In post 6031, Catbug wrote:I wanna know what you think about them individually. Like what comes to mind for each.
I just told you, I'm not sure and I couldn't just briefly explain my thoughts on them individually. I'll try to do that later.
In post 6032, mastin2 wrote: In post 5996, Toogeloo wrote:"beast can't be that stupid, and scum have access to certain abilities that were able to get his role exactly on day 1, and they were planning on claiming masons with him when the other mason is probably in play somewhere, and they couldn't actually confirm themselves because they aren't really masons."
Or, far more simply,
Scum knew his ability was in the game, but not who it belonged to. Titus, KNOWING SHE WAS CONFSCUM AND GOING TO GET LYNCHED (you are conveniently ignoring this quite important fact; scum claiming role info is SCUM claiming role info), fished.
Nobody is ignoring anything. You're just twisting facts to fit your arguments. Titus was only confscum after Matt revealed his result. She claimed what she had been blatantly crumbing since the start of the game. I doubt she was planning on becoming confscum and that she planned her claim with that in mind. And why would she not claim it? Or why would she claim anything else?
In post 6033, mastin2 wrote:
It's a self-targeting GLOBAL action. As in, I get a list of every (digital? Don't remember off the top of my head) action taken during a night (but not who was targeted), similar to TWIE's ability of globally seeing every player targeted but not by what action.
I used it N2.
You know.
The night there was doubt about pidgey's ability being real.
Fuck yes they're going to sabotage an ability that can CONFIRM PIDGEY'S ABILITY AS EXISTING, and thus making him conftown.
So, your role usage and its presumed sabotage was all about Pidgey? I can't even describe what I think about this, but I just can't believe that you'd use it with confirming Pidgey's role as your primary reason. Mostly because I don't think there was that much doubt about Pidgey's claim. Then, that role could possibly confirm more than just Pidgey, who was already pretty town. Yet, you're saying scum sabotaged you because they didn't want Pidgey to become conftown, which is even weirder than you claiming to use the role to confirm Pidgey. If they did sabotage you, it wouldn't be to prevent Pidgey from becoming conftown, but to hide their own actions and prevent other town players' roles from becoming confirmable, Pidgey's role not being confirmed would be collateral. Because I also don't think they'd have been able to go through with a Pidgey mislynch on day 3.
And it's not like he had some extraordinary reads. IIRC most of them were pretty in line with the general opinion at the time.
. But you seem to be implying that even if he's scum you wouldn't want to lynch him because he'd just be a sacrifice to protect a partner and so you'd rather look for the partner?