Stars Aligned II - Game Over!

[startransmission]

Hrm, still trying to grasp the back and forth on the merits (or lack thereof) of claiming noise/wards. Seeing as how most people have already claimed and how apparently claiming last game led to a town win- I heard no noises and I warded nobody.

I think the dramonic wagon, though understandable, is a bit premature. No one is a murderer yet, but there are scum already. We should be trying to lynch scum, not a later potential 3rd party.

I think the point is that dram either rolled cult -or- he rolled investigator who will choose to become a murderer. Why are you not thinking about the scenario where dramonic rolled cultist?

vote slysly

I actually agree with slysly. The meta on Dramonic does make it likely that he would choose a third party route. So the wagon is justifiable- but it's still speculation... he could not have gone third party. I don't see where slysly said he wasn't cultist- there's just no evidence to substantiate that.

[startransmission]

animo...

Your post summarised is that:

Play townie very scummy
You scum hunt very badly
You chose an action with no benefit
and now you've handicapped yourself even further with an insanity

And you want us to keep you alive til day 4 so you can contribute

^Beat me to it.

That's how I take your post as well, animor. And I'm supposed to take you word that all insanities you garner from here on out are due to harmless and wasteful night actions?

Vote: animorpherv1

And nobody's really claiming alignment, just if they heard noise and/or warded somebody.

[startransmission]

@Animorpherv- Are you serious that you took a insanity intentionally over getting some of the tools to either help in information or effect?

....

I never actually thought about Searching. My main goal was to try to help out town in an unconvetional way Night 0, and I figured since I'm of no help to town, then I might as well get rid of my vote, but still post and contribute.

This is some of the most bizarre logic I have ever faced. How does wasting a night action, and losing the value of your vote, help town? Conventionally or otherwise? It seems your inability to help town is a self fulfilling prophecy.

[startransmission]

I give up. I stalked Adel.

Reasoning:

Adel is a good player -> What if he's cult -> If he is we're all screwed.

Wow. I can't argue with that logic.

[startransmission]

@Chaco (and animorpherz1 too I guess)
That explanation makes a lot more sense than laundering (but only because any explanation would make more sense than laundering). If he did stalk, then he MUST be town currently. I am still not certain of his honesty now though.

I think that we can now be certain of his honesty. He's lied already, who's to say he's not lying again now?

@iLord
Of the options I see, I'd put them in the following order of likeliness from most to least:

(1) Cult lying to explain a future insanity gain.
(2) Town that made a horrible Night Zero decision.
(3) Stalked night one in hopes of going Murderer.

Despite him now claiming that he in fact did #3, I still believe this to be #1. Either way, it's lynch worthy.

Cue obligatory "That was awfully convenient..." @ Ani/Sajin. O_O

Are you trying to say that they set this up together? Seems like a bit of a reach.

[startransmission]

I guess it's of no use that I've chasnged my plan to search tomorrow?

Not when you're as untrustworthy as you've proven yourself to be.

[startransmission]

So, if Adel gets killed, kill Ani? But for today leave him alone?

I'm for currently looking elsewhere. I am against making a solid statement of what to do with Animorpherv1 if Adel is or is not successfully/unsuccessfully murdered. The bridge will be crossed when we come to it. Deciding those things now or in advance is speculative and not beneficial to town.

So if Adel isn't killed then what does that prove? What does it prove if he is killed?

I don't understand not making a solid statement about somebody who has lied and who's every move, current and planned, has been anti-town.

[startransmission]

Excellent. Go out for a meal, some drinks, and a movie and what do you get? Seven pages of action. I haven't read anything since I last posted, but I did glance that there's a break possibility. Adel apparently proposed it. Once I read up on it I suppose I'll comment. But I'm sure no less than 200 posts will happen in that time.

400 posts in a single day? What's the record?

[startransmission]

This is near impossible for a working man to keep up with. Arg.

There's a list and some reason for it. Let me attempt to catch up and perhaps I'll join that list.

[startransmission]

I have no idea what's going on. I refuse to replace out.

You think I'm useless now Magua? You haven't even gotten a glimpse of just how useless I can be when I put my mind to it.

Ok, go on and discuss semantics!

[startransmission]

Quick thing though, as I'm curious.

Magua,

Do you think cult can ward? How might that affect stalks??
How about resurrections? What might that have to do with kills?
Speaking of stopping kills, might ritual have some effect in that respect also?
I'd really like to know how you feel about insanities, the value of searching for them, and how cult could garner them.

[startransmission]

I have no idea what's going on. I refuse to replace out.

You think I'm useless now Magua? You haven't even gotten a glimpse of just how useless I can be when I put my mind to it.

Ok, go on and discuss semantics!

You're probably scum, but in the event that you're not, get the fuck out this game, please.

Where's your vote?

[startransmission]

You're probably scum, but in the event that you're not, get the fuck out this game, please.

And I'd like an explanation of this.

[startransmission]

Good call. He's obvscum.

[startransmission]

@startransmission:
You just acknowledged that you were completely useless and knew it; then stated that you have no plans to replace out.

Eh, you're half right. I'm not useless, I just have a life and almost 900 posts in three days is tough to keep up with. I didn't say I was useless. If I really thought that, then I would replace out. I do have some courtesy.

My questions weren't at all random btw.

And I thought I was the only one here with a throbbing hard-on for Magua! Looks like you got me beat!

[startransmission]

And I thought I was the only one here with a throbbing hard-on for Magua! Looks like you got me beat!

In case that was misconstrued- your Magua buddying is noted.

[startransmission]

Hey what do you say we vote for startransmission instead of Icerink? When poked, startransmission flinches like scum.

When was I poked and when did I flinch?

[startransmission]

Hmm. I suppose that's fine for now. On cursory inspection, it looks like it beats Nicky (e.g. with regard to treatment of ani):

Unvote; Vote: startransmission

...But I vaguely recall reading a game where he was lynched D1 on the basis of erratic behavior. I've never played with him before, though. I can't remember what his alignment was in that game....

What did you find scummy about me when you read my iso?

And in what way am I behaving erratically?

[startransmission]

Hey Startransmission made a bunch of defensive posts and "I will catch up" posts!

@Star- Who do you think is scum?

I don't recall being poked, flinching, or being defensive. I have made a bunch of "I will catch up" posts. What can I say, I've never been in a game like this before. In less than a week there are more posts in this game than most full games I play in that take a month or so.

I'm looking at DGB, Phate, and Iecerint. Phate's buddying of Magua was a little much, DGB making it sound like I was somehow out of control and scummy, and Iece for going along with what I consider a pretty weak argument against me from DGB.

Nothing solid, but they are certainly my focus.

[startransmission]

It's not doing any harm there. I'll move it when I can make a solid argument against somebody else.

[startransmission]

catching up

[startransmission]

Suppose I'll tow the line.

Vote: CSL

[startransmission]

start, no one has claimed yet to have rezzed Phate. Whoever rezzed Phate is pretty likely town. We're not sure if it's you or one of the three people killed last night. Did you rez Phate?

No I did not.