alright I got the readthrough done... thank god for days off! a few things popped out to me so I'll try and get to them as best I can, but be warned- I've never been one for extremely in depth posts... First of all I'm going to do something I don't do very well... W!nt3r- I'm sorry. At the time it seemed like your defensiveness was scummy, but now that I read over the thread it was just good gameplay what you were doing. Two people seem rather scummy to me at this point.... First off I don't like j-man's post about posting without knowing his alignment.... kind of confused me. but the more I read, the scummier it seemed. If your town, you'd know it just as if you were mafia youd know it.... unless you are mafia and post as if you don't know it to seem more pro-town(I've done that before as scum). Secondly, TC. To start off, I'm definately not a fan of criticizing other players for their gameplay(ie. your an idiot, you don't speak english, etc.) I've been criticized for my gameplay as town before and it doesn't feel good- joking or not. But moving past that... First scummy move was putting strappado at lynch-2 for a random reason... if your not scum, that definately wasn't a pro-town move. After that, he was rather quiet(I'm not saying that's a scumtell tho- I was too. I understand that school and work are bitches). I don't understand him bringing up the original roles...maybe trying to make us believe that he has a different role when he really didn't? It is a definate possibility that although the roles were re-distributed, it is possible for some people to have the same role. After that, his posts mainly seem to consist of attacking people for extremely vague reasons. I don't like the way he's playing this game... I get a huge scum-vibe from him.
vote: TartarianCerberus