BM's Mystery Mafia!! GAME OVER???

[GodOfWine]

after a long look at the evidence,

vote: Albert B. Rampage

[GodOfWine]

after a long look at the evidence,

vote: Albert B. Rampage

This is why you don't do drugs, kids.

drugs, dice, they are equally random.

his name is blasphemy

only to those imprisoned by monotheist supernaturalism

[GodOfWine]

I prefer the name Bacchus, AlSleet. I'm not a hedonistic Greek, more of a gladiatorial Roman.

[GodOfWine]

unvote: Albert

VOTE: JDodge

Keep fishing.

[GodOfWine]

yeah thanks SirWario, it was a joke. i guess everyone else took it literally. it would be pretty stupid to make such a boldly scummy statement "keep fishing". i thought everyone would pick up the sarcasm. guess not

[GodOfWine]

GodOfWine wrote:
unvote: Albert

VOTE: JDodge

Keep fishing.

How was JDodge fishing about someone else fishing.

To answer that, I was not commanding JDodge to "keep fishing". I was saying generally, as to an audience, "Keep fishing!" It was a joke, we got past that part.


The whole vote was just to imitate JDodge's previous post. I was not intending to start a mass movement. I really dont find him scummy at all so I guess I can't justify keeping a vote on him. I will be watching all those people who were eager to interpret a little playfulness as a chance to gang up on the funny guy. You know who you are. (cough, AlSleet, ~N9V~, pulsewidth, cough) I'm not FoSing though. More of an IGMEOY.[/quote]

[GodOfWine]

I meant to do this at the end of my last post.

unvote

I have made my three suspcions clear. (There may be more that I forgot to include who had similar actions. Consider yourselves included.)

[GodOfWine]

I agree. Miscounting the players, especially when you weren't even trying to prove anything except to the mod cant be anything but an honest mistake. He has warranted an

FoS: ~N9V~

[GodOfWine]

Hmm, I have to say that recent activity has prompted me to

vote: ~N9V~

It is a combination of the reasons from post 112 (and the surrounding conversation) and the way he defended those accusations. [quote="~N9V~]^^Cuz I was posting my thoughts as i read...[/quote]
I need a little more substance than that. ~N9V~, if you'v got the substance, let me hear it to clear your name.

[GodOfWine]

Excuse me, ~N9V~, apparently you misinterpreted me. I meant that your response sounded like a flimsy wad of horse faeces. Even if it is the reason you posted the same theory twice, I didn't like the threory in the first place. So take my vote and cherish it, because it will be there until you convince me otherwise.

[GodOfWine]

In this little situation, I am defnitely more a fan of pulsewidth and YagamiLight's opinion that you gotta look at everything, because as YL said, they add up. Xdaamno, this reasoning sounds like you are trying to get something overlooked.

[GodOfWine]

Thanks Nelly for that awesome post which allowed SirWario to realize N9V's fatal flaw. Every single conclusion N9V has come to is based on the assumption that JDodge is indisputably townie. Now I'm not really suspicious of JDodge at all, but it is strange that N9V would make the

assumption

. We all know what happens when you assume...

[GodOfWine]

Oman: If you love Nelly's case and agree with it, it's a little strange not to put the vote on. You're not a hammer vote and Day 1 would really be only marginally closer to being over. Do you still find bobby scummier than N9V?

[GodOfWine]

If N9V is town, he should be able to convince us of it without claiming at this point.

[GodOfWine]

You disagree, I take it.

This here, is what I call trying to close a topic. You're trying to shrug the subject off by framing it as a simple difference in opinion that cannot be helped, or investigated further. I find this very telling about the alignment of a person, since townies will rather defend themselves then let suspicions slide off them as new suspicions arise.

I heartily agree. That dismissive attitude that arises when scum cant logically defend something they said is most telling. Bobby rises a few scum notches in my book.

[GodOfWine]

Alright.

unvote, vote: Albert B. Rampage

For possibly the strangest play I have ever seen, and for responding to SirWario by saying "Stay out of this newbie" or something to that effect. I don't like rudeness.

[GodOfWine]

Personally I think ABR just went totally and completely insane, right before claiming to kill jordan, and then it being revealed he had killed Bobby. The whole devilish "test that you have passed" speech makes me even surer that ABR has become, shall we say, unstable.

[GodOfWine]

If this is a gambit, I am a fucking brilliant man

Cop killers are certainly brilliant.

[GodOfWine]

I'm sorry I will try to be more insightful.

[GodOfWine]

Well then sorry, I will try to be more analytical.

[GodOfWine]

Sarcasm, Oman, sarcasm. I am not really very concerned with your request right now. I have said my piece. I want ABR lynched. All he does is give us more and more reason to lynch him every post, especially very recently. Why don't you get off my case and look around you?

[GodOfWine]

Oman thats just stupid. Hes the best lynch, you know it and you're just struggling to keep the mentally insane member (ABR) of your evil mafia trio alive. (you and erg0 are the others, naturally) you manipulative little hound.

we must lynch ABR because I said so, and I am King.

[GodOfWine]

I was extremely serious, Oman, you are correct. ABR recklessly killed the cop. What is townie about that?

[GodOfWine]

I can't understand why the "too scummy to be scum" defense is still standing. I apparently am the popular vote now because I decided to promote voting for the player who just killed our cop without wanrning or precaution. I'm sorry if I'm the only one who finds that scummy, and would like to rid the game of a player who will continue to act recklessly.

Oman and Erg0 who like to defend ABR, you have a tendency to build your defense on the

assumption

that ABR is town. Stop that.

[GodOfWine]

By royal decree, I force you to believe me!

[GodOfWine]

No I will not say they were jokes.

Also my case against ABR has less to do with killing a COP then it has to do with the reckless manner by which he was killed.

[GodOfWine]

Yes erg0, I am saying that wasn't a joke. Fruitless, yes, but quite serious all the same.

unvote, vote: Oman

For: shamelessly defending ABR and not heeding my royal decree (well no one did but whatever hes the most vocal)

[GodOfWine]

Obviously no one has actually been reading anything I say. JordanA24 and SirWario, you have both questioned me using logic that is based on the fact that I was dead sure ABR was scum. Not true. I thought his behavior was very scummy, but the main reason I put the vote on him was because of the erratic and reckless play that I thought would endanger the game down the road. Forcing someone to "claim or die" as ABR did is wild gameplay and killing bobby with no warning only increases his wildness. I thought his character (Hydrogen was it?) put everyone at risk without logic. And SirWario, get some balls and slap a vote on me, like everyone else.

And as a side note. People should pay more attention to the posts I make. Not to what I'm saying but the words that I say it with.

[GodOfWine]

Anyway I'm going to claim, seeing that my future seems a bit uncertain here. When I mentioned reading my posts a little closer, I was talking about looking at the language that I had used because I was trying to surreptitiously claim. I was a little upset that my royal decree was ignored because I am

KING ARTHUR, vanilla townie

. All I've got on my side is valor and a sense for justice.

[GodOfWine]

Well, I started using the regal wording once I started becoming frustrating that I could have such a powerful title with no real power, besides your standard vote. I know that this game has crazy role names and everything, but Hydrogen is still a weirdo claim in my mind. It just doesn't sit well with me, especially giving "hydrogen" the power to kill.

[GodOfWine]

I guess it makes more sense than I thought earlier. I don't know I'm still inclined to believe that roles based on inanimate objects wouldn't exist. First of all (and maybe I'm being too literal for the situation). When everyone convened in the woods at the start of the game, why would we have counted Hydrogen among us? It's invisible!

[GodOfWine]

Good point, Nelly, I guess the name claim really is insignificant as long as it is somewhat cryptic. The only thing that may bother me is the possibility that you may be nameclaiming broccoli to help ABR out of a jam explaining the Hydrogen claim, but that seems like wild unfounded speculation even to me.

[GodOfWine]

Okay as long as more than one person is willing to vouch for these exceptionally weird names, then I am just fine accepting Hydrogen as a participant. Just needed a little reassurance.

[GodOfWine]

unvote, vote: N9V

I really dont like the way Oman attacked me, but I guess I have to attribute most of that to the erratic messages I had posted. I will return to my previous suspect

[GodOfWine]

Well, I have been thinking of things to say for a while that would be new and revealing, but I really can't add much more. My vote is where it is going to be (on N9V) and I'm just letting you guys know I'm alive out there.

[GodOfWine]

FOS:Oman

I didn't like the way he was playing before, and now that feeling is returning. He seems fine to accept that he doesn't have that valid of a reason for voting Xdaamno.

Also,

Vote: Xdaamno

Also, I'm not sure what you guys see in Oman. He's looks like a frustrated pro-town player to me.

Oman has been attacking xdaamno all game, but he hardly seems to care. I also really don't like when people use the reason "I didn't like that post but I don't know why" to draw attention somewhere. It's usually just that you don't have enough information to make a real case, or that nothing suspicious actually existed. But once you call something suspicious, everybody has a tendency to ACCEPT that it was suspicious because somebody else said it was. Then you get the problems of over analyzing and the like.

[GodOfWine]

I usually have bad relationships with people who prefer to elongate the day period of the game. I agree with Fritzler about moving as quickly as possible, not because we'd become side-tracked but because you need to jump on the scums mistakes and tells before they get a chance to confuse you with wordiness and circular logic. They basically start filibustering until people get tired of dealing with them and change their attention.

Get em while they're hot you could say.

[GodOfWine]

That was in response to Xdaamno. Thought I was on the last page but was still a whole page behind.

[GodOfWine]

unvote, Vote: Oman

HoS: Xdaamno

These two guys have been at the top of my scumlist for about 10 pages of posting. Earlier, I was more suspicious of Oman, then more recently xdaamno.

[GodOfWine]

EBWOP: (last sentence omitted) Now Oman pulls ahead in the race again.

[GodOfWine]

This game has no direction at all.

[GodOfWine]

ABR, that was useless.

[GodOfWine]

If someone else puts Oman at -1, I will hammer.

I wish I could vote again for this purpose.

[GodOfWine]

People like MoS and Shanba are kind of annoying me here, by voting for people who are in absolutely NO danger of being lynched. If you're only doing this so that later you can say "Look I voted for this guy back when no one else did!" just put a freaking FoS on them and let it go. MoS vote/unvote was totally weak. Shanba's vote on Setael was retarded. Oman should just self-vote and let TCS do the honors.

[GodOfWine]

vote: Erg0

Post 1036 is absolutely incoherent babble.

[GodOfWine]

Okay, okay, its not incoherent its just worthless.

[GodOfWine]

Point is, we didn't fully adopt the plan, and therefore this isn't relevant to anything. At all.

You can't tack this on to the end of your most detailed post and then expect it to be taken seriously. I actually agree with the plan you proposed, I just can't see it actually being organized because there would always be some morons who didn't see the logic and refuse to adhere, based on the logic those moronic refusers are supposed to be automatically forced to hammer, and I'm sure there will be more than one.

Also, since the vote count has been reset, we would have to wait for Oman to return to L-1, which I don't think is even going to happen.

[GodOfWine]

Until there is a new vote leader, I will not reconsider my vote.

[GodOfWine]

And I was persecuted for my voting Oman earlier. I guess that doesn't make up for the fact that I helped kill the doc. Just know, I never succumbed to voting for CES.

[GodOfWine]

EBWOP: (add "today" to the end of that post)

[GodOfWine]

I say go after zu_faul because I am not a fan of his play style.