Mini 142: Guitarists Mafia- Game Over

[nonny]

We can talk on Day 2. Day 1 is for following IS mindlessly.

How many times have you been right? does seem like it's all the often

No vote now.

[nonny]

I was gone on a last min trip all weekend will read and post more later.

[nonny]

i will be gone from the 17th to the 24th but will try and get something of value in before then. Sorry i havn't contributed much so far you may replace me if you wish.

[nonny]

This is just some stuff i gathered from reading...my opinions and that is it. By post number b/c quoting would take up to much room.

Post 40: Dourgrim states that no cop would come out on day one and his sanity is not verified. Does he know something we don’t?

Post 52: Maverick that is crap logic. Not saying the dourgrim is evil but if we lynched a newbie and they are evil we got luck but if we didn’t and they are still evil it would be easier to spot. Same situation with an expierenced player but we wouldn’t catch them, most likely.

Agreeing with post 53by dourgirm except for the role claim….little to anxouis, and to willing maybe a plot to get people to not vote because he is willing to claim.

Post 70: MoS I never random vote lately don’t like it much.

Dour and tally going in circles and seem to be saying the same things though I have to agree with tally not dour here.

Jusitn…IS’s logic convinced you? What logic??

Post 97: um she Mr. Flay…thanks

Post 108 I agree with mav there

Personally i have seen tally play like this on day one in chat room gamesb ut htose are of course quiet different. She isn't exactly scrambling to save her self either which ussually is a sign of confidence or stupidity. I'll give her the benefit of the doubt though.

Dourgirm has been fighting to save himself since his second vote and started the whole thing between tally over something somewaht meaningless and from what i could tell some what farfetched.

Justin seems to be agreeing with IS which I find quite odda nd what is this about IS logic? I didn't know that existed!

I personally find dourgirm to be suspicous because of how he has been acting likea fish out of water.

Sorry for my lurking i didn't intend for it to occur.

VOTE DOURGRIM

[nonny]

do i need to request a replacment from the mod....?? leaveing tonight.

[nonny]

Not going to replace nonny since it's the holidays and I don't expect posting will be too heavy anyways. Will send out a prod to those who need it tonight.

okay then i shall be gone starting tongiht......

[nonny]

I'm not really sure who looks suspicous now so i'm gonna re-read because it has been awhile since i did that..so that will happen either today or tomarrow depends on what happens.

[nonny]

^what mav said.....i really need to rereread sorry have had much comp time this week.

[nonny]

nonny? nonny was lurking a lot before the holidays, and a lot of us were busy. Right now we're in a full-fledged fit of lurkerdom but she's not off my radar. If you'll notice, all of these people I've either voted for or (in IS's case) said I would vote for. It's not like I'm really singling you out, Talitha, whereas you seem to be engaged in the same "spat" with me today that you were in with Dourgrim yesterday. Yesterday it got a townie lynched. What happens today? I don't trust you in this game; not that I really trust anybody, but right now you're my best lead.

Yeah I know I have but i assure you i'm not doing it on purpose and I'm just not finding anyone scummy at the moment......So I really have nothing to go on.

[nonny]

Yeah that confused me to then I relized....hey where

are

all the siggy's they disappeared....

That is an interesting thing to happen either you have a metal hang over or you were role-blocked.

[nonny]

I've been posting just I have nothing to really add currently.

[nonny]

I've been posting just I have nothing to really add currently.

You've been posting? Where?!?

Are you going to be more active now that Dreamcatcher is over?

I havn't been posting as much as the rest of you sure. But dreamcatcher had no effect on that, I will try to post more but i can't always post a lot. But I serisouly have nothing to add right now.

[nonny]

okay, now that i'm about to be lynched ill roleclaim.
I'm Keith Richards, normal Townie. I'm to lazy to go out at night so I have to work my magic during the day.
And thats all the pm said, and thats my defense. Lynching me would be stupid!

okay yeah i didn't see this.

But for some reason it seems a little fishy....but that is just a gut feeling so hmm.

Yeah i can't think of anything else to add.

[nonny]

I really think Assassin is our scum, especially with Nonny's hesitation. Its so clear to see that she knows something, and im speculating that its about Assassin. My vote stays.

woah woah woah don't use my uncertianity to get someone lynched. I'm unsure that is it case closed.

[nonny]

assassin when you do something like that make it equal judge your self how other may see you that is the best way to defend yourself.

FoS assassin no vote

[nonny]

We do have a lot of lurkers. But I think we got assassin. I really suspect Nonny, she still hasnt voted him after I pointed her out. It cant possibly be this obvious.

Either way, I want to lynch Assassin and possibly Nonny tomorrow. Unless better scum pop up.

I don't vote unless i'm sure i don't follow bandwagons, and i'm not sure so i'm not voting.

And lynching me tomarrow would be a bad idea but i guess we can discuss that tomarrow.

[nonny]

what is the difference justin? I have to agree with Mr.Flay there.

I'm a doctor.

[nonny]

COnsidering it is you saying that IS, i'll wait for a counter claim if there is one.

[nonny]

it sounds like a good plan but personally i'm not believing anyone quite yet, and will like to hear from everyone else about these investigations before anyvoting.

Question: why do you want to kill Mr. Flay? It is posilbe to have to cops isn't? And for all we know you could be insane or not?

[nonny]

It seems a little convienant for Mav that we were all waiting for a supposed counter claim. And that IS "found" him as scum. Little to convienant for my liking.

My night one investigation was KingEnigma - Innocent, my night two investigation was Talitha - Innocent, and my night 3 investigation was Mr. Flay - Guilty.

Maverick - Innocent (cop)
KingEnigma - Innocent
Nonny -
Internet Stranger - Guilty (He claims cop, when I am cop)
Mr. Flay - Guilty
justinl -
Mastermind of Sin -

But mav you didn't investiagte IS right? And your other investigations are of declared innocents. then there is Mr. Flay another active player who did have some suspicions on him since day one....easy lynch?

MR. Flay i'm Kurt Cobain.....

Right now I'm leaning towards believing IS.

[nonny]

Mav we all know that IS doesn't play by the book why would he point out possible investigations?

And I found tal guilty also day one.

But going by deaths we have one killing group or I got lucky right? Which do you all think it is?

[nonny]

I Find it convieant that you don't have suspicions on three poeple....wow all you need to lynch someone.

[nonny]

Mr. Flay, your wrong, you and Internet Stranger surely know who my parters are, Nonny, justinl, KingEnigma, and possibly MoS, I'm not sure about.

I'm not thinking I'm your partner because i'm not scum, and I think you are. And in all your posts you say our names at least once that just seems like munipulation to me.

Here is how things are right now:

Mr. Flay - Scum
Internet Stranger - Scum
Mastermind of Sin - Scum/Town
Nonny - Town/Possibly Doc
Justinl - Town
KingEnigma - Town
Maverick - Cop

Possible doc? No one else has counter claimed which someone would do if they were it. So saying possible at this point seems stupid to me.

Now say the scenerio is MoS is scum, if we lynch me today it's over. But if he is town then we will win as soon as you lynch me you'll know I was telling the truth and hopefully the doc (nonny) will get a lucky protection. So basically if I am lynched today town is screwed.
But I vote not to depend on either of those scenarios and lynch Mr. Flay or IS today, and tonight I'll investigate MoS for the 100% sure win.

You know ussually in a small game like this if somone else claims your role you vote for them, which you arn't doing. Is that to mislead the town?

It is in the hands of Nonny, Justinl, KingEnigma, and even MoS. So choose wisely.

Wow it's in the hands of someone lurking, someone already voting with you, someone you find scummy, and me....i feel safe

IS, I wasn't saying that you rushed on and posted before me necisarily, I ment that you claimed cop before I had a chance to tell people my investigation last night, so now people may believe you over me just for that. I have no way of showing them that you are lying, all I can do is tell them all I know, and hope they will believe me. And I'm pretty sure you didn't kill me last night so it would turn out like this, because right now the chances of town winning are very slim, which I know you are very happy to hear. (see)

Wait he claimed before you had a *chance*? That is. to me, a pity claim.....in other words crap.

I'm going to wait for KE to show up before I vote anywhere, but as I see there are two possible scum groups.

Justin and Mav, or IS and Flay. MoS could be part of either from how I see it, but i'm not that great of a scum hunter.

[nonny]

that is what i think to enigma. Is that all you have to say after like two pages or something?

[nonny]

excuse me justin but i am a confirmed innocent by the same logic you used...no counterclaim and there won't be one either. ON the other hand you aren't 100% cleared in my book atleast....then again no one is.

I'm still having trouble deciding who is scum mav or flay.....and i don't want to vote wrong and lose it for us all. I hate it when that happens hence i vote rarly.....actually i don't think i have voted once in this game yet

[nonny]

the fact of the matter is mav..that you have lurked most protown roles don't lurk that much especially ones with such important roles.

Question: Mav if you were grounded how did you mange to make night choices and not one or to posts....or even tell the mod you are grounded and have him pass on the message?

[nonny]

as i see there are two possible scum groups justin-mav or flay-IS, so i'm not voting right now until i'm sure cause the third scum is out there waiting to jump on, which for all i know is kingenigma or MoS.

[nonny]

Sorry mav but you keep dorpping my name and making it seem like it is up to me....it's not KE can still decide to.

Bah this will teach me to lurk whether by accident or not.

[nonny]

Ah, good game guys you had me confused....isn't that easy to do. But yeah sorry i was unable to read and what not the few days before it ended.