In post 1479, wind-up wrote:he is just not that kind of person. he stays inside on saturday nights.
lol I was asleep man sorry
In post 1479, wind-up wrote:he is just not that kind of person. he stays inside on saturday nights.
In post 1521, Smashbard wrote:Oh shit. I hadn't realized it has been that long since I last posted. Sorry for the prod guys. I hate doing that.
Bacde, we should do a Hydra together.
That is all.
In post 1579, petapan wrote:In post 1578, Bacde wrote:I mean, a ZONEACE lynch does sound tempting but I'm super skeptical of roflcopter right now
his scumgame from the last time i played with him was super weak, he pushed retarded reads and avoided bussing there's nothing to be skeptical of
In post 894, ZONEACE wrote:SERIOUSLY IF SMASH'S BREADCRUMBING IS SO FUCKING OBVIOUS WHY DOESN'T HE JUST CLAIM? If I'm so stupid that I must be the only one who doesn't see it, then what is the fucking point of him not just telling us? It's utter bullshit.
You people aren't using any fucking thought, just jumping from wagon to wagon in the hopes of getting a lynch to end the day.
that's not how you're supposed to play this game (unless you're scum and the target of the lynch doesn't matter as long as it's not a scummate)
In post 1595, roflcopter wrote:and if neither smash nor replacementkingdomaces fucking catches a bullet tonight then lynch them
In post 1599, JacobSavage wrote:In post 1590, JacobSavage wrote:
KingdomAces -Day Mason
Smashbard -Day Mason
JacobSavage -
roflcopter -
petapan -
Oversoul -
ZONEACE -
PeregrineV -
Bacde -
What does everyone think of this order for claimage?
In post 1624, JacobSavage wrote:He's going to claim I tin of Tomato Ketchup, I just know it.
since I might die tonightIn post 1638, Bacde wrote:KingdomAces - Day Mason
Smashbard - Day Mason
JacobSavage -Vanilla Townie
roflcopter - Vanilla Townie
petapan - Mafia
Oversoul - Vanilla Townie
ZONEACE - Gunsmith
PeregrineV - Vanilla Townie
Bacde - Unclaimed
Updated claims
If I think ZONEACE is telling the truth (and I do)In post 1653, PeregrineV wrote:So, even though you are the last to claim, you don't claim?In post 1640, Bacde wrote:since I might die tonightIn post 1638, Bacde wrote:KingdomAces - Day Mason
Smashbard - Day Mason
JacobSavage -Vanilla Townie
roflcopter - Vanilla Townie
petapan - Mafia
Oversoul - Vanilla Townie
ZONEACE - Gunsmith
PeregrineV - Vanilla Townie
Bacde - Unclaimed
Updated claims
these are my townreads from a quick reread of the beginning of the game
And you somehow think you will be killed tonight over the Mason, the other Mason, and the Gunsmith?
I really need all these questions answered, as this entire post makes no sense from a town PoV.
look at page 4In post 1695, PeregrineV wrote:FYI, both of the links I posted were Oversoul-town in other games. One with superscumhuntingOversoul, and another with plodposting Oversoul.In post 1693, Smashbard wrote:I'm liking Peregrines recent defenses against the likes of Jacob & Oversoul. His points against Oversouls meta seem particularly convincing to me.
Maybe Go/HD was a scum gambit after all. I'm still not sure. But at this point I think I'd like to let Peregrine slide for another dayphase and take out Oversoul or Rofl.
There's some stuff I can't say now, but can you point out what you are talking about in the Go/HD "scum gambit"?
here's the thing thoughIn post 1698, Smashbard wrote:I'll put it this way, if Savage isn't town we lose. Because I'd rather lynch Oversoul, Rofl & Peregrine before Jacob, but I also don't really have a good solid town read on Jacob either. His active lurking all game except for the last day phase when he was just a vanilla townie (claim anyway) doesn't sit well with me. But since then his willingness to claim first and otherwise scumhunting efforts makes me unsure of whether I think he's scum either.In post 1694, Bacde wrote:^^honestly I feel like jacobsavage is town
what do you think smash?
Since if we can get 1 strong townread, we win the game
He's basically an uncomfortable null read for me right now because there's so many better lynch candidates than him.
In post 1714, Smashbard wrote:Jacob setting up for a fake claim doesn't make any sense considering he offered to claim first and immediately claimed Vanilla. Chances are he was just trying to save Nobody Special from a kill.
I'm guessing both Jacob and Bacde have tried the whole "Look at me scum, don't kill the power roles, because I've got something going on!" when in reality they probably don't.
Given that information, and Peregrines defenses seeming really genuine, I'm pretty much sold on Oversoul or Rofl being the last scum.
If I'm wrong, on both accounts and the town ends up in Lylo, you guys probably want to follow Aces suspicions on there being a Mafia Doctor or Godfather and lynch Bacde at the very end. Or whatever. I won't be alive til that point anyway. Unless Scum really really wanna hand us the game and continue to keep the Masons alive.
are you worried about his blocks of text helping us out?In post 1730, roflcopter wrote:peregrine stop flooding the thread with huge blocks of colored text
considering that there are likely 2 scum in the 4 unconfirmeds, who do you think is your town buddy?In post 1734, roflcopter wrote:no they're just obnoxious and i don't want to waste my time reading what he thinks is so important if he's not going to explain why its so important
I'm wondering because his non-contributory stance on this game can't be taken as scummy if this style of play is his MOIn post 1744, roflcopter wrote:i'm guessing he tends to contribute more at endgame when he's the last scum alive, and his "contribution" has been 1) doing clerical work that literally anyone can do regardless of alignment and 2) volunteering to claim first
Why is this idea laughable?In post 1741, JacobSavage wrote:I mean from what I gathered you case is: Jacob hard bussed Zepher and then soft bussed peta and HD.
Which is pretty laughable to be honest.
My Zepher read was based almost wholly on ISOing Trollie when the day opened.
you're kidding meIn post 1753, JacobSavage wrote:He is?
I completely agree with you hereIn post 1768, roflcopter wrote:what this thread really needs is more direction from the conftowns
smashbard I know you are sorta upset about your reads this game but knowing that you are town has been indispensible for me to make not-shitty reads this game. TBH I've been about as wrong as you have this gameIn post 1779, Smashbard wrote:Uhm, to be clear, I have been an advocate for a Rofl lynch for the past several day phases. Especially after the chumminess between himself and Peta trying to direct the town into a mislynch of Zoneace together.In post 1761, PeregrineV wrote: 3. rofl received many town reads from scum, and currently "town confirmed by gunsmiths" players can't seem to adequately verbalize why rolf is so town
It's everyone else who keeps saying that Rofl is somehow indisputably town, so I have conceded my pressure on him for the sake of trying to get all of us to agree on a viable lynch.
Your only hope of that happening is if it comes from Bacde. Because KingdomAces doesn't have the ability to direct the town and all of my ideas have been horrible and I haven't actually been on a successful Scum Wagon since the start of the game. So we have exactly zero credibility to lead anyone to a lynch.In post 1768, roflcopter wrote:what this thread really needs is more direction from the conftowns
To be fair, your point about Zepher trying to get Jacob lynched over his lurkiness definitely gives Savage a lot of town points. I didn't see Zepher as a player clever enough to think so far ahead that bussing Jacob would be a move that would make Jacob seem town later down the line, so the chances of Savage being town are greater than his chances of being scum.
However, your point again as to Peta mentioning that HD was looking miles better than Go in their interactions seems weird to me if Oversoul would end up as scum. Because why would Peta side with one scum over the other so early in the game if he had no reason to at that point? So maybe I am wrong about Oversoul.
But if I concede that, then the only possible scum left are between Peregrine, Bacde and yourself. Being that I currently believe Bacde to be town, this whole last minute spat between yourself and Peregrine has got to be scum vs. scum spreading some last minute confusion for the town.
fyi the only possible way for me to be scum is if I'm a godfather or mafia doctor, and we've already had a scum PR flipIn post 1790, PeregrineV wrote:@Rofl- This is buddying.In post 1785, Bacde wrote:Smash your opinions are actually helpful to me
if I can't convince you that rofl is town, then I want us to keep looking at rofl until we come to a conclusion
A lot of your opinions that I thought were retarded at the time (such as if greygnarl flips town, then ZONEACE is confirmed town) actually ended up being VERY correct
I feel like together we make a really good townie so lets figure this out
well you accused me of buddying, which is silly since I've been buddying smashbard since d1In post 1795, PeregrineV wrote:???In post 1793, Smashbard wrote:Are you just going to flail and accuse everyone who votes for you as scum out of the blue despite never once declaring these suspicions before this point?
Please, tell me how the two claimed Mason's are scum now too, since my vote is on you.
Unvote. Until an official vote count is posted.
Not sure what you are talking about.
honestly you seem more motivated to not get lynched than to find scumIn post 1792, PeregrineV wrote:I'm at L-1 and will flip town, so you should move your vote now.In post 1788, Smashbard wrote:After this, if Peregrine flips town, I'm sticking my vote on Rofl and not moving.