Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[ashmite84]

Hi all, will read up ASAP and post when I've caught up.

[ashmite84]

Okay, I'm up to speed. Thoughts: (forgive me if I repeat accepted opinion or state the bleeding obvious)

I'm not a major fan of either of the prominant wagons but if it came to it, I believe the FL wagon holds more water than the Cream wagon.

Gimbo must be protected. This should be obvious but there might be a protecting role out there that has other ideas.

I have faith in the coin-pooling idea but it would require a lot of co-ordination and my support for it depends on the answer to the following:

mod: is it possible to perform an action such as 'give all my coins to player X', or do you have to nominate an amount?

This would eliminate scum lying about their amount of coins.

Phoebus question definately does not sound like the words of someone who got the townie PM, therefore

vote: Phoebus

[ashmite84]

Phoebus question definately does not sound like the words of someone who got the townie PM,

Hahaha!
And what exactly is the townie PM?
Are you role fishing?


Are there even any specific non townies?
For all I know - there's the mafia, a bunch of toads who can buy powers and that's it.
Even Peach might be a mechanic from where I sit...

You are right clueless, you are.

What exactly have I said or.. rather... not said that's so evil and scumbaggy?

Why would I tell you the townie role PM? The townies already know it. You ask me if I'm rolefishing in a post where you yourself are rolefishing. It's clear from my post that the only roles I'm interested in fishing for are scum roles.

I'm also not liking the laughter and calling me clueless unreasonably and would probably now policy lynch you anyway.

You persist that Peach may be a mechanic, townie roles know this to be incorrect from something in our role PM. You may be a third party role or a power role. Either way your death would not phase me. I'm uneasy about 3rd party roles in a game like this and as for power role - anyone can be a power role in this game with the right coin.

And finally, no pro-town should fear being lynched today, because barring some horrible stuff up, you will be revived.

Pretty happy with my vote right now.

[ashmite84]

Phoebus is a decent lynch.
We need more votes please.

Fix'd.

[ashmite84]

RS - who is a better lynch in your opinion? FL or Phoebus?

[ashmite84]

Why are people claiming at the drop of a hat?

[ashmite84]

Why are people claiming at the

drop of a hat?

L-1 or 2?
/quote]

Are you sure you need the answer to this question?

RBT was barely even looked at at the time of the claim. Goborage's poison shroom was a potentially useful item that he seemed be in a hurry to get rid of.

Mod: tags fixed

[ashmite84]

ashmite, unlike my shroom, goborage got a shitty shroom that is potentially incriminating as he explained in his post, if it was me, i probably would've gotten rid of it too.

I read his post, I just felt it a pretty weak reason. I'd never give up a 1-shot vig like that.

[ashmite84]

ashmite, Riceball was going to lynched at deadline.

Gimbo, there are ways to do that that wouldn't result in his death.

Gimbo - what he said.

Re: RBT, numerically yes RS was on 6 and RBT was on 5, but all the heat was currently on RS and no one was really discussing RBT, and he just pops in out of the blue and goes "all right guys, you've twisted my arm, I'll claim."

I guess it doesn't matter, I just wouldn't have claimed so easily, that's all. Someone else (SSF?) said it felt like RBT had thought of a story and was bursting to tell it, necessary or not. I get this impression somewhat too, though not enough for true suspicion.

[ashmite84]

I have an idea, but I want Gimbo and Surye to each answer this question first: How important do you consider the 'other' ability of the 1-Up 'shroom / the ramifications of the scum knowing it in relation to "actually playing mafia"? A 1-10 followed by an explanation would be appreciated.

1 being 'meh'
5-ish being somewhat significant
10 being game-altering.

[ashmite84]

Well, so much for my plan. Ah well.

[ashmite84]

2)how beneficial for town would it be to know the quantity of coins everyone has, creating a way to control the buying of items.
Opinions?

Very

beneficial.

[ashmite84]

I will donate or coin-claim if that is the plan the majority wish to follow. Maybe we could vote?

[ashmite84]

^ NO, town has already decided, so give up your coins NOW .

FoS:ashmite84

I just read the last 3 pages and there seems to be some argument over wether this plan is beneficial or not.

[ashmite84]

I've just re-read RS' D1. On more than one occasion he defended Cream saying he didn't see the case against Cream / there were better lynches than Cream. Unless the two are in cahoots, I would have thought that the Cream wagon would have been a cushy place for RS to park his vote and get lost among the crowd.

This led me to re-read Cream's D1. After no interaction with RS, Cream applied some light distancing just when it was becoming apparent that RS was going down anyway.

Cream's D1 is an interesting read and littered with other scummines that has nothing to do with RS aswell.

I think Cream is in the DK crew.

Vote: Cream147

[ashmite84]

unvote; vote: iamausername

[ashmite84]

unvote; vote: iamausername

Bit slow on the uptake, aren't you?

No, I just read the thread after all the other wagoners.

[ashmite84]

Okay,

unvote

first of all. Now, let's end the speculation, unless y'all don't want to.

Iam: If you like I can explain what farside saw? If this is what everyone wants I will.

Alternatively we can do a random dice roll of all the people who claimed to get it, and line them up to explain it. Then highest roller has to explain, if they do - semi-confirmed, if they don't they become suspicious. Then second, third etc. until someone gets it right.

[ashmite84]

Okay,

unvote

first of all. Now, let's end the speculation, unless y'all don't want to.

Iam: If you like I can explain what farside saw? If this is what everyone wants I will.

Alternatively we can do a random dice roll of all the people who claimed to get it, and line them up to explain it. Then highest roller has to explain, if they do - semi-confirmed, if they don't they become suspicious. Then second, third etc. until someone gets it right.

What? This issue is over. We decided not to talk about it, remember? I have a good guess at what it might be, but I'm not sure and according to farside it would be bad for the town for it to be revealed so yeah not gonna happen. You seem to be a couple pages behind every time you post.

FoS: ashmite84

This was in response to Iam's post on the previous page.

[ashmite84]

Theres a newbie called Obmig who wants to play if you are having trouble finding a replacement.

[ashmite84]

Sounds like the best damage control so far.

Vote: Faerie Lord

[ashmite84]

If he's not telling the truth, then he's likely to be Bowser anyway...

Uh, what? Does no one think it's likely that FL is a member of Bowser's team trying to get himself lynched in Bowser's place and securing the win?

People should really stop voting FL (or anyone else, for that matter) right now.

Of course I've considered that. Do you have a better idea?

[ashmite84]

Happy birthday FL.

Unvote

Not trusting K7 right now. Are you given a PM every night that Peach is

not

kidnapped telling you such?

Will claim if Pop wishes.

[ashmite84]

I am a

Toad

(Mushroom Kingdom). I am loyal to Princess Peach, and try to keep her from getting kidnapped.

[ashmite84]

Apologies and thanks Mod. Will be more careful in future.

TSPN what is fake bout my claim? This should be good.

Give 2 coins to Populartajo

Mod edit
Visible Votecount:
FaerieLord (1): Korts
ashmite84 (1): TheSweatpantsNinja

Not voting (19): iamausername, skitzer, Wintermute, forbiddanlight, somestrangeflea, Surye, killa seven, Gremwell, Alabaska J, farside22, ting =), DarlaBlueEyes, FaerieLord, Lord Gurgi, Cream147, Riceballtail, goborage, populartajo, ashmite84

[ashmite84]

Give: 1 (One) coin to populartajo

(This should fail, I have 2 coins)

[ashmite84]

TSPN what is fake bout my claim? This should be good.

This:

I am a Toad (Mushroom Kingdom). I am loyal to Princess Peach, and try to keep her from getting kidnapped.

Is wrong.

I would have figured that paraphrasing was done so he wouldn't be MK'd.

That is no doubt what he will claim now, but do you

paraphrase

things in a quote box?

When you say "Is wrong" do you mean it's not word for word? I was trying to make it accurate enough to be recognized but not so much that it would be breaking the rules. What is scummy about the area box?

[ashmite84]

How is a toad the protector of the princess? Shouldn't that fall under mario or someone like that?

Anyone else see anything wrong with this?

[ashmite84]

How is a toad the protector of the princess? Shouldn't that fall under mario or someone like that?

Anyone else see anything wrong with this?

Yea, it completely ignores the sited information about the character. And Mario never protects her... ever. He's always reactionary.

No, I mean: IIRC Farside as good as claimed Toad, if so, she should recognize things from my claim, as should any toad.

[ashmite84]

Already did but

Give: 1 coin to populartajo

. (will fail). Putting faith in pop's judgment. Good point about AJ's claim.

FOS: Alabaska