Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[Lord Gurgi]

Hello peeps, I already reread, top of my scumlist is cream. For a lot of reasons that the town in general has already pointed out and because, way back when, he said:

Vote: Gimbo. By the way Gimbo, saying the word 'fuck' so excessively is in no way cool, but it is quite annoying. And remember,

if the town lose, you lose

Why on earth would you vote someone you know is town Cream? Further, how do you know he's town? That and I think that his claim does not exclude him from suspicion.

Second on my list is AlabaskaJ, for a lot of reasons, mostly game behaviour in general.

Third is split between Darla and Syzygy.

Also, no I'm not going to do a PBPA.

PS: Gimbo... -_-

[Lord Gurgi]

now can we PLEASE get back to mafia...????

[Lord Gurgi]

Sorry I haven't posted in a while, call it counteracting Gimbo.

Unvote; Vote: mr. incrediball

Lurking for more than a week and we have a deadline. 'Nuff said.

[Lord Gurgi]

I agree we need a massclaim.

Also, still suspicious of Alabaska. Let's get claiming.

[Lord Gurgi]

I also think we might want to massclaim today

Why?

We need to find Bowser or we lose.

[Lord Gurgi]

I also think we might want to massclaim today

Why?

We need to find Bowser or we lose.

And massclaim will help... how?

How will it hurt? We're at lylo (effectively).

[Lord Gurgi]

I also think we might want to massclaim today

Why?

We need to find Bowser or we lose.

And massclaim will help... how?

How will it hurt?

Peach's identity will be exposed to the scum who don't already know it. Assuming we then do manage to keep the game afloat, we will be stuck in the same position we are now

every day

.

How will it help?

(We're playing argument tennis here... It's fun.)

We will be less likely to lose now. (I agree)

[Lord Gurgi]

I also think we might want to massclaim today

Why?

We need to find Bowser or we lose.

And massclaim will help... how?

How will it hurt?

Peach's identity will be exposed to the scum who don't already know it. Assuming we then do manage to keep the game afloat, we will be stuck in the same position we are now

every day

.

How will it help?

(We're playing argument tennis here... It's fun.)

We will be less likely to lose now.

How!?

We can reason out the scum. Why are you against a massclaim? Don't make me get Pie in here.

[Lord Gurgi]

So your vote counts when you vote the same as Mario/Luigi you're saying? Your role is being coming less and less believable.

No, my vote still counts for zero. I just double what their vote's value is. Clearly, this is what made the lynch happen. Whoever was voting, was a doublevoter as well.

Awwww, you should've targeted me...

[Lord Gurgi]

So your vote counts when you vote the same as Mario/Luigi you're saying? Your role is being coming less and less believable.

No, my vote still counts for zero. I just double what their vote's value is. Clearly, this is what made the lynch happen. Whoever was voting, was a doublevoter as well.

Awwww, you should've targeted me...

Targeted you? I was under the impression that, first of all, you are already a double voter and, second of all, he only doubles mario or luigi, which, according to Gimbo, you aren't.

Oh right. Read RBT's not the inquote I just wanted four votes.

[Lord Gurgi]

My verdict: Too elaborate for a lie, yet believable.

[Lord Gurgi]

FL is tellin the truth.
peach isnt captured stop claiming please.

Why are you so sure, k7?

@flea i know who peach is and its not fl.
so i assume fl is tellin the truth.

Do you not see any holes in this logic?

Killa Seven is logic-proof.

[Lord Gurgi]

Happy birthday FL.

Unvote

Not trusting K7 right now. Are you given a PM every night that Peach is not kidnapped telling you such?

Will claim if Pop wishes.

Why would K7 lie? K7 and faerielord would have to be scum together, have planned an elaborate and counterclaimable plan in the event that they lynched the princess, rather than relying on the

20 in 21

chance that we would simply lynch the wrong person.

I want

ashmite

AlabaskaJ dead.

And yes, claim feather/star results, the sooner the better. Its not like you risk being NKed because of it.

Fixed.

[Lord Gurgi]

C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER

No kidding.

gurgi what reasons do you have for wanting me dead? Baseless tunneling is not exactly in the town's best interest right now IMO.

gurgi what reasons do you have for wanting me dead? Baseless tunneling is not exactly in the town's best interest right now IMO.

gurgi what reasons do you have for wanting me dead? Baseless tunneling is not exactly in the town's best interest right now IMO.

I am not going to dredge up a case from the last 70 some-odd pages. I think you're scum. Anybody who argues can dredge up their own case against the person they suspect. I had to search back to find the case against Mr.Incrediball since

nobody would tell me what it was

.

[Lord Gurgi]

Whatever.

Happy birthday FL.

Unvote

Not trusting K7 right now. Are you given a PM every night that Peach is

not

kidnapped telling you such?

Will claim if Pop wishes.

hey.

Claim now I'm pretty sure pop is cool with it.

Speaking for other players, especially when it isn't true.

The case iamausername has just posted on mr. incrediball deserves some looking into.

Also, although he is throughly Rosso-esque, killa seven should not be let off the hook completely, in my opinion.

Says the guy that has votes on him. Why don't you make your own case instead of following along.

What the hell…I said I was looking into it. I just got home and read his post… I can't magically analyze all of their posts and make cases right away. What I can do is say that the evidence he has presented piques my interest and is an impetus for further scumhunting. Also, I don't see what having votes on me has to do with anything, especially seeing that there is no sound basis for those votes IMO.

This.

Reasons people should vote for Alabaska: he's being awfully defensive

oh no I'm defending myself when attacked; as the dutiful town-aligned player I am I should role over and get lynched for extremely poor reasons you are right

and trying to get people to lynch me

this is an argument? if that counts, chock another argument up for RBT's lynch: he's trying to get people to lynch me

; yet there has yet to be a counterclaim

you may be that role, except that you are scum and steal the vote no matter what and that is why there is no counterclaim

, or proof that my claim is false

again, you are much more likely to be lying about your role than fakeclaiming; I have never said your claim was false outright today

. Basically, since I found him suspicious, now he has to OMGUS me to death

you are stealing this from other people who failed to read the game lol. Love how you just switched onto this after others used it for a reason, even though it doesn't apply at all, because I went after you first genius

. So, let us carry on and lynch this scum.

wrong lol.

Me in bold. FYI lurkers and noobs who are skimming the thread: there isn't a case on me at all. Don't randomly jump on me; you'll end up looking anti-town and foolish. Instead, read the thread. I have disproved every argument against me already and now RBT is grasping at straws trying to keep it afloat.

TSPN, please reread all of my post refuting the argument against me and then tell me why I am scummy. And if you say I'm being defensive, I will steal mod privileges, replace Elias into this game, give him a dayvig, and have kill you

so damn hard

.



Let me say this again:

BEING DEFENSIVE IS IN NO WAY, SHAPE, OR FORM A SCUMTELL.

This even more.

Voting patterms: RS, Cream, RS, Cream, RBT, Cream, RBT.

[Lord Gurgi]

Give: One (1) coin to populartajo

Not that I have any, but it's worth a go.

[Lord Gurgi]

Hmm I'm just thinking here, what would happen if he were to give it to Alabaska to be made into a pill?

[Lord Gurgi]

Really

don't know why this game is dying.

People don't know what to do about the K7/FL situation, and don't want to post to be wrong. Therefore, they are lurking today to see if it was or wasn't a good option to believe it, and then can chime in tomorrow to say that they were right in their suspicions, without having any proof given in thread.

This.

[Lord Gurgi]

Wintermute was in this game?

[Lord Gurgi]

So, I'm replacing someone. I see we are in psuedo-LyLo. Can anyone briefly summarize whats going on right now? And/or any questions you might have for me?

K7 claims that the princess was NOT kidnapped. He says he's toadsworth and that he'd know if the princess were really kidnapped, and also the name of the kidnapper (the latter is unconfirmed I think)

FL says that he's Princess Daisy, and the person that got kidnapped. He'll die tonight but the game won't be over.


Korts said something about how Bowser was the only one who could kill and people are saying it's a slip, let's kill Korts

Goborage during D1 claimed to have a poison mushroom so earlier today people were like "so, why would town have a poison mushroom"...I think we eventually decided items aren't determiners of alignment

Oh, and most importantly, populartajo is confirmed townie, as he was revived D2 by Gimbo or whoever replaced Gimbo. We are giving Pop taj all our base...erm...coins. We also give him one more coin after we confirm our transaction to show we don't have any more coins.

That's most of what I can think of.

I'm the new Gimbo.

[Lord Gurgi]

Now I know what I will be remembered for.

[Lord Gurgi]

Then why is Gimbo (now Gurgi) out of the firing line?

Good question, why is he?

Am I? I wasn't aware that I was. It's just that the game is getting away from an Alabaska lynch.

[Lord Gurgi]

Is there a problem with lynching Daisy? If FL flips Daisy on death we know that K7 is telling the truth, and he should be protected by Alabaska assuming that his claim is true.

[Lord Gurgi]

Ok, I'm back, and will be catching up shortly. A quick skim tells me, though, that I owe you guys a claim.

I'm a Shy Guy, and I'm your guide around here. My ability basically is that I can use a feather for tracking instead of investigating.

Cool role...I have an issue. Isn't Shy Guy a bad guy?

Not in all the games, I think. Mario Party springs to mind.

Consider that DK was only 'evil' at the beginning of the series. Not towards the end. I don't know what to make of his claim however, I would think that investigate > track.

[Lord Gurgi]

What?

I can only track, not investigate.

Exactly, it makes it seem like you are nerfed, investigation is pretty worthless to scum, but track and watch let them find power roles.

[Lord Gurgi]

EBWOP: And that is why it sounds odd to nerf townie, but then it would be a boon to scum.

[Lord Gurgi]

Tajo, which FL are you referring to?

[Lord Gurgi]

I endorse this plan, removal of all power items from unconfirmed hands is a good idea.

[Lord Gurgi]

I endorse this plan, removal of all power items from unconfirmed hands is a good idea.

Yeah, but do we have enough confirmeds to carry them?

We have plenty, do you really think that many people are carrying around fireflowers? Having them and not using them is incriminating on its own.

[Lord Gurgi]

I endorse this plan, removal of all power items from unconfirmed hands is a good idea.

Yeah, but do we have enough confirmeds to carry them?

We have plenty, do you really think that many people are carrying around fireflowers? Having them and not using them is incriminating on its own.

I think more people have mushrooms,actually. And who all is confirmed? I wasn't going to go through 65 pages of back log. I hit maybe 20 of them randomly chosen.

We need a list of confirmed and semi-confirmed people. I can't keep track.

[Lord Gurgi]

All I know is that You and pop taj are apparently the MOST confirmed. I know personally that TSPN is confirmed, but I'm not sure if he's confirmed other than through me. Why is riceballtail confirmed?

Isn't, just can't hold items. Item destroyer for the purposes of the town.

[Lord Gurgi]

Give Mushroom to RiceBallTail.
Give Fireflower to RiceBallTail.
Give Feather to RiceBallTail.
Give Star to RiceBallTail.
Give One (1) Coin to PopularTajo

All townies should be willing to do this. All refusing to do so will get my vote and I will push your lynch come heck or high water.

All actions are serious.

[Lord Gurgi]

Have proved they have no items or coins.

-iamausername
-skitzer
-Natirasha

-forbiddanlight

-somestrangeflea
-Surye
-killa seven
-Gremwell
-TheSweatpantsNinja
-Alabaska J
-farside22
-ting =)
-DarlaBlueEyes
-FaerieLord

-Lord Gurgi

-Cream147
-Korts
-Riceballtail
-ashmite84
-goborage

-Popular Tajo

Crossing him out since he's confirmed like a pro.

Please quote this and cross out your own name when you do.

[Lord Gurgi]

As much as I love your use of my phrase, why am I not on that list?

[Lord Gurgi]

Just in case.

List of possible confirmed

Cream
Ashmite
Farside
Natirasha
Lord Gurgi
Gremwell
TSPN

Confirmed like a pro

Populartajo

Horrible spelling fixed.

[Lord Gurgi]

Hey guys, giving all our coins away is smart, I'm not so sure telling the scum who has what items is quite so smart.

That's not the point, guy who is looking more scummy now, everyone is to remove all their items and coins, because it minimizes the number of variables we have to deal with.

[Lord Gurgi]

I also like the lynching alabaska like I said ages ago plan.

Vote: AlabaskaJ

. This wagon is full of win.

Mod edit
Visible Votecount:
Alabaska J (3): farside22, forbiddanlight, Lord Gurgi

Not voting (14): skitzer, Natirasha, somestrangeflea, Surye, killa seven, Gremwell, Alabaska J, ting =), DarlaBlueEyes, Cream147, Riceballtail, ashmite84, goborage, populartajo

With 17 alive it takes 9 real votes to lynch.

[Lord Gurgi]

EBWOP: Also I can't account for the voting thing, I was not notified of anything more than my item and coin status (which is 0) by the way.

Give one (1) Coin to Popular Tajo

[Lord Gurgi]

Want to kill scum? Then vote Alabaska. Srsly.

[Lord Gurgi]

Forbiddan it wasn't directed at you. It was voted at the non-voting people.

[Lord Gurgi]

I don't see anything wrong with yesterday, scum died.

[Lord Gurgi]

No. Popular voted first.

[Lord Gurgi]

Why didn't you claim when Alabaska did?

[Lord Gurgi]

It's comparative to Luigi and Ghost-Hunter Luigi.

[Lord Gurgi]

I like Alabaska lynch for now. Have liked it for a while. Why is he still breathing?

[Lord Gurgi]

THERE IS NO CASE AGAINST ME.

I dunno, he's pretty clear about this. It's not like he could be overreacting, and forgetting the things that have been put against him because he's scared scum.[/sarcasm]

[Lord Gurgi]

This should be helpful

There's actually a decent reason (for page 1) to believe Alabaska is town right now, btw.

It's not 100% assured, but usually mafia are allowed to talk during day start confirm phases (ie. every newbie game atm). I would think that Alabaska as scum would have at least noticed if his inbox started filling with messages from random people.

I don't like this. Its practically a mass claim on coins, which I think will help the mafia more then us by far.

Alabaska's distrust of a confirmed townie is odd. Add him to the list.

MafiaSSK replaced out as soon as being prodded? Shocking.

Unvote, vote farside.

Where is that coming from?

FOS Alabaska

, might become a vote.

I endorse this post. I seemed to remember alabaska's vote flopping a lot, but upon review it wasn't anything other people didn't do (the whole deadline issue).

Can someone cite a reason they are voting Alabaska/IAUN outside of their reactions to Cream's claim?

[Lord Gurgi]

You wanted a case, this one holds together.

[Lord Gurgi]

Huh my post disappeared, anyway I was saying that you didn't refute anything, you just said that it's about normal and that you can see how it would look bad. And here's the thing: It looks bad. Really bad.

[Lord Gurgi]

This is Massclaim, so claim.

[Lord Gurgi]

I don't see why the mod-confirmed toad needs to explain anything. As much as I love his vote for Alabaska, resistance to claim after everything that's happened is off.

[Lord Gurgi]

The problem with using a star is if we have the wrong person use it we could accidentally 'clear' two scum of the same faction.

[Lord Gurgi]

I don't bring in outside grudges, I just don't find your titles very funny. I usually do just pick a scum by gut and run with it.

[Lord Gurgi]

I never get to kill anyone.

[Lord Gurgi]

I don't bring in outside grudges, I just don't find your titles very funny. I usually do just

pick a

scum

by gut and run with it.

this is the driving force behind my lynch guys :/

Oh hey guys, he plays by gut, he MUST be wrong. The case-based players have made a case against you too. We're just sorting out the fineries until we lynch you at this point.

[Lord Gurgi]

I don't bring in outside grudges, I just don't find your titles very funny. I usually do just

pick a

scum

by gut and run with it.

this is the driving force behind my lynch guys :/

Oh hey guys, he plays by gut, he MUST be wrong. The case-based players have made a case against you too. We're just sorting out the fineries until we lynch you at this point.

Not saying gut=wrong, just saying that you convinced lots of people to vote me and basically spearheaded this thing on a gut read. Gut votes are fine; gut wagons are not.

Also, the case against me is quite weak, and seeing as I've proven this numerous times, I'm saying this is a gut wagon.

The wagon on you started a while after I first stated my suspicion of you. Frankly the wagon started when Tajo agreed with me and then someone (I can't remember who) posted an exhaustive case.

[Lord Gurgi]

Tajo, you ARE getting yourself some protection tonight RIGHT?

[Lord Gurgi]

I just reread my PM, apparently I can buy mushrooms for two coins, if we need to buy one I might be a good way to do that.

Why are you NK immune?

[Lord Gurgi]

I think we have this game suitably broken, what do we still need to do?

[Lord Gurgi]

LOL, Tajo is confirmed town idiot.

[Lord Gurgi]

Well I take credit for being suspicious of Alabaska the second I replaced in. I want to hand the MVP for this game to Tajo and Surye.

[Lord Gurgi]

*sniff* I thought

I

was the new Gimbo.

[Lord Gurgi]

I dont want to imagine what would have happened if Gimbo had gotten the Lakitu role.

Hey!

[Lord Gurgi]

I dont want to imagine what would have happened if Gimbo had gotten the Lakitu role.

Town would've auto-won. No-one should have that much of a handicap.

Probably, I'm surprised town made it with Gimbo having that much power.