Ghostlin wrote:Bunnylover wrote:Ghostlin wrote:EBWOP: This is the Bunnylover case/ISO. Most of the analysis posted by this player is WIFOM, fishing blantantly for Locke Lamora's role, a vote for us to Policy Lynch someone with a post restriction while not making a case why he's scum, sheeping, somewhat untrue setup speculation, and is generally somewhere between scummy and unhelpful in general.
Wait what.
Fising for LL role? A person said they knew LL role (name) and I wanted LL to confirm that so in case LL is scum he fake claims something that Zoraster didn't say while LL had already agreed that that was his claim. I wasn't asking for powers or anything, I don't see how a name claim is harmful. For example if LL had said, "Oh Yes I am that person," when Zoraster had fake claimed the first time, we would have a confirm scum on our hands or maybe dead not sure how it would go down. Plus I wasn't the only one who asked for it.
Name claim =/= Role claim.
I explained why we should lynch Raivann and Hasdgfas (before the vig shot). Yes Hasdgfas was more on the PL line, but I explained why.
Sheeping what? Where have I sheeped?
Setup Speculation? If I'm speculating about the setup how do you know its untrue unless you have inside knowledge that would prove it untrue? Since your withholding that information would that make you anti-town?
1)...The Has case was weak to the point of nonexistant. You didn't bother to expand it any with proof of how/why he would BE scum. You just went 'bad post restriction is bad.'
2) My point is, why should LL have to claim
anything
seeing the 3rd party claim and LL wasn't a suspect?
3) You sheeped onto the Raivann wagon with kinda a 'lol, that post sucked', (I'm paraphrasing) didn't expand that at all, and indicated you'd jump onto a Zoa wagon once you found out the reason he lied. (You never did, but indicated willingness too.)
4) I didn't say the speculation was untrue, I said it was unhelpful: NK's are the most nebulous way to get information about a setup. The number of NKs should not been taken as a credible bit of information, and yet you seem(ed) to want us to take this as evidence.
1) It was a PL, yes, I already admitted that. I never said Hasdgfas was 100% scum, just don't want to wait till the 6th day with 6 people left and Hasdgfas is still their and were wondering is the cow scum faking a PR or what.
2) Did you not read what I posted? Yes its unlikely for that to happen, but always good to get even the smallest chance of something out of the way. I don't see the harm in one person name claiming, so I'm confused why this is bad? Did we know he was 3rd party? No we didn't. I hate that LL never had the chance to respond to the claim, but I saw no harm it could do for LL to name claim and if he had name claimed the first time Zoraster fake claimed, Zoraster would have been lynched sooner (be it like 8 post sooner, but still).
3) You didn't read my Raivann should be lynched before Zoraster post where I showed the scenario of what could happen for each flip. It made more sense to lynch Raivann. Raivann wasn't doing anything to help the town. Raivann was just here, made several unexplained votes, made that stupid post of "Don't vote me I got a town read on you," which is just ew. I had my own reason to vote Raivann.
Zoraster, yes I was going to join the wagon, but not till
I SAW HE LIED
. I go by the rule, lynch all liars.
4) This is what you had said
somewhat untrue setup speculation
. I didn't say, "HEY TOWN WE SHOULD ALL DETERMINE HOW MANY GROUPS THEIR ARE BY THE KILLS IN THE NIGHT." Thats how I do it, yes. I was asked by what evidence I was talking about, and thats the evidence I go by.
Your trying to make something I said that has no significant meaning into something giant. Their probably a lot of other things you can find about me to push your lynch on me without having to grasp at straws.
@Magua: Not sure where I'm going to put my vote. I'm debating with-in my head rather or not to vote Raivann, but if he town he just such an easy mislynch. I mean even I think he's scum, and I'm useless in my reads almost all my games except for three and one was with like 8 people left.