Rapture Mafia - Over!

[bv310]

Would you all kindly join me and

Vote: Horrordude0125

[bv310]

Please don't.

[bv310]

Mein Gott im Himmel, you guys post a lot. I'll try and do a catchup in the next couple hours, otherwise it won't be up until tomorrow afternoon. Flying home for the summer tonight.

[bv310]

Fair enough. Like I said, I'll try to post tonight.

[bv310]

Unvote, Vote: MPR

Seriously, that's the worst iso-read I've ever seen.

[bv310]

Jeez, internet goes down for one day and I miss three full pages.
Here's my catching up post from page 12.

A couple thoughts (In chronological order):

1) Drives' AtE in post 281 is the kind of thing that deserves a lot of pressure. Cracking this early in a game is ridiculous.

2)R_C, I'm sorry to have disappointed you so far. I'll try to get better.

3) The Chronopie wagon was bizarre, to say the least. From what I gather, it grew from a weird choice of words regarding *using* Adam. His posting since that point have grown progressively scummier however. A lot of fluff, following, and this bizarre post:

An outed doc will not serve any use at this point in time, and is likely to be an NK magnet. Therefore we shouldn't bother lynching him.

Upside, He blocks some potential kills. OTOH upside, Mafia Kills him, instead of some more useful PRs. Wait... Upsides all round

Meantime, we can treat him as semi-confirmed, until we have a cc (not endorsing a cc atm).

Meantime, lets lynch some scum. Vote for Sorasgoof everybody.

There is very little in this post that is town in any way shape or form besides saying that a doctor claim on D1 is a bad thing.

4) I agree with Red on the Soras wagon. Seems to be the most likely scumpoint so far.

5) Nacho trying to imply Soras being a jester without blatantly saying it is rather scummy.

6) Everyone calling KoC's Doctor Who reference a claim is either retarded or scum.

So, in conclusion,

Vote: Sorasgoof

Also, KoC, testimony accepted.

[bv310]

Horror, I did not try to PL you. I RVS'd you. Big difference. OTT, I like that post. Nice and to the point.

[bv310]

Wow, looks like I missed a lot in the last day or so. I should be able to post more in a few days (Changing ISPs currently to one that's more reliable)

Anyway, here's a quick catchup post.

First up, the Chrono wagon. I agree with the reasons for it, but I feel like it escalated WAY too quickly. Reaper coming in and MC Hammer'ing was an odd action to say the least, but I don't feel that it was scummy. (I agree with Reck that it's the best hammer ever, though )

OTT, I don't see a whole heck of a lot to comment on.

[Preview Edit]

Really Soras? That might be the worst fakeclaim I've ever seen. If my vote wasn't already on you, I'd be adding another vote.

Also,

FOS: Kise

You never just accept a claim without any flavour justification, especially in a setting as flavourful as this. You just accepting it really doesn't make a ton of sense.

[bv310]

And now you're putting on the pouty face? Awesome. Day 1 scum ftw.

[bv310]

Well, when you try to do everything you can do defend yourself as a doctor and you have to out yourself Day 1, it really makes you doubt the town. Maybe I don't

want

to lose, but I'm doubting our victory.

Enough with the AtEs. Man up and actually try to defend yourself instead of whining about how everyone's playing and how everyone's against you.

I will, however, support a TF wagon.

Unvote, Vote: ToonFighter

[bv310]

If I told you guys that bv was scum... would you believe it? Could you see it?

If I had to lie and claim daycop with a guilty, or lie detector that scanned something bv said and my machine went erratic... would you lynch him with me?

If I even had to say something as anti-town as "lynch me if I'm wrong and he's town" to convince you... would you take it?

I would be extremely surprised to see any of that, especially since I'm not scum. I'd be cool with a 1:1 trade though, since you're either scum making a ridiculous gambit, or some other kind of anti-town role.

Do you buy sora's claim, or do you think Toon is an okay/better lynch?

No, I don't buy Soras' claim whatsoever. As a Bioshock fan, Big Daddy as a Doctor makes little to no sense. Bodyguard, yes. Vig, maybe. But not Doctor.

Seriously, look at this guy.

Nothing about him screams "I want to save people!"

But you never lynch D1 Doctor claims. Ever. That's why I support a TF lynch, since he is second scummiest in my opinion.

[bv310]

If he survives to Day 2, then either the scum know he is lying, or he is scum fakeclaiming. No scum team in their right mind will leave a claimed doctor unless they KNOW he is lying. I'll keep this suspicion as long as Soras continues to be scummy.

[bv310]

In what way is my mindset anti-town? Is it how I'm suspicious of someone else or how I don't believe a very convenient doctor claim coupled with pouting, AtEs, and a lack of any reasonable defense of himself?

[bv310]

I'm not telling them what to do, I'm just saying what I expect to happen.

In LyLo, if he had been playing the way he has so far in the game, I probably wouldn't believe the claim. I don't know if I'd vote for him, but I'd be pretty suspicious.

Also, since I can sense that someone has the urge to step in and answer for bv... please don't.

What do you mean by this?

[bv310]

Really D_J? What possible motivation could you see to requesting a modkill? The ONLY thing you'll accomplish here is making yourself tomorrow's lynch after your scumbuddy flips.

[bv310]

I just don't know anymore. A DJ/TF scumteam doesn't seem too far-fetched at this point. DJ's modkill request seems designed to elicit suspicion and derail the lynch.

On the other hand, I'm still hella suspicious of Soras.

I'mma go find a wall to smash my head against until this all makes sense.

[bv310]

So you requested a modkill because you're too lazy to push for an actual lynch and would rather have the mod do it for you?

Unvote, Vote: Don_Johnson

[bv310]

Awww, Chrono. We were only halfway to the record.

But yeah, I'm glad that's over. See you on the other side, hopefully.

[bv310]

Sorry. Back. Catching up. Laptop hates me, etc., etc.

[bv310]

DJ, you really need to stop asking for modkills. If the mod wants to do it, they will. Asking for it just means you're too lazy to properly play the game.

[bv310]

Well, when I flip VT, please do me a favour and lynch the obv-scum DJ.

V/LA until Monday at the earliest.

[bv310]

I'm leaving for the next 3-4 days. I figured I'd get it out of the way now.

[bv310]

Hey guys, back from V/LA. I reread what I've missed, and would like to reiterate that I still find D_J scummy. Also find the "Backup Little Sister" claim bizarre as all hell. I'm assuming the LS can drain a dead player of ADAM and then give it to someone else, but I've been wrong before.

[bv310]

Oh, so I'm dead then. Oh well, straight VT here. Nice playing with you nice folks. Sorry if I disappointed anybody. My play this game has been atrocious.