you don't really get a say in who the mafia kill.


Good game everyone, well played especially to MoS, I would like to know however, what his train of thought was when he said if atticus was scum it would prove someone else to be scum.

[Hadhfang]

Sapmbot was the cop, right? I assumed he was the cop after he pushed Atticus, but I tried to get the attention on myself when I pushed him. I wasn't sure if the scum picked up that Spambot was cop, otherwise I would've confirmed Occult as scum the last day. I purposefully set up Hadhfang to be nightkilled because I figured out he was a doctor-ish role.

Well it didn't really matter when or how I got killed since that was my job. :p

Also, no. Spambot wasn't a cop, he was a vannila townie.

[Hadhfang]

Hadhfang, who were you protecting when you died?

You, I couldn't think of anyone else worth gambling on.