Explosiva Mafia - GAME OVER

[JDodge]

Well hello there folks.

I'm told I'm to blow up someone and then die. I'm told that there is no other lynch for the day. How fun.

Considering I am town, and I am thus the only

confirmed

town due to my status as bomb-carrier, allow me to set some ground rules for how I'm going to decide who to lynch.

1. I don't give a rat's ass who you would bomb were you in my position. I care why you would bomb them. Don't vote people, I don't care about your petty little votes. Give cases instead.

2. I will execute the person whom I feel is scummiest next Wednesday at 9PM my time (Eastern time, US). I may be late. Deal with it.

3. Don't bitch about my guidelines for who I'm lynching. This is going to be my only act in this entire game, don't cloud my judgment with your senseless whining.

4. I will comment on what I feel necessary and answer any and all questions directed at me. I may be a dictator, but I'm not an unreasonable one.

Now that we've gotten that out of the way, I want to see some cases brought forth. Now.

[JDodge]

I really, really want to blow up armlx. What reasons do I have not to?

[JDodge]

I really, really want to blow up armlx. What reasons do I have not to?

What reasons do you have to lynch me, versus say Iceman who tried to use WIFOM to manipulate the lynch in a scummy way today or Twomz, who basically is acting drastically less helpful then I know him as town (Weather Mafia) but about on par as scum (CKD's Riverworld Mafia)?

Because you're acting dead on in my scum meta for you.

Bomb alvinz

This is not a case nor in any way important, and in violation of one of my guidelines. You go on my TARGETS LIST.

I outlined a case on alvinz in some of my previous posts. You can read me in isolation or have me link and quote the important stuff, Jdodge. you albe to go back read it or you want me to make a quick version?

At this moment I'd also like to know since when did icemanE approve of an Alvinz death? When did that start and he even bring a case on that? He's was voting springlullaby and ain't even acknowledge recent stuff me and springlullably said about that matter. Wtf?

I'd prefer the short version, because I doubt I'll have time to analyze the entire game. Hence why I'm asking for cases.

TARGET LIST:

Armlx
Iceman
BM (for old times' sake)

[JDodge]

Coron should be on your death list. Not only has he suddenly gone silent, which is a significant change from the beginning of the game, but at one point he made his own meta regarding frequency of posting an issue (and engaged in a bit of doubletalk when called on whether his data supported his claim). The combination is the square of the scummy of the sum of its parts. Also, a lot of the contrived-looking exchanges have Coron as a common thread.

So you're saying the entire case on Coron is that he suddenly went silent, and that at one point he brought up his meta, probably leading to some exchange with armlx trying to force his own style of play on him?

Yeah, that's nothing out of the norm for Coron. Nice effort, though.

[JDodge]

Because you're acting dead on in my scum meta for you.

From what games are you drawing said meta? I don't remember any game I've been in with you as scum.

Sorry, didn't realize I was only allowed to read games I'm in.

Not telling. Doing so would allow you to research said behavioural meta and thus change it, which is contrary to what I want in the long-run.

[JDodge]

I think alvinz is the strongest lynch candidate.

No reason given. Max goes on to the target list.

I'm all for a armlx bombing. I've already said I felt he was scum. I also think alvinz could also be scum. His recent post really jumped out at me as scum.

Please repost why you think he is scum. I'm interested in hearing it.

Just wondering, as odds are your "scum meta" of me is due to reading a biased sample of games.

Hell, compare this game to Lover's Multiball or Xyl's Smalltown. I'm pretty sure those games contradict what you think you see here. Or Shaft.ed's Fat Camp Mafia or what ever it was, or PYP3.

I can see where you got that conclusion from games like Norinel's Eclipse and House Mafia though.

You might want to try giving me reasons to not bomb you instead of arguing that my basis for reaching my conclusion is flawed, because I don't believe it is flawed and will probably not be changing my mind on that.

TARGET LIST:

Armlx
Max
iceman

That is in order BTW.

[JDodge]

Wait JDodge have you read the game, if you had you would know I have been pushing for an alvinz bombing for ages

Have you? I'm pretty sure I clearly laid out my guidelines. Hypocrite.

Compare Twomz's behavior here to the two games I gave as examples.

Which examples?

[JDodge]

Wait JDodge have you read the game, if you had you would know I have been pushing for an alvinz bombing for ages

Have you? I'm pretty sure I clearly laid out my guidelines. Hypocrite.

Your guidelines mention nothing about you not reading the thread

But it does state that you should shut up in saying "I think you should bomb X", and present a case instead.

Stop arguing semantics with me, it's not going to get you anywhere. You're just going to continue to prove yourself incompetent.

[JDodge]

Your logical basis is nonexistant.

NEXT

[JDodge]

Based on the last fives page or so because I can't summon the righteous energy to read 40 pages right now.

I'd bomb forbiddanlight: active lurking, no case - lynchproof play but zero risk taking.
Fits the 'I'll lurk this one to the win'.

Seems to fit with a quick forbiddanmeta. I'll add her to the list.

TARGET LIST:
Armlx
Max
iceman
forbiddan

[JDodge]

Bomb alvinz

This is not a case nor in any way important, and in violation of one of my guidelines. You go on my TARGETS LIST

You get bumped down a slot since you're clearly not reading what I'm saying despite the fact that I have sole control over the day's lynch. Scum would want to suck up to the bomb carrier a bit more methinks. Regardless, pay attention.

TARGETS LIST:
Armlx
Max
forbiddanlight
iceman

[JDodge]

I feel Alvinz should be blown up because

Please specify exactly what you feel to be hypocritical.

[JDodge]

K.

I am reasonably sure that if Coron

is

scum, that TSS is scum with him. Like 85% sure.

In the meantime, I'll put Coron on my targets list.

TARGETS LIST:
Armlx
Max
Coron
forbiddanlight
icemanE
Armlx again for good measure

[JDodge]

So you are more than 85% sure armlx and max are scum (since they are higher on your list than Coron)? If that's the case, then could you tell us why before you explode? Since you can only explode one, it would give us something to look at from a proven townie POV tomorrow.

No. I said that if Coron is scum, then there is an 85% likelihood that TSS is scum with him. Pay attention.

Nicely done, DoS.

TARGETS LIST:
(I still haven't seen any logical reason not to bomb) Armlx
Max
Coron
Alvinz
forbiddanlight
icemanE

[JDodge]

May I ask why I'm on some people's targets lists? I don't know what the last thing I read was :S.

Hi, thanks for NOT ANSWERING. Seriously...

Either pay attention to the fucking game or get yourself replaced.

[JDodge]

Either pay attention to the fucking game or get yourself replaced.

Then answer my question. Either by pointing me to a post where you elucidate this or by putting it straight out there again. Honestly, if I'm on a targets list, there is obviously a reason. And since nothing else has been incredibly interesting in this game lately, give me something to defend.

I just said it a page or so ago. Pay attention, and read the fucking game. Thanks.

[JDodge]

BM suspects me because I replaced Jordan and he thinks Jordan lurking out is a scum tell. Awhile back Jordan lurked out of and was replaced in a bunch a games if I recall correctly.

Indeed, but it's more the MANNER in which he did here that bugs me. He didn't request replacement, and yet, did not intend on actually scumhunting. At the time i wasnt worried, but with hindsight, it seems off...

BM

Could be easily explained by him having more of a vested interest in this game.

NEXT

[JDodge]

BM suspects me because I replaced Jordan and he thinks Jordan lurking out is a scum tell. Awhile back Jordan lurked out of and was replaced in a bunch a games if I recall correctly.

Indeed, but it's more the MANNER in which he did here that bugs me. He didn't request replacement, and yet, did not intend on actually scumhunting. At the time i wasnt worried, but with hindsight, it seems off...

BM

Could be easily explained by him having more of a vested interest in this game.

NEXT

Which, given his personality, might indicate that he was scum, no?

BM

He was flaking and clearly cared more about this game than his other games. Understandable.

Tomorrow night I will make my decision. Then the bomb will happen. I reserve the right to extend that deadline.

[JDodge]

Bomb: Armlx

It came down to you vs. Max, and I have more faith that someone will bomb Max in the coming days than I have faith that someone will bomb you. Plus that whole "I WAS WAITING FOR BM TO RESPOND SO I COULD SET HIM UP" thing was hella scummy.