^No reaction to this Spy Spy?Patrick wrote:Fate replaces ekiM.
Or DGB?
/grin.
I'll be caught up by tonight, for now let me say I've read the first 8 pages or so and LOL IRONY@Hoopla being the one janitiored.
^No reaction to this Spy Spy?Patrick wrote:Fate replaces ekiM.
OH GOOD LORD.VasudeVa wrote:Tajo, why do you know about my meta/asking about it? I have never played with you before.
kpopulartajo wrote:Thx Flay. At least one of these guys is scum.Mr. Flay wrote:I thought you people WANTED to play together?(it's me, isn't it, doing the job you hired Patrick for...)
Prodding DGB,Elmo, KMD,Plumegranate, Rhinox, and zoroaster for falling behind activity guidelines.
Slicey has a small grace period to his prod, due to weekend V/LA. Elmo and Plumegranate get a bye due to Caffwagon.
DGB, Elmo, KMD, Plum, Rhinox and Zoraster.
Remember to isolate Tajo when you are in endgame and POE gives you a name out of this list.
1) We know the setup to be 2 VIGS and a tracker. Search your soul and if you don't find it there I'll explain next week with two hands. For shenanigans purposes I'll play along as if there were 4 thoughSpyreX wrote:Damnit Fate while I appreciate the awesome we got a few points to cover:
1.) Hoopla scum? I'm gonna need more because while not thrilled that maneuver oozes town.
2.) Sera scum? He's been one with the hatemachine.
3.) VV TOWN FATE NO DONT YOU BE THAT GUY. NO.
Pretty much everything else <3
Tell us what is wrong then, because:ooba wrote: Also, Why wasn't KMD blocked if elmo was the scum kill?
It's suboptimal to try and block a possible role while you already have a claimed informational role. There's something wrong here.
COMPROMISE TIME SPYREX.ooba wrote: 1348 - AD is scum
You ever tried to catchup as scum? Its EXTREMELY more difficult compared to town, as you have to read 55+ pages and come up with bullshit cases. Requires a lot of effort.Kmd4390 wrote:Fate, why is not having a catchup post a scumtell?
One of those two slots is scum. They both played the "overwhelmed" card and didn't comment on the whole thread. Sera wins this scummy race because the first of his catchup posts were easy setup based posts "lol we picked jan+RB heres my thoughts on mafiaz theoryy", then he devoted all of his content to exploiting VVs scummy play.Ok, I can see your point here. I was more concerned with the Sera/Saint points you made though.
Look, this game is suffering from what I'd like to call "Gears of War syndrome" (PAY ATTENTION DGB, COPYRIGHT ON THAT WIKI PAGE BTW)Kmd4390 wrote:FATE LEMME TRY THIS UR WAY
MITH IS SO SCUM AND NEEDS VOTES. HELP ME LYNCH HIM PLZZZZ.
ELLIE YOU CANT WAVE YOUR HAND AND DISMISS THIS^ WITH "LOL OOBA CLASSIX"Fate wrote:NOTHING WORTH COMMENTING ON?
K ooba I'll play ball. LAST TIME you mentioned my slot (eKim) with regards to a read was your d1: "luuuuuuuulz d0 scumhuntinnn" and calling this slot SCUM.
Those posts weren't commenting on? Besides being fresh new stuff from a player your are "GLAD TO SEE" its a slot you APPARENTLY haven't given much thought, AND one that calls you scum with the need to dangle.
Defense? Rebuttal? Read?
NADA.
I don't know WHY this wagon is so god damn hard to push, but this is the A-grade shit Ellie should be voting for and this Ulyssean effort to get ooba lynched will NOT BE FORGOTTEN if he flips roleblocker.
THANKYOU SPYREX IT IS APPRECIATED.
AS FOR NKS I'D SAY VIG NUMERO DOS DIDNT SHOOT TO KILL N1 OUT OF RESPECT FOR HOOPLAS REQUEST, AND PER MITHS PR DIRECTION, THEY SHOT HEROD LAST NIGHT (bc they werent supposed to shoot Elmo unless they shot tajo N1, which was apparently the scum NK, so they shot non-Elmo)
DO YOU REMEMBER THR LAST TIME YOU SAID THIS TO ME?Ellibereth wrote:FATE I WANT TO BOUNCE OVER FOR A SEC I MIGHT BOUNCE BACK K.
UNVOTE, VOTE PLUM
What the hell?PokerFace wrote:Posting while on break, I read alot yesterday and planned to post tonight but car tire went flat on way to work and I barely made it to work late after a go around with AAA. I'll need new tire after work to get home so next time I post is uncertain but I will get something done on the weekend I hope
mith wrote:Kmd: I don't think you're understanding what I was arguing in my previous post ([preview edit]I don't know how you get "therefore if zoraster doesn't know I claimed, he must be town" from my post at all[/pe]). This was my approximate thought process:
a. Oh, zoraster posted, ~reads~, wait, Kmd???
b. Wow, that's one of the biggest "not-a-clue" moments I've seen in Mafia.
c. Maybe that's a point in his favor, though. Surely scum would know what was going on.
d. Though they might to play dumb for WIFOM reasons/so we come to that conclusion...
e. But wait, how could he not know what's going on if he's town? He's been asking about stuff, he's supposedly doing a big reread...
f. Thoughts c and e make actual ignorance a null-tell (hecouldbe ignorant either way, it just seems really unlikely); feigned ignorance can only come from scum.
g. Expressed ignorance is a point against him.
h. I'm already suspicious of zoraster. This is another point against him. Is there anything about his read-post that points toward him being town?
i. No. What Rhinox/Seraphim thing? What concern on Herodotus? His comment on DGB reminds that zoraster hasn't made much of a case on her, and that he hasn't voted her today. Other little wording things (like the MME comment).
j. He's already second on The List, nothing about this reads town, let's put him back at L-1, get a claim, and lynch him.
I wasn't saying that hewasdefinitely playing dumb, nor voting him for that reason; I was saying that the possibility of him playing dumb breaks the deadlock of ignorance and turns it from a null-tell to a slight scum-tell. (If I were just looking for an excuse to vote for him, why bring up the "scum shouldn't be ignorant" point at all?)
As for "explain to me why zoraster could possibly want to act like he didn't know I'd claimed tracker" - I already pointed out one; he dropped from 8 to 5 in a few hours. My own initial reaction was "wow, he has so completely missed the plot, he can't be scum", and it's possible he was trying for that reaction in a last attempt to survive.
If you don't think that's legit suspicion, and that I'm just making up the above thought process, fair enough. You're wrong, but there's not much else I can say to convince you.
zoraster: I want an answer to the question I asked in 1150.
Current thoughts on zoraster - after 1136, playing dumb seems a more distant possibility (if he is, that's an impressive acting job). However, I'm still not seeing how he as town doing a reread and posting thoughts on everyone could have possibly missed the Kmd claim (see ekiM's post).
1155 continues the "ask specific questions" schtick... which doesn't impress given the two specific questions waiting for him at the top of the page. Additional questions:
What "concern" on Herodotus were you addressing in your big post?
What Rhinox/Seraphim "thing" felt like two people on the same side fighting?
TOWN SAYS wrote:That was my thought process here. "He's town, scum would know what was going on" = the Packers. "He's scum, he couldn't have missed that on a legit reread" = the Vikings. "He's scum, playing at being dumb either to make us Packers fans or for some unknown reason" = the Lions and Bears.
oobaSCUMZ wrote:Fate just because I don't feel the need to explain each and every step does not make me more scum .. Anyway you have to read between the lines ..I work on connections. If I cannot see iam\DGB, I'd rather go for the stronger connection I see in mith\Rhinox\Plum. Plum wagon was looking like it would lead to a lynch so made sense to vote her ..ooba wrote: - iam was scummy since I saw a possible iam\DGB pairing but iam seems genuine in wanting DGB lynched.
>_>Rhinox wrote:I don't get this. why the change?Ellibereth wrote:FATE I WANT TO BOUNCE OVER FOR A SEC I MIGHT BOUNCE BACK K.
UNVOTE, VOTE PLUM
---------------
HH 1466 - ok, understand.
---------------
Just as a FYI, I'm going to be running around an awful lot in between Ohio and PA this weekend, starting tonight, so I'll be even less active this weekend than I normally am on weekends. Sorry.
$50 says he doesnt post before the lynch.Seraphim wrote:Wow. I feel just absolutely apathetic about this game but I don't want to replace out.
That being said, a brief cursory glance at the wagons running right now...I think I would definitely go for a DGB wagon. I need to read back the last few posts, get some context...expect some more from me in a little bit while I try to get back into this.
The combined towniness of mith+Kmd willed it to be, and so it was.SpyreX wrote:I missed the memo where Plum making a good post meant leaping to DGB and not ooba.
But, I'm down for stuff.
Unvote, Vote: DGB
STILL WOULD <3 OOBA MORE BUT