Mini 559 - Cult Mafia again - Game over

[Pink Puppy]

I was not playing to get recruited.

[Xtoxm]

When CKD turns up I can reference this game Lol

[Xtoxm]

Looks like day is almost over...

I would like to make my claim.

I am a townie; no power role; open for recruitment

I will probably vote Imat soon. But I wanted to claim in case day ended.

Then what was with this?

And the backing BM in lynching his townie?

[dahen]

Well... playing to get recruited is what you get in cult games. I don't have anything against it. Thanks all for a good game.

[Pink Puppy]

Do you not see how claiming that raises a lot of WIFOM questions?

Maybe I'm lying and trying to draw the recruitment knowing it will fail. So Cult doesn't know if they should waste their time trying to recruit me.

Maybe I'm telling the truth but now that I have said it everyone will be looking to lynch me in future, so that makes me less than ideal cult member.

Plus, if I draw the NK, that keeps one of the PR's alive, and takes away a potential recruit for the cult.

Don't you see that my dying helped you?

How would the game have played out if xtoxm or oman, or dahen had died instead of me?

[Xtoxm]

Ok, I believe you.

Well I was being protected so I wouldn't have died.

Are we also to assume you were recruited?

If so, Oman was cleared via cult not having won yet, if Oman was NKed, dahen was still clear.

If you had been recruited, and Oman/dahen NKed, it was game over for town, less we lynched one of you and Norinel killed the other.

If you weren't recruited, which we'd have been forced to assume, only a BM lynch would have been suffiecient, which I don't think you'd have been willing to do.

[Xtoxm]

BM, what were your night targets?

[curiouskarmadog]

I wont bore you with a light flavored scene, since Bm has claimed...

Battle Mage,

Cult Recruiter

, Lynched Day 6

Town Wins!!!

[curiouskarmadog]

The Residents:

1.) Blazerunner --- townie
2.) dahen --- Doc
3.) Elias_the_thief --- townie
4.) Friend of Old --- Mafia Goon
5.) GhostWriter ---townie/Cult Recruit
6.) Battle Mage (GSGold) --- Cult Recruiter
7.) Pink Puppy (lalaland) --- townie
8.) Xtoxm (militant) --- 2 shot Vig
9.) Norinel ---Mafia Goon
10.) Oman --- Nurse
11.) omg_im_innocent_wtf --- townie
12.) (Imat) XreyoX --- townie


Mafia Goon --- Friend of Old
Mafia Goon --- Norinel

Cult Recruiter ---BM(GSGold)
Cult---GhostWriter

Mafia/Cult Doc (can protect against a kill and a recruit) --- dahen
2 Shot Vig (power role) ---Xtoxm (militant)
Nurse (Power role) ---Oman


Night One:
BM recruits GhostWriter - succeed
Xtoxm vigs Elias – succeed
Dahan protects XreyoX – succeed
FoO kills Blazerunner -- succeed

Town/Mafia/Cult 5/2/2

Night Two:
Xtoxm vigs GhostWriter – succeed
Norinel kills GhostWriter – succeed
BM recruits Norinel – fail
Dahen protects Xtoxm -- succeed

Town/Mafia/Cult 5/1/1

Day Three:
Town/Mafia/Cult 4/1/1

Night Three:
Dahen protects Xtoxm – succeed
BM recruits Dahan – Fail
Norinel Kill Pink Puppy – succeed

Town/Maifa/Cult 3/1/1

Day Four:
Town/Mafia/Cult 3/0/1

Night Four:
Dahen protects BM – succeed
BM recruits Oman – Fail

Town/Mafia/Cult 3/0/1

Day 5:
Town/Mafia/Cult 2/0/1

Night 5:
Dahen decides to protect no one.
BM recruits Xtoxm – Fail

Town/Mafia/Cult 2/0/1

I think this town got insanely lucky that BM chose incorrectly for his night choices. I thought BM played a great game and cant believe he was able to talk himself out of the Cop fake Claim.

After Night 1, I thought this town was doomed...

The game only slightly suffered from replacements. The constant prodding of Dahen got annoying fast.

This was my first game as a mod, hope I stayed on top of things enough for you and you got some enjoyment out of it...next game I mod I need to be able to go crazy with flavor though.

[Xtoxm]

I wont bore you with a light flavored scene, since Bm has claimed...

Battle Mage,

Cult Recruiter

, Lynched Day 6

Town Wins!!!

YAAAY!!!!

[Xtoxm]

I think this town got insanely lucky that BM chose incorrectly for his night choices. I thought BM played a great game and cant believe he was able to talk himself out of the Cop fake Claim.

Yeh...Town should listen to their cleared vig more

Not to rub in too much...

The game only slightly suffered from replacements. The constant prodding of Dahen got annoying fast.

I agree that he was too inactive.

This was my first game as a mod, hope I stayed on top of things enough for you and you got some enjoyment out of it...next game I mod I need to be able to go crazy with flavor though.

Yeh it was good fun. I've played a couple cult games now and i've quite enjoyed them both.

Congratz

[Xtoxm]

Oh and well modded and thnx

I don't think you made any mistakes.

[Norinel]

Good game, everyone. I suppose it's doubly MoS'ed when you get lynched because the town thinks you're cult and the cult thinks you're town... I even had some arguments ready to prove I was Mafia (Mostly based on my Day 3 play; I was even dropping some intentional hints by that point), but I couldn't pull that out when there was a good chance of three town left.

As far as PP goes- I meant it when I said I thought she was recruited N2, and I'm surprised to see that I got recruited then.

I think this town got insanely lucky that BM chose incorrectly for his night choices. I thought BM played a great game and cant believe he was able to talk himself out of the Cop fake Claim.

Yeh...Town should listen to their cleared vig more

Not to rub in too much...

Yeah, I was pretty much agreeing with your scumdar for the latter part of the game, but couldn't openly support you too much or the town would get rid of the cult with time left to lynch me.

[Oman]

Dahen: I'm a nurse. You're a doctor. You don't think that should me you don't lynch me?

Anyway, great play, shame BM threw in the towel like that.


Thanks CKD awesome fun setup, great play,

[Guardian]

Yeah Cult Mafia

[Battle Mage]

Dahen: I'm a nurse. You're a doctor. You don't think that should me you don't lynch me?

Anyway, great play, shame BM threw in the towel like that.


Thanks CKD awesome fun setup, great play,

Lol it was an impossible scenario. They were both confirmed, and my claim was shaky at best.

BM

[Oman]

I was so shocked they lynched me over you.

[Xtoxm]

I was so shocked they lynched me over you.

I didn't do that cos I thought you were scum, but cos it was easier than trying to make dahen change his vote in a delayed response argument. By that time it was won.

[dahen]

I would have claimed nurse in this game if I were scum, since a doc was pretty much guaranteed.

The lynch of you, Oman, was much safer, since if you came up nurse, BM would have no chance on earth in swaying Xtoxm. If we instead lynched BM first and he came up town, Xtoxm would probably be confused and I was afraid he might turn against me in that scenario.

[Xtoxm]

I would have claimed nurse in this game if I were scum, since a doc was pretty much guaranteed.

No it wasn't.

The lynch of you, Oman, was much safer, since if you came up nurse, BM would have no chance on earth in swaying Xtoxm. If we instead lynched BM first and he came up town, Xtoxm would probably be confused and I was afraid he might turn against me in that scenario.

No I wouldn't have. You can't have a nurse without a doc. You were as clear as I was by that point...But w/e town won

[XReyoX]

Well done.

[Xtoxm]

Well done.

Sorry I couldn't prevent your lynch...But I think in the long run it helped town to remove a potential recruit, assuming we didn't lynch BM that day.

You shouldn't have got yourself replaced, though.

[XReyoX]

I dunno. I don't think I could have stayed in the game due to external reasons. If I were still alive, my list would have been, from scum to town, Oman-BM-PP-dahen-Norinel. And that would have probably, IMO and not including the possibility that I might have been recruited, lose us the game. Also, I was thinking of claiming bullet proof, although I didn't do it, to save my role. And that would have probably get me killed, too.

Anyway, I'm better off staying out of Mafia games for now. My prediction is telling me that I'm going to lose the next game. And I've got lots of work to do for my mishmash.

Good game mod.

[Imat]

...Good game Town. Good thing you figured this out, or my death may not have been for anything...It may not have served any purpose anyways...Sorry Reyo for playing a bad day, though to be fair BM didn't help...being the CR that he was.

[Elias_the_thief]

Yay for being NKed N1!