Do you think we should go over possible roles? I mean there arn't to many legendary guitar players. I assume that is what were dealing with, maybe not.
*Maverick*
Well, if your going to pick someone random, why pick someone who has played mafia a lot, and is very experienced with the game, when you have newbies in this game that have never played before. I mean the chances of being scum are the same guessing at Dourgrim and a newbie, but if Dourgrim were town, that would be a bigger loss than if a newbie were town.. That is my way of looking at it.. But then there is always the possibility of Dourgrim being scum, so if you really think that's the case then forget everything I just said.Internet Stranger said:
So you pick someone at random, lynch them, and hope for the best. This time around, Dourgrim is the one I picked and hence, the winner of the Day 1 bandwagon. So lets hop to it, pile on the votes and show him how popular he really is.
You sort of agreed to my point made in post 110, in post 111. Just thought I'd correct you, you have agreed with some points.Mastermind of Sin wrote:
The only time I ever said I agreed with anyone's points was when I revoted Talitha because Dourgrim's points in addition to my own were enough evidence for me to put my vote somewhere.
I'm guessing that suss means suspicious, I guess I missed where someone else found me suspicious? You say that just because I disagreed with MoS, I assume?Talitha wrote:
Maverick's looking very suss to me too.
I agree, like I said before, we have gotten very little information today, and would almost definately know more tomorrow.Mr. Flay wrote:
but I am certain that we'll know more tomorrow, especially when we get to look back on today.
I can recall saying I had a gut feeling once, and that was in my most recent post, apparently you havn't been paying too much attention, as you say you are.Assasin wrote:
Maverick: all he talks about is gut feelings. What's up with that
I voted Mr. Flay over Internet Stranger because I am 100% sure about Mr. Flay being scum, because I investigated him, and am only 85% sure IS is scum because he has claimed cop which I know is my role, but there is always that possibility of there being two cops (the only problem is that he supposedly investigated Talitha, which would prove his sanity, and so did I). But if we lynch Mr. Flay today, and you guys finally see that he is scum, you'll also know then that IS is scum as well. Or you could lynch me and know they are both scum, but be unable to do anything about it, and if that is how you want it, go for it.Nonny wrote:
You know ussually in a small game like this if somone else claims your role you vote for them, which you arn't doing. Is that to mislead the town?
I believe you, but there is no way to know for sure right now.nonny wrote:
Quote:
Here is how things are right now:
Mr. Flay - Scum
Internet Stranger - Scum
Mastermind of Sin - Scum/Town
Nonny - Town/Possibly Doc
Justinl - Town
KingEnigma - Town
Maverick - Cop
Possible doc? No one else has counter claimed which someone would do if they were it. So saying possible at this point seems stupid to me.
I think everyone on this board would be shocked if I proved to the town that you were scum. But so far your getting the town to believe you, even though your the one lying.Internet Stranger wrote:
I am going to be flat out shocked if Maverick somehow pulls this off.
That's exactly why IS said that. IS knows that Mr. Flay is his partner, and that it's either gonna be me or Flay lynched today. That way if Flay is lynched mafia will have a better chance of winning tomorrow because town will possibly be thinking that IS was telling the truth. Actually I must hand it to him, he's doing very well in thinking of clever stuff to convince the town.justinl wrote:
MastermindOfSin wrote:
Also, if IS's theory about Mr. Flay and Maverick possibly being scum together is true, then the scum would need one more innocent vote before they could lynch their scum partner, unless Mr. Flay plans to vote for himself.
You're grasping at straws. If IS's theory about that is correct, then we should lynch Mr. Flay anyways.. duh