I'll have a read over the thread later today or tomorrow, and then I'll make a post including my notes on the game. I will not be claiming until I get an understanding for the game. If you aren't okay with that, then you know what to do. If you want to give me any information about the game and the current situation we're in, it looks like now would be the time.
NY 117: The Vanillaside (Game over)
-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
>implying that lynching a townie is a good thing
I'll have a read over the thread later today or tomorrow, and then I'll make a post including my notes on the game. I will not be claiming until I get an understanding for the game. If you aren't okay with that, then you know what to do. If you want to give me any information about the game and the current situation we're in, it looks like now would be the time.-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
Alright, you had your chance to lynch me. If you do it after I have to read this thread then I'm not going to be happy with the hammerer. I'm going to take it personal. You know, just saying.
Give me an hour or so.-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
Please note that I do not expect you to read this entire post. These are my personal notes as I read through the game. Although you are welcome to check them out to get an insight as to where I am coming from, I will give a summarized conclusion at the end of the post (which I would like you to read).
[Town]RECK---dramonic---Elli----Fate-Spyrex---DH-[∙]--VV--Nacho-Jack---vez-MPR------[Scum]
Let's go with a scumscale like this. My top three picks for scum are MPR, vez, and Nacho. Jack and VV are both lynches I would support as well.
MPR was tested at the beginning of the game, and he did not do well. Ever since then he has kind of just flapped about, never really becoming a solid force in this game. So, like I was saying, he starts off on full defensive mode. He's worried about the wagon on him, and he doesn't just bring it up once or twice, which would, if that were the case, most likely be forgivable. Instead he continues to harp on about it over the course of several posts. A little later he criticizes Seraphim for voting vez. His reasoning for doing so is that Seraphim is moving his vote around too much, but I don't think even MPR fully bought that attack. It seems incredibly half-hearted and out of the blue, and he never brings it up again as far as I know. No, his real reasoning, I contend, is that he didn't want to see vez get lynched. Instead of standing up for vez, like a townie who wants to push his opinion would, he subtlely begins to undermine those on the wagon instead. This will not be the first time MPR comes to vez's defense. A little later MPR says he won't vote vez due to the size of the wagon... oh, it's not because it bothers him, but it bothersSocrates. Although, granted, this may just be MPR putting his foot in his mouth when it comes to phrasing something otherwise innocuous (Socrates was actually in the process of testing something), it bothers me that we're still talking about vez here. This is the second time MPR has tried to prevent this wagon from getting momentum. His post 230, the third major interaction with vez, is just pure coaching. Right out in the open and no one called him on it. Since this post, MPR has stayed mostly tight-lipped. As well he should, as the mafia scored big time in, one, stopping the vez lynch (he's either scum or VT, either way the mafia got the town to lynch someone more important), two, lynching the Vigilante, and three, shooting the Tracker. MPR no longer needs to put himself out there as the hardest work is done.
vez, by all accounts, should've been yesterday's lynch. He should be lynched today. He should be lynched tomorrow. He should be lynched in the morning, in the evening, and at supper time. Not as a policy lynch, but as a merit-based lynch. He has already claimed, he brings no use to the town, and until he does, he doesn't deserve to be alive until the endgame. The cherry on the top is that MPR is totally connected to vez, as I've already proven. In normal circumstances, vez could conceivably be a bad VT, but likely not scum. In this game, I'd say there's a much better chance for him to be scum. He skipped the first few pages because it's too much to read (why you would spend time playing a forum-based Internet game if you don't like to read is beyond me), he completely out of the blue lines up a Seraphim lynch on the back of an SSBF flip, and then he criticizes the town for not following through on lynching the uncc'd Tracker. This person is anti-town to the hilt, and he needs to be taken out. There's a good chance he'll flip scum too, don't discount vez just because, "oh that's just his way". Oh, and by the way, vezclaimedalready.
Nacho and Jack are basically equally scummy in my opinion. Neither of them have had any real presence in this game, although Nacho may have had slightly more to say. They both throw votes around, don't defend them, and only pop up when someone has the nerve to vote them. With Nacho I'm willing to cut a little more slack for, because I know he can be lazy as town (although I really enjoy his posts when he's on his game, I wish he would give us more), but Jack should give us a little more worry. As VV, Socrates, and Fate have implied, this is not like Jack normally plays. You take meta arguments for what they're worth, but you know it's true regardless. Additionally, Nacho was on the same boat as vez in wanting the SSBF lynch to go through after the claim. That just boggles my mind.
My top town reads, not including RECK, are dramonic (RF), Elli, and Fate. RF was on top of the game at the end of yesterday, and he brings up good points (which I tried to refute the best I could) against Korts. Korts isn't scum though, and I should know. Korts was not the reason the vez wagon failed yesterday. This was the work of Socrates, Seraphim, and MPR. If there isn't a scum flip between MPR and VV, I would be very surprised. We all know that vez wagon should've happened. If not when it was at its height, it should've happened after SSBF. Elli has just been his usual helpful self. I've seen no problem with his short, sweet posts. I don't care for Fate's newfound style and overall attitude, but when someone is right, they're right. Fate has been on top of the game and making positive contributions. I especially liked when he backed down from Korts earlier when Korts proved that he had a valid argument. It shows me that Fate isn't just pushing arguments for the sake of confusing the town.
Vote: MehPlusRawr-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
Either one would be fine with me really. The angle I'm going with is that if MPR flips town, then I'd probably be a little more hesitant to push vez as scum. The inverse isn't necessarily true though, so if vez flips town I think I would still be pushing an MPR lynch. I think MPR will just give us slightly more information, but, yeah, either one is fine.Spyrex 526 wrote:still, your arguments seem to favor Vezo as a more solid scum pick. Is there something else I'm missing?
---
Well, all scum are PRs, right? As long as we hit scum, we're gold. That's why I propose we go after who looks most like scum. From my perspective, that's MPR.VV 527 wrote:When do we lynch Jack though?
---
The major problem I have with you, MPR, is how I count you've came to vez's defense on three separate occasions. The first when you criticized Seraphim for voting him under the guise that he was "moving his vote too much" (this despite it being D1, and I alsodon't recall you ever bringing up again), then you say you can't join the vez wagon because Socrates wouldn't like it, and then you give some pitty-pat response to one of vez's crappy posts that looks to me much more like coaching than it does like a townie trying to scumhunt.MPR 534 wrote:Yeah, that's pretty much how I play, RC. At the beginning of the game, apparently most people thought I was town after the wagon thing, but oddly enough, people are wagoning me now for that. I think that Vezo is town because scum really would care more about being lynched- a third of one team is much worse for that team to lose as opposed to an eleventh of a team.
Alone, each of these points can easily be refuted, but because they're together, and because they all revolve around vez, it leads me to believe that you have knowledge about the game that we don't have. Either you guys are partners, or maybe you're trying to buddy up to him, hoping that when he flips town people will trust you. Either way, I think you're the best lynch the town has right now.
---
Oh, no, VV has done fine. I wasn't a huge fan of Socrates though, as you probably saw if you read that post. VV is moving up at the moment. Spyrex is probably moving backwards, but he's still on my town side. I agree with you that I absolutely did not like him going after RayFrost, but I think, before that, he had been solid. I honestly don't see many problems with Spyrex's D1 play.Fate 536 wrote:RC I did read your post FTR and I think SpyreX is still WAY too high on your town above town list. I mean DH is more townie than him and VV hasn't been dead weight stupid yet has he>-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
You can keep throwing that up there, but you'll keep getting the same answer. No. I don't buy it. I think it's too coincidental. I don't like the interaction between you two at all, and I think the town would be remiss to so easily toss this opportunity aside just to lynch a lurker. I'd like to think I have slightly more objective a view, coming in after a lot of play had already happened. With that, if we're serious about lynching Jack/Nacho, then we definitely need to get them in here to talk to us. However, I think I've heard enough from MPR/vez to know that there is something fishy going on.MPR 550 wrote:town read
-noun
1. A read that's town.
2. Something that RC fails to grasp.-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
I really like DH's post, I'm glad to see Nacho back, and I completely echo Fate's sentiments over the last few posts. I honestly don't know which player here is worse, but vez is nothing if he isn't making his lynch more appetizing every time he opens his mouth... that is, until MPR gets a chance to speak.
Mod, can we get a prod on Jack please?-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
The main reason why I preferred an MPR lynch yesterday over vez was that if MPR had flipped scum, I would've been sure that vez was his buddy. The same wasn't necessarily true the other way around.
That being said, vez's quickhammer does make him look bad. I've been hammering out this scene in my head, let me know what you guys think about it:
I'm not sure on all the details, but I'm thinking vez sacrificed himself for this lynch. Especially after lynching the Vig on D1, it's hard for me to imagine a VT so willing to throw caution to the wind for a second time. After all, vez already claimed, so he knew he wasn't the Gunsmith himself. How did he know that MPR wasn't?
It doesn't add up for vez.
Elli/Fate/DH/RECK, what do you guys think of my theory?-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
Alright, alright. Hold your horses. I didn't tell y'all to rush to a no lynch yesterday or we could've had one of the scumbuckets out already.
I've got some good news, some bad news, and some great news.
The good news is that Korts investigated DH during the first night and came up with "no gun".
The bad news is that I investigated Socrates/VV during the second night and, of course, came up with "no gun".
The great news is that I managed to pull off one guilty investigation before I was vanillized (I was told that I visited RECK and was stripped of my powers during the fourth night).
I visited Nacho on the third night and was told that he does "have a gun".
I'm all for second amendment rights and all, but in this town it's kill or be killed.
Vote: Nachomamma
Now I've got a few leads (since I had plenty of time to read over the thread) as to who Nacho's partners are. I want to share these with y'all before the day ends, but I figure I'd give y'all some time to ingest this.-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
I definitely think Jack. I think I can connect him fairly easily to Nacho with what they've had to say about each other.
Spyrex/Elli is a little tougher. There's the possibility as well that DH is a Godfather. I could see that as possible, but we'll cross that bridge when we come to it.
Elli 675 wrote:oh wow.
Supersmash was an all-town lynch.-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
*phew* I had been worrying about how this game would turn out given I didn't have Internet during the afternoon/evening. Much props goes out to RECK for the swift action.
Ty for the love Seph + everyone. As lop-sided as the game may look at first glance, the scumteam were all very deliberative in each move we made. That no lynch threw us into a big debate, I think, because Jack, me, and DH all had different opinions about how we should handle day 4.
And it's really hard to quantify the unheard of luck that the scum had with that first lynch/nightkill. When the two arguably most important town power roles are taken out, you know the town is going to have an uphill battle. I enjoyed playing the game though, and this group was a lot of fun.-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
-
-
RedCoyote Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 8036
- Joined: October 19, 2008
- Location: Houston, TX
<3VasudeVa wrote:Actually, I loved RC's #617. I think I went back and reread that 5 times and laughed every time. I like funny people(Even if they're a-holes and stole my claim D=<).
In actuality Hoopla was picking on me, although I think me, Jack, and DH had a nice rapport.
I hope Korts/DH/Jack don't mind, but that's the actual scum QT (if it wasn't posted already). You'll notice it really jumps in activity as the game gets down to the wire. Like I said, all three of us kind of had a different idea in mind about how to handle D4, so this was likely one of the most important QT's I've had in my time as MS (it's at least second though behind zoraster's Pledge of Allegiance large theme when I was just a lackey in a terrific scumteam of DGB, Debonair Danny DiPietro, Gammagooey, and Chronopie).
Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.