LOST (Game Over)

[Lukewarm]

@Marci

I think you played super well!

For several days in a row, I thought you were the 3rd towniest player in the game BestBird->MLB->You.

It did a lot to get you all the way to the endgame, but it just spelled a hard Elo for you

[Lukewarm]

Day 1 of this game was.... , but after that this was a very enjoyable game that I had a good time in.

Thanks for modding STD and catboi!

[Lukewarm]

Gg I had fun. Though yes it was super frustrating at times, but that’s definitely part of the typical mafia experience. Thanks for the game Peta, STD.

were u happy when u died

did anyone even ever figured out why u died

I wanna know why bell died?

Was it because of his Taly scum read?

[Lukewarm]

This game became pretty unplayable for me a bit before I started pushing for my own lim. Like I couldn't parse anyone anymore, I was forgetting stuff but ISOs were too large to refresh my memory,

Yeah, the day 1 of this game was anti-town for this reason.

Even just to use myself for reference, I have a 5.1 page long ISO. 4 pages of that all Day 1, and then only like 1 page of that of that is Day 2+3+4.

Day 1 made all ISOs unreadable.

Spoiler:

I think that all large games should have day 1 posts limits.

[Lukewarm]

my ISO is the opposite of that

You have 130 day 1 posts in a different ISO, and you were vla for half of day 1, and you actually lived to day 13 (compared to my day 4 lol)

And your day 1 number of posts is likely still much higher then your average posts per day phase lol

[Lukewarm]

Want dead thread.

Want mafia thread too, but I know that takes a while.

No redactions from me in either hood btw std

[Lukewarm]

but seriously...i'm assuming the dead PT formed after my 2nd shot...?

When I died I was told that there was no dead thread "until a certain game even occured"

I was assuming that was your 2nd shot

[Lukewarm]

I think that all large games should have day 1 posts limits.

I agree.
Though, I would say that Day 2 needs them too.
I ended up almost falling behind while trying to read everything.

I legit couldn’t keep up and being blamed for the spam when not anywhere near top poster was hilarious.

I am almost certain that if you look at posts made from [the time you repped in] -> [the time of the gladiate] you had the most posts, which is the only time I was personally saying something like that. It was a lot in a short period of time. If you zoom out to the game overall you don't average at the top

But to be fair, I added more then my own share of thread bloat to this thread.

[Lukewarm]

I decided to be very productive with my time.

Posts Per Day

133 Math
79 Dancing Puppets (Nancy Drew 39 and Titus)
58 Pooky
49 Luke
47 Bell
44 T-Bone
42 Frog
33 Rad
32 Johnny
28 Ceph
28 BBT
26 Off the Hook

Spoiler:

Posts Per Hour

5.55 Math
3.29 Dancing Puppets (Nancy Drew 39 and Titus)
2.43 Pooky
2.05 Luke
1.96 Bell
1.86 T-Bone
1.76 Frog
1.39 Rad
1.34 Johnny
1.19 Ceph
1.18 BBT
1.09 Off the Hook

And then got tired before I finished the player list.

Yeah, I did the math and everything at the time.

Your total posts were lower because you had not been there as long, but you were posting at a substantially higher rate then anyone else for a while

[Lukewarm]

Sorry we wotc'ed you Teeby

Hey noraa!

The amount of times I have incorrectly scum read you made me real uncertain about it lmao


A broken clock is right twice a day I guess!

[Lukewarm]

Noraa - 2
Off the Hook - 2
Best Bird - 1
Mislim Bait - 1
Johnny - 0
butterflies - 0
Roden - 0[/quote]

0. Roden
1. Butterflies
1.5. Best Bird
2. Miselim Bait
3. Johnny
6. Off the Hook
6. Noraa

Roden, butterflies - 0
Johnny, BB - 2
MB - 4
OTH, Noraa - 7

I am curious.

Those who are town can you all do a ranked choice voting system?

0=no vote
1 = least scummy
7 = scummiest

Most points is first pick for scum
Second place is second pick etc

You don’t have to vote everyone.

Could do say Person A =3
Person B = 4
And that’s it if really unsure.

0 = Roden
1 = butterflies
2 = Johnny
3 = Mislim Bait
4.5 = BB
4.5 = OTH
4.5 = Noraa

0 Roden
1 Butterflies
2 Mislim Bait
3 Best Bird
4 Johnny
5 OTH
6 Noraa

0 Roden
1 Butterflies
2 Mislim Bait
3 Johnny
4 Best Bird
5 Noraa
6 OTH

Dead thread solved this game before any living player did lmao

[Lukewarm]

Damn mafia prob would have lost then? I guess that's the thing with massive games, harder to keep track of things for players and mods

I think me around for another day or two would have changed a lot.

Hard to tell what ifs.

It’s a weird situation all around.

I know that it is hard to imagine what all would have gone differently if Taly had been hammered with Bell's 6842 -- But I don't think that it would have actually bought you much, if any, time. The hammer happened before you made any of the posts that made you look unpartnered with Taly, so if it had locked up then those would never have come.

That being said, you did a great job of not looking partnered with Taly there!

[Lukewarm]

@Drap -- just wanted to also throw my two cents into the ring on your fake guilty.

You seem to think that the scum team having to kill someone other then you is a +town scenario, but turning your own death from a night kill into a day kill is -town. Scum kills always land on town. Day Eliminations are the town's only chance to kill scum.

• You moved the scum kill from townie A (you) -> townie B,
  And then the day Elimination form Maybe Scum -> Yourself, guaranteed town from your POV.

You deprived the town of a possible scum elimination by making yourself be eliminated. And you seemed to think that it outed Nancy as a wolf, but that was even proven false, so the benefit you thought you got was not even real.

Just... push C/G next time. Like, they were fairly likely to have died then anyways lol

[Lukewarm]

Protection on me tonight please.

Doc on me baby, time to carry this game.

As a small note, posts like this on day 1, when you are very unlikely to be the night 1 elimination, can definitely contribute to you getting roleblocked night 1.

The moment you claimed to be blocked night 1, I remembered these posts lol.

[Lukewarm]

(Because he still said it was good in the dead thread, even after both the C/G flip and his own miselim, which I had just read lol)

[Lukewarm]

@Bell

Spoiler:

what are players you definitively townread?

Probably

CSF, Dwlee, Roden. Luke

.

Nancy

just below.

pooky

below that. Currently. But I tend to change on a dime with that one.

Klick

far below that but still in town read land. Sort of.

I think it would be worthwhile to try to sort

PD

. Right now I lean town based on approach but it’s hard to sort the hyper competitive ones.

100% accurate day 1 town reads.

Much impressed.

[Lukewarm]

(Because he still said it was good in the dead thread, even after both the C/G flip and his own miselim, which I had just read lol)

I don’t think he was ready to hear it. It will only work to help him when he’s ready

I hope butterflies flipping town helps him.

And as for that, maybe Taly flipping then changes things. But I would also get two days to recouperate from covid and maybe I don’t suck as bad and maybe Bella isn’t guiltied,

It’s too hard to tell with what ifs so unless I can learn from it I try not to focus on it.

Ah.

When I read your comment on the Day 1 elim, I jumped to the conclusion that you thought your distancing from Taly would have bought you a few days in the thread, similarly to how people wanted to townbin Taly after your flip, and I realized that the hammer actually came before all of that distancing.

If that was not your intent, feel free to ignore

[Lukewarm]

if Taly had been hammered with Bell's 6842

Also @bell, you did an accidental hammer this game

[Lukewarm]

So I went to check if the night Malcolm was jail kept, if he actually did the kill or of scum tried to kill drap. And...

Lmao

Night 6 Actions

Killing

---

kills no one (no action submitted by mafia

)

Investigative

Locke (Professor Drapion) Tracks BBT (visited professordrapion)

Protective

Jack (BBT) protects profdrapion

Misc

Ana Lucia (CSF) JKs MalcomTucker

Not Used

Daniel (Off The Hook)

[Lukewarm]

There are nuances lost in summary.

I also feel like Toogs approach towards you in the pt was more suspicious then his big post in the main thread led me to believe.

His comment about not being sure you could be different alignments did not line up with his posting in the pt

[Lukewarm]

My PT partner brought up the fact that they don't trust me, that I could be scum, and that I basically asked for a free pass through Day 1.

---

I have not read anything other than my PT. I actually didn't consider the possibility that my partner might consider us unaligned. Based on my show knowledge, I actually would have thought us Masons if my PM didn't specifically call us neighbors.

The "I didn't consider the possibility that my partner might consider us unaligned"

Contrasted with this

You basically asked for a pass in thread.
One you don’t deserve based on what I know of your role.

What do you know of my role? All I know is that we are neighbors.

Feels incongruent