[phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Undefined array key 13927795 [phpBB Debug] PHP Warning: in file [ROOT]/ext/alfredoramos/seometadata/event/listener.php on line 114: Trying to access array offset on value of type null Cheese Thief | Game 1 Over - Mafiascum.net
Post
Post #43 (isolation #6) » Tue Oct 03, 2023 2:39 am
Postby Skygazer »
anyways how are we going to reveal who saw the cheese when? since silver claw and i woke up at 6am it goes without saying it was gone for us (or we would claim its gone for us i guess if we were paired)
Post
Post #104 (isolation #9) » Wed Oct 04, 2023 12:49 am
Postby Skygazer »
the thing is i can only be the cheese thief if silverclaw is a follower, right?
i still dont see how i could be cheese thief tho considering the cheese was missing before my time and the person who said it was missing and silverclaw can't both be followers with me??
anyways its funny and tragic when ppl shade me just because i've played a good scum game or two
Post
Post #139 (isolation #13) » Wed Oct 04, 2023 6:57 am
Postby Skygazer »
In post 63, NDMath wrote:
Also, I peaked at Silverclaw and saw the 6 so I know he can't be cheese thief, and it seems unlikely for skygazer to be cheese thief either since he claimed before silverclaw.
In post 86, NDMath wrote:
I woke up at 2, cheese was already gone so it was stolen at 1
so in this world, i woke up alone, stole cheese at 1am, picked someone randomly as a follower, claimed a random time, and got really lucky??
why in the world should i be included in the split lol
In post 133, camelCasedSnivy wrote:
its the same thing where we just have to decide who isn't a follower but whoever votes who doesn't really matter because the follower can pivot from a non-thief
For this to happen you'd have to put faith in me because I'm supposedly Math's follower, mallow is supposedly yours, and Silver is supposedly Sky's, and I'm not letting either of mallow or Silver vote last. And if I'm being 100% honest I'd rather just solve it based on dayplay, and based on Dayplay I think it's Skygazer. She was just sitting on her laurels, knowing she's "confirmed", and didn't try to solve at all. Also when I asked Silver if he thinks you are thief or not, I really didn't like his answer.
the game has been open for like 48 hours my guy. have you seen me play before???
Post
Post #141 (isolation #15) » Wed Oct 04, 2023 7:03 am
Postby Skygazer »
like i said earlier, i plan to sit down and map out all the mechanics when i get home. it seems like with everything laid out it'll be easy to solve i just need to have all the facts in front of me.
anyways i always find it stupid when ppl throw shade at me for trying to clear myself as town. like ya scum wants to do that too but getting cleared/firmly townread is literally one of the best things you can do to help town win.
Post
Post #142 (isolation #16) » Wed Oct 04, 2023 7:06 am
Postby Skygazer »
In post 2, Mizzytastic wrote:
The player with the most votes, or players tied for the most votes will have their role cards revealed. The Sleepyheads win if the Cheese Thief is revealed, otherwise the Cheese Thief and their Followers win.
arguably we could all self vote or vote in a circle and have a 100% win rate
In post 2, Mizzytastic wrote:
The player with the most votes, or players tied for the most votes will have their role cards revealed. The Sleepyheads win if the Cheese Thief is revealed, otherwise the Cheese Thief and their Followers win.
arguably we could all self vote or vote in a circle and have a 100% win rate
we would need to have one person who is confirmed sleepyhead (not thief or follower)
how so?? the language just says we win if a cheese thief is revealed. if we need a non cheese thief left alive then a follower wouldn't necessarily be disqualifying in which case we know silverclaw cant be the thief and would be safe to have as last alive
Post
Post #161 (isolation #21) » Thu Oct 05, 2023 9:26 am
Postby Skygazer »
tbh i agree that autowin is no fun but I'm just trying to aggressively clear myself because I hate being scumread as town, especially when i feel that i shouldn't be scumread. like the mechanical odds of me being thief are fairly low so it's annoying to be scumread in spite of that when i feel like i haven't been particularly scummy this game. it's also interesting to see how people respond to the proposal. in a way, the autowin is me throwing a tantrum about being scumread to force a win lol but i probably wouldn't feel great about it
Post
Post #162 (isolation #22) » Thu Oct 05, 2023 9:30 am
Postby Skygazer »
i don't think there's anything wrong with proposing it, though. plenty of open mafia setups have been broken in similar ways mid-game, and they're usually either tweaked afterwards or deprecated. in this case i feel like a small rule tweak could remove the autowin
i guess scum could also force an impasse and make us guess who is the thief and who is the follower so it's not entirely autowin either
In post 163, Silverclaw wrote:
Feel free to propose it lmao, but if I wanted to break a game over my knees I'd be building more Pathfinder characters right now
That made me genuinely laugh, thanks.
Sky, I get your frustration. I think it's probably not you, but I know it's not me, mallow or Silverclaw and I also don't think it's Math. So I'm proposing you as a "safe" bet.
If it's so annoying to you I can propose math/snivy instead.
I mean getting misread happens and I should learn to cope
In post 75, NDMath wrote:
cheese disappeared at 1
mallow and silverclaw both have two vouches they weren't there at 1
dragoneater and skygazer both correctly claimed a paired time without partner help
In post 83, NDMath wrote:
cheese was stolen at 1
you saw mallow at not 1
it cannot be mallow thief
Post
Post #185 (isolation #32) » Thu Oct 05, 2023 1:34 pm
Postby Skygazer »
so that's like a 1/9 chance of DE70 being thief, compounded by the fact that if he were the thief, he claimed his time without knowing the time his follower had, or knowing that his follower was tracked (1/6 chance as he essentially guessed randomly). that's like uhhh 1 / 54 odds, or 1.85%. i think i can just rule him out. maybe you all could do the same for me? :-)
tomorrow i'll think about how the various possibilities have interacted and if they make sense as partners.
Post
Post #189 (isolation #34) » Fri Oct 06, 2023 12:39 am
Postby Skygazer »
cant believe ur trying to make me do work
In post 901, Skygazer wrote:
my role pm is default text color other than my rolename. which is green and not red because i'm definitely town haha
again i don't think it'll help us solve much at all tbh and it seems like a time sink. the same listmod could use different formattings. scum could lie about their formatting. etc etc
In post 4128, Skygazer wrote:
i think scum should shoot me tonight because uhhhhh im conf town
