In post 955, Aj The Epic wrote:This is a weak post. Everyone you 'wouldn't mind' lynching is a lurker. You take only the easiest routes on any of your reads and echo exactly what Titus has for reads for your 'will not lynch'. There's no independent thought here.
Just quoting to see if AJ pushes someone for being a lurker.
In post 972, RadiantCowbells wrote: In post 971, Shiro wrote:
You think pistachi0n is town?
I am fairly certain one of pistachi0n/zimpf is scum
Walk me through the reasoning that
a) there's a confirmed scum between those two players and
b) that there's only one confirmed scum between those two players
c) that none of the above information points to any specific one of them, just the pair.
Good set of questions from RadiantCowbells here.
In post 973, Shiro wrote:There is no reasoning.
Grib is basically the towniest motherfucker in this game/
Just a feeling. I mean you could argue that both of them COULD be scum but I wish to believe not two scum are hard lurking like that
Bad set of answers from Shiro here.
Dwlee's pistach tunnel (although is it really a tunnel if there are more than enough good reasons for it?) looks townie.
Uhh... why? Seems rather non-sequitur.
In post 1047, Dwlee99 wrote:Wtf zymf..
you
. wtf
What the actual crap..
just to get it off of your back..?
the entire wagon that was on me has joined my wagon has moved to pistachio despite scum reading me.. wuuuuutttt.
Mario, it is multiball..
Another multiball spec-ing? This seems odd. Why are people first jumping to the conclusion of multiball explaining what's happening rather than, idk, them being wrong with their reads? Or a bad bus?
In post 1056, Elyse wrote: In post 1046, Zymf wrote:I'm sorry for being inactive, I shouldn't have joined this game :/
@Frogger: If you have a replacement ready, I don't mind being replaced.
Most of the active players seem to agree that we shouldn't lynch Dwlee. I don't really understand why, but...
I don't mind lynching pistachion either. So just to get this off my back, I think we should lynch him.
VOTE: Pistachi0n
I don't know what to make of this.
Help
Wow, this is a really good way to "comment" on a post while literally saying jack shit.
In post 1066, RadiantCowbells wrote:You wouldn't lie to me.
So you're saying that if you were scum this game, right now, you would admit that you're scum and vote yourself?
I- uh- what? RC looks like he's being silly RC here, which is all well and good, but it's still a weird conversation. If RC
is
scum, this basically means that Elyse isn't his partner, because this would be the weirdest way for scumbuddies to behave, by attracting attention to themselves using a silly reason to unvote over several posts.
In post 1072, Elyse wrote:
I was scumreading you but upon reflection and some meta from our old games (good times btw) I'm not so sure of that read anymore. Gun to my head, you're town.
Wow, townreading him basically just after he decided you were town? What a realistic development that isn't even slightly convenient.
In post 1082, Dwlee99 wrote:Let us look at our options..
either pistachio and zymf are scum together and zymf is bussing
Zymf is town and voting pistachio
Or zymf and the nut are part of different scum teams
What seems most likely?
I would happily argue that the first and second are easier conclusions to come to. This seems like a weird justification. Bleh.
In post 1091, Elyse wrote:Lining up lynches, etc.
Seriously his ISO is terrible. I'm not moving my vote.
In post 1677, Elyse wrote:Intent to hammer.
I'm leaving my house in 45 min and will hammer if MM doesn't claim by then.
1v1ing Titus tomorrow.
Just putting that first quote by the other three. Take a look and spot the issue!
In post 1106, Titus wrote: In post 1104, Grib wrote:snip
Well, at a glance, it isn't impossible. None of them have voted together, except in the last votal, which. Makes me less inclined to lynch pistachi0n.
VCA pre flips? Really?
In post 1109, Titus wrote: In post 1107, Grib wrote:No single wagon toDay has had more than six votes, when the necessary needed to lynch is ten. I think this suggests a scumteam that's timid, overly-careful, new, or lurking.
Or a low charisma scumteam that cannot push a counterwagon to scum but is better at defending and wking.
Dave Elyse AJ.
This is certainly a change of opinion. She goes from saying that pre-flip VCA is bad to suddenly having a VCA which supports her hypothesis.
In post 1142, pistachi0n wrote:I don't think Dwlee is scum anymore. He's so adamant, every post of his is "LYNCH PISTACHI0N LYNCH PISTACHI0N" and he even argued with Titus about the right reason to vote me when Titus was willing to vote me anyway.
I'm scum-reading Shinobi. Half of the posts are about semantics, "I guess," or statements with no elaboration.
VOTE: Shinobi
This is a weeeird post. He just comes in, makes a non-sequitur comment, basically ignoring everything else going on, places a vote on a vanity wagon.
In post 1228, pistachi0n wrote: In post 1144, Shinobi wrote: In post 1142, pistachi0n wrote:I don't think Dwlee is scum anymore. He's so adamant, every post of his is "LYNCH PISTACHI0N LYNCH PISTACHI0N" and he even argued with Titus about the right reason to vote me when Titus was willing to vote me anyway.
I'm scum-reading Shinobi. Half of the posts are about semantics, "I guess," or statements with no elaboration.
VOTE: Shinobi
What? Where?
Like in
1088 "I can be swayed, I guess"
964 statement with no elaboration
In posts like
357 and
521 he's disagreeing but not giving content/elaborating.
When questioned, he (almost 100 posts later) gives an amazing four posts out of Shinobi's 50 or so posts at this point that vaguely support his point I guess. This is kinda meh. Plus, the irony of "statement with no elaboration" considering that his last post was a statement with no elaboration.
In post 1161, pignash wrote:Oh it's so fun to post and then immediately get called scum...
It's almost like it's the reason I have said little to nothing the whole game because I feel like opening my mouth means being scumread. It's discouraging really. Every third person is throwing out naked scum reads so it's not like I'm alone in this.
Blaming other people for his own lurking. Nasty.
YAY ONLY TWENTY PAGES TO GO FUCKING HELL
I don't get what you're trying to say here, Shiro. It's all Greek to me.
gdi
In post 1219, Titus wrote:Oh by the way, Davesto has ignored this thread after the pressure on him abated.
This is scummy. After me having already justified that I was away for IRL reasons literally
42 posts ago, she seems to have forgotten this and decides to call it out as if it were scummy.
Buy your free opportunism here!
Looks like someone saw something convenient to comment on that happened a while ago whilst still ignoring a large amount of things that are going on. Cool, cool.
In post 1484, Titus wrote: In post 1480, Aj The Epic wrote:It ain't a scum response to attack your ego, Titus. It's sad you think that, too because it prevents a lot of proper discussion.
It is a scum response to attack ego. Town argue with evidence. I am aware of the size of my own ego.
Attacking ego is a logical fallacy and the sole purpose of such is to discredit the poster and not address the truth of the argument.
While me arguing at you with evidence meant I was still scum for *reasons*, obviously.
This shit is townie as hell, regardless of either AJ's alignment. Quitting an easy lynch to push a town wagon would make no sense from scum. If AJ is town, then he's a PR and scum supposedly just gave up the opportunity to be rid of a town PR. If AJ is scum, it's really fucking ballsy to change the wagon whilst being his scum partner, not to mention something that could easily screw him over later.
