* I assume cop/doc is useless to the mafia.
* Using RB is counter-productive for (at least) tonight - 1:9 (10%) to block kill vs. 2:8 (20%) to block cop/doc. (Still bad if no lynch.)
* I think we should claim what we did last night when we get powers.
* Therefore we should be getting an investigation claimed each night, and most of them will be accurate, we hope.
* Lynch town/scum, we got 8:3 (72%) / 9:2 (81%) chance that a townie gets a given power.
* First cop claim is most reliable statistically until we lynch scum, so probably most important - WHO WE INVESTIGATE NIGHT 1 IS A BIG DEAL.
* Therefore perhaps we should do majority vote for who should be investigated? Or something?
I am concerned about claims. The scum have no reason not to claim tri, modulo ssf's post. If we want to win, we are probably going to have to lynch someone claiming tri, which makes our life fun. Maybe if someone claims tri, then both the cop and the doc target that person the following night? Scum can always fake-claim guilty as cop, but still. Hmm, not sure, worth thinking about though. Is it is best to ignore claims entirely? Probably not, but then we're stuck with lynching people who are claiming townie. The WIFOM here stinks.
The MoS thing is playable but boring. I will
MoS: "Pot calling kettle black" in 107 strikes me as bad. Why do you object to Phate making a perfectly logical statement about another newbie?
Really? Why?FaerieLord wrote:I really think that most of the people on this SJ things are either over ambitious or complete hypocrites.
ssf: I agree on the WIFOM. I also think a l - 2 claim is probably good in principle - it would be better if people simply announced they were willing to vote and hammer instead of putting any more votes on. That seems the best of both worlds, to me. I also agree we need a plan on how to play the setup. I also think we shouldn't be relying on the cop power, and (controversy ahead) we shouldn't seek to protect the triumvirate at the cost of finding the scum. In the worst case, the game becomes mountainous. At which point we will need to have done scumhunting previously, or we're screwed. Contingency plans are good. I don't mean we go rambo, but there's a balance, and I don't want people to use the kid gloves and find neither instead of both. We are here to lynch scum, and only to protect the tris inasmuch as it helps us to lynch scum.
If wespurgistan wrote:Maybe a no-lynch isn't that bad at all, remember, if we lose one triumvirate, the power roles are all gone, as far as I understand the rules.
miztif: The mafia pick one to do the kill. RB has to pick that one to block, or the kill goes through. I'm not sure why I'm helping you nightkill, but I'm feeling informative today.
Not by anyone sane, no. Assuming it were, it's obviously unintentional, soSpider Jerusalem wrote:I believe that could be considered a role claim right there
The next person to speculate in
Why are Flyinghawk and spurgistan lurking? Also, YuanTi is active lurking and/or dead.