Mafia 29: Mafia - Game over!

[commify]

I will

vote bloojay

because he is before me alphabetically. It is not technically random, but it is arbitrary.

[commify]

HairyMezican pretty much said "I meant to do that."
Yeah...

The following people still haven't posted:
bloojay
Omniplex
Uraj45
ZONEACE

I'm suspicious of him, but I'll keep my vote on a lurker for now.

[commify]

I

unvote bloojay

. Everyone's posted at least once now.

I still like my zone vote, I don't see what mairy was doing so wrong that made him get so close to lynch so fast

I don't see how your reason for voting for Zoneace is all that solid.

[commify]

I'm inclined to agree. We're going to have to start lynching sometime. Let's just try not to be too hasty--the bandwagon on HairyMezican got rolling quickly. We wanna make sure we nab a townie.

Also, if I don't post for a day or so, it's because of finals.

[commify]

A note after looking through the game with posts-by-player: joe has only one post the entire game, and that contains very little other than a quick vote. If we're going after useless posters, he'd be at the top of my list, but I'll leave my vote on ZONEACE for now, until I hear more opinions on this.

Joe's been lurking longer, though--nothing since page one.

vote joe

[commify]

unvote

olliep13's been vacillating this entire time. He jumped on the HairyMezican bandwagon, then changed to a no lynch a bit later, claiming that "we didn't have enough reason to vote HairyMezican and his role claim seems credible." And then he switched from no lynch to Zoneace.

vote olliep13

[commify]

Firtst of all, Commify, you say that I've been vacillating when it comes to my votes but your vote history is: Bloojay, No Vote, Joe, Olliep13.

I voted for:

Bloojay-Random vote.
No Vote-I took my vote off of bloojay and waited for a while without casting a vote. This is perfectly reasonable, isn't it? Also, remember that this is not the same as a No Lynch.
Joe-Lurker.
Olliep13-I have stated my reasons.

You, however, seem to be hopping from one bandwagon to another.

[commify]

FOS coron and MoS

. Contentless, spammy posts. And they seem to have good chemistry.

Ditto that. They're like Tweedle-dee and Tweedle-scum.

[commify]

unvote

you guys are unbelieveably annoying.

vote coron FOS mastermind

Isn't it funny how both Bloo and Zoneface both voted me

Sort of a little bif FoS those two.

Isn't it funny how you get votes when you act suspicious. 8)

Actually, I was wondering why both of them voted for Coron instead of mastermind.

[commify]

What I'd really like is an extension of the deadline, because people are typically busy during the holidays. I know I have access to the internet, but I'm sure there are a lot of people out there who haven't had time to post recently.

[commify]

I disagree. I leave tomorrow to go visit my relatives, so I won't be able to access the computer. Thus, a deadline would be convenient for me.

I don't see how it'd be "inconvenient" for you. Some people haven't posted in a while, and I'd like for them to speak. Especially the ones who voted for Zoneace but haven't done anything else in a while--if we're going to lynch someone, I'd like to know where they're coming from. The only downside to a deadline extension is the fact that we lose some of that very cool atmosphere that comes with night falling on Christmas Eve.

[commify]

what the heck? why are we lynching me, when it is very likely that Coron, ollie, scale or uraj are scum?

why go for teh safe lynch when we can go for the likely scum lynch?

The idea, I think, is that you are both claiming to be safe lynches. Both of you may

be

safe lynches. Indeed, I see nothing really suspicious about either of you.

I was content to vote for olliep13, but I'll have to

unvote

and

vote Coron

, I think, because if we're going to have to lynch someone than we should obviously go after the scummiest likely lynch. And Coron does seem like townie scum right now.

[commify]

Well, that sucks...I'm still convinced Locus Cosecant is townie, but no one else can see it...his play is much scummier than normal, and he has a slightly scummy play style already...

I really just see Locus as having a scummy style of play. He was in the first game I ever played, and managed to annoy everyone by being overly zealous, but he was the doctor. Of course, I don't have any instances of his beign scum with which I can contrast that style of play...

[commify]

Alternatively, the town tried an unsuccessfull Coron bandwagon and both bloojay and commify are townspeople.

I voted for Coron because I thought it was better to vote for a possible townie than for ZONEACE or HM, who were goons. I saw the case against ZONEACE as rather weak, and I never really thought that HM had done anything scummy.

[commify]

Yeah, you pretty much covered it, Coron...I know it's not much evidence, but at least it's something, more than what we have to go on...besides, we can always go on a lurker hunt later today if nothing else turns up...

Anyone who hasn't posted yet for Day 2?

[commify]

Mastermind of Sin: I'm sorry, I should've reiterated. I

felt

that they were not scum. I thought this was implied, especially because I explained further on

why

I thought they were goons. Are we clear now?

Oh, and I will rebuke you for using the "A-hole" word, which is not necessary or polite.

[commify]

I'd like to know why Coron is still voting for bigbenwd. Seems kinda... confusing, really. I'd like to hear some actual reasoning behind it.

[commify]

I'm still voting him for the same reasons I voted him in the first place.

Ah, certainly. But you see, I really didn't think it was a

good

reason.

[commify]

so now not only is maximus trying to trick you into thinking he has information, but you're now going to make me claim just because of a possible hint??? really, you people need to look at his actions more carefully...i don't buy his "hint" one bit...

I've been kinda suspicious of MoS, but I agree. We can't just blindly take his suggested logic as a good reason.

Right now, I'm not sure what to do.

[commify]

I'm just trying to get somebody lynched today because it's day 2 DEADLINED. Our odds are better with lynching the most suspicious/frustrated person right now than sitting there our hands folded hoping somebody trips.

And FYI, I wasn't claiming. Take what you must out of that or any of my other posts.

Very well. Do you have any of that insinuated solid reasoning or not? If you do, please share it with us.

[commify]

This is pathetic.

Make note of the last few people who voted for me. They are most likely scum because deadline is approaching and they are mindlessly jumping on the bandwagon in hopes that noone would notice.

I was hoping we could take out MOS but oh well if the town is too blind to decipher between deception and truth.

Let me make it easier.

Unvote
Vote: Maximus

To be perfectly fair, Maximus, you have failed to give any reasons.

I still with the town best of luck but I think mafia's got this one down.

This is Mafia Mafia, remember?

[commify]

Man... I really don't know. I was confused yesterday, although I was leaning towards Maximus because he couldn't back his actions up. MoS edged around a bit, and I'm wary of PeaceBringer after his vote-hopping, but I was pretty confused myself.

What was Genocide Heart's role as an "accomplice", btw? Cop-like? Maybe he was on to something. But no, he voted for Maximus.

Oh well.

[commify]

I'm kind of suspicious of people who voted for Hairy Mezican. He didn't seem like scum to me. More like someone who made a mistake at the beginning, and everyone jumped on it, and he just sort of floundered until finally getting bumped off. I expected him to get lynched rather than night-killed, though.

[commify]

why not vote for JDTAY, then? He's done the same thing, except to more than just one confirmed innocent. And he hasn't done anything to contribute to the game, either.

That's very true. And his vote for Thesp was scummy.

vote jdtay

[commify]

vote: jdtay

i'm easily swayed.

and on another note, we're having a cliff jumping later. everyone else is doing it.

Wait... huh? Sarcasm?

[commify]

Okay guys, you really don't want to lynch me. I know I seem kinda useless right now, but I could be really beneficial to the mafia. Just give me a few more nights...

Oh, okay. Because you insist, and because I have so much faith in you.

There. Now that's sarcasm.

[commify]

Vote JDTAY

Almost any bandwagon will do.

Are you replacing someone? If so, who?

And I would like to hear some reasoning. I thought I explained my vote on JDTay. Others have not. This suggests to me that my suspicion was wrong, and that the members of the bandwagon are the real scum.

[commify]

I'm still here, I guess. I kind of like my vote, but there's a splinter of doubt, too. I wonder if Coron will respond to my post like he's done all the others?

[commify]

Would it be better if we were waiting axiously with a gun to his head?

*Twiddles handgun?*

[commify]

That's really, really good.

Although it is a sad commentary on our skills that all the dead townies are from vig-kills.

[commify]

I'm gonna

unvote JDTAY

now. Because I thought he was being scummy, but... A bunch of people voted for him afterwards, and I couldn't help but wonder if some of them were townies. And since Coron

was

a townie...

[commify]

I don't know if we should continue on as we've been. While I don't see anyone new as too suspicious right now, but continuing on and bandwagoning KE and commify for being on the JDTAY bandwagon with Coron may very well lead to another pair of roleclaimed people and leave us back here as before. I don't think we want that, but then, where to turn? Anyone have any ideas?

MoS also voted for JDTAY...

[commify]

yeah, wtf? this is the second time you failed to mention my involvement with the JDTAY wagon, when I practically started it!

unvote, VOTE: DarkLight140

because something weird seems to be going on here.

Weird, maybe. But not necessarily scummy. Is there a reason why he would fail to mention it?

[commify]

Vote Lazarus Moth

This is exactly why people think you've been acting scummy.

[commify]

This entire game has me pissed off. Too, too many people need to be or have been replaced.

I stand by my vote against Coron early on. Also, if I haven't had anything productive to say recently, maybe its because most people aren't posting.

[commify]

I find Thesp's claim less credible, as both of his investigatees were mysteriously killed off.

[commify]

It's... odd. This daytime vigilante is pretty good.

Also... I figured olliep13, the "deputy", would be the Mafia Mafia counterpart to the normal serial killer role.

[commify]

Sorry, weekend-partay-related inactivity.

I was willing to vote for StevieT92: he was a lurker and scalebane was a lurker. Together, they were

the player who lurked

. But he's close to being lyched now, should we let him claim or something?

[commify]

here is what i am getting as maybe scum

mainly STD,
then Nanook,
then you.

but the problem is, none of them is acting very scummy...

maybe that also means they're

not

scum

anyways, not an accomplice

[commify]

they are the most scummy, but none of them are actually scummy

thats what i meant

If I were a robot, reading that statement would make my brain explode.

[commify]

well, someone said to name who you think is the most scummy, so i named three. but you are each about a 1/20 on the scum-o-meter, while everyone else is a 0/20.
So you are the scummiest, but are not particularily scummy.

Mmmmm. Reasons for scumminess are still welcomed. I can see what you're getting at... you think people are scummy, but there is simply a case of no one being terribly standoutish scummy? I, for one, find the accomplice claim plausible, acceptable.

[commify]

And still happy with my vote. STD is the most bizarre I have *ever* seen him, and I don't see anything in joe's behavior before him that reassures me, either.

Wait... who's Joe?

(I'm fine with STD's vote on me, I suppose. I haven't been posting enough, should post more.)

I'm still cool with Stevie's claim. It makes enough sense to me. Slightly suspicious of Mr. Flay because he is the reincarnation of Lazarusmoth, but otherwise no opinions, no ideas.

[commify]

Wise-guy. One-shot night kill immunity or something? That sounds reasonable enough.