RealTime Mafia (Game Over due to too many modkills.)

[Percy]

Vote: ortolan

Wasting words, stating the obvious.

5, 126/12000

[Percy]

Postless:

alvinz95
Raging Rabbit
Sun Tzu
xyzzy


Lurking worse than verbosity.

Unvote
Vote: alvinz95

6, 205/12000

[Percy]

FL wasting our time, let hypothetical vig make up their hypothetical mind. Idle afternoon important.

Vote: forbiddenlight

Prod: alvinz95, Sun Tzu

15, 1079/12000

[Percy]

Postless:

alvinz95
Raging Rabbit
Sun Tzu
xyzzy


Lurking worse than verbosity.

Unvote
Vote: alvinz95

no

Why? Lurking is OK because it's wasteless?

7, 1312/12000

[Percy]

Still suspicious of FL.

veerus: Distancing? Appearing favourable to animorpherv wagon without vote? Explain.

14, 1697/12000

[Percy]

I lost my role PM anyways.

Please defend yourself

NOW

. I'm not sold on lynching (poor initial case), but refusal to defend making it worse.

Veerus = scum or scumpartner.

I'm liking a animorph lynch more now from his ridiculous play last few posts.

So you AGREE with me that animorph's last few posts were scummy while at the same time claiming that I'm scummy because I voted him for it??

You are right about animorph being scummy, but how you did not make a notion about animorph's scumminess before (correct me if I'm wrong), and how you now suddenly vote when put under pressure leads me to think that you are trying stay under the radar and that you are scumpartners. Typical scumpartner play.

Not sold on ani, but veerus is scummy.

Unvote, Vote: veerus.
FoS: forbiddanlight

for continued pointless discussion.

Meji_fan, what arguments persuaded you? More details!

38, 2740/12000

[Percy]

Veerus scummiest by association here.

Agreement - animorpherv1's scumminess would forge stronger case. But compelling argument remains if ani town - he wanted to help animoprherv's wagon without actively voting. Either way, he's scummy.

FL: Referring to:

Should I ignore RR? But...wisely, no more speculating

...then three more posts on issue.

Meji_fan, what arguments persuaded you? More details!

157 and 158

You're

only

reason is word use?!

Don't understand veerus "distancing".

Argument requires ani, Jebus and veerus to all be scum. Jebus attempts to bail out ani, veerus distances from both and shifts focus to Jebus. Occam's razor, though.

lynching townie, although not good in it's own right, is better then no lynch.

No.

71, 3919/12000

[Percy]

lynching townie, although not good in it's own right, is better then no lynch.

No.

actually, yes.

My mistake - lynch gives more info, better. Sorry...

Mod: why have quotes counted towards limit?

8, 4431/12000

I won't be answering questions in green/bold.

[Percy]

new post by veerus, more tunneling...scummeh

pretty sure my word-wasting consisted of attacking Surye (scum) for doing so and then breaking the cycle of crappy contentless posts

Tripleposter -> irony.

Indeed, also unhelpful vague defenses. Big scumread.

FoS: ortolan

RR also refusing to clarify

and

wasting words.

The argument you claimed I made makes no sense. You should read the post as two seperate sentences, like I meant.

Agree with FL on this - backtracking. First reading makes most sense, seems intentional.

I expressed a town read of Ortolan before the whole jester thing even came up

Are you talking about this:

ortolan hate is stupid.

?!

Also protecting ortolan and stringing town through long stupid argument,

and

yesterday's Jester.

Vote: Raging Rabbit

794/10500

[Percy]

and yesterday's Jester.

Huh?

Jester speculation doesn't mean much, ortolan clearly knew he wasn't gonna prevent the lynch.

Defending ortolan. How did he know? You assume sensible play after Yesterday?!

Example

of too much faith in ortolan.

984/10500

[Percy]

alvinz, happy with vote on Rabbit.

Your points are awful. First one maybe, not others. Especially NK speculation!!

Trying to move lynch to ortolan's detractors?

1103/10500

[Percy]

Well, your attack was extremely crappy

explain

unhelpful vague defenses.

If I was aware voicing suspicion of a jester was considered a scumtell (and would then be manipulated by players such as veerus) I wouldn't have.

You kept vote on, but suggestion reads as desperate, innocent-seeming attempt to save ani. Yesterday:

anyway since discussion seems to have moved on...i'll share my suspicions.

According to Natirasha we've only used ~1/6 of our words so no need to hurry into a lynch

the bandwagon against animorpherv doesn't seem much stronger than that against anyone this game has been for wasting words

I dislike him claiming to have "lost his role pm"- this is lame regardless of him being scum/town. This alone makes him a decent default lynch when the time comes.

this was first post that caught my attention. he's subtlely defending ani. nothing wrong with defending someone...but way he does it seems scummy to me.

What was "subtle" or "surreptitious" about what I said? I made the point that the case against him was just another variant of the "wasting words" case which has already come up many times this game. I then said his comment about the lost role pm renders him a decent default lynch anyhow. I'm not *really* defending him anyway, and if I were, what was scummy about it? You've provided no reasons.

Reads as attempt to stall lynch. Also admits to *sorta* defending (now) known scum.

Also,

FoS: Meji

; uselessness.

1245/10500

[Percy]

Oh yeah, I was scummy as hell. Don't think I did a very good job, but I was passable I guess. I framed ortolan, as he seemed a good target for a lynch the next day.

In terms of game format, I think this game definitely has potential. I hope you run something like this again, but perhaps a smaller player group would be better. It's hard to get good reads on anyone with so little words, so if you halved the wordcount and the playercount perhaps you'd end up with more invested players. I'd be totally up for RealTimeII.

Sorry about the accident, Sens. Hope you're recovering OK