Mystery Mafia 2- Game Over! But who won!?

[elvis_knits]

I always think it's funny how guys like that movie. I mean, I guess they like the fighting and there are boobs in it. But there's like one million buff guys dressed only in banana hammock, heavily outweighing the few boobs (no pun intended? Maybe I did intend).

[elvis_knits]

I wonder if BM will mind I said boobs.

[Surye]

I wouldn't be drunk posting as scum... I'm always afraid of slipping.

WIFOM! Or Some type of booze obviously in front of you.

[Korlash]

I think guys like that movie because it was based off a comic book... All guys like comic books.

[Battle Mage]

Vote Count

Korts 3 (Surye, Korlash, Elvis Knits)
Landlord 1 (Korts)

Not Voting: Landlord

With 5 alive, 3 votes are required to lynch.

And so, Korts was promptly hung from a tree. Yes, not hanged-HUNG. Then he was beaten with sticks, and finally set on fire. With few suspects remaining, his story just didn't add up, and the new kid on the block was lynched and kinda singed. But was he scum?

Korts - Cop, Lynched Day 9

The remaining 4 players looked at each other. Surye held Korlash's hand, and they looked into each other's eyes, while Elvis Knits looked at them with disgust. While they were all distracted, Landlord had apparently lost his mind in the wilderness, as he removed his mask, and revealed his true identity, before jumping into the inferno with Korts.

Landlord aka IcemanE - English Mafia Goon, Modkilled Day 9

That means the survivors are:

Elvis Knits, Korlash and Surye! Town Wins!

Thanks for the excellent game guys. Bit of a sad way for it to end, with a modkill, and i think even at the end, Landlord could still have theoretically clinched it. That said, the town thoroughly deserved the win, in what i think was a game slightly tilted against them. If it wasn't for Iceman killing Killa Seven last night, i think the result might have been very different.

And serious congrats to all who played-with no exceptions i can think of, you all played your parts remarkably well, and made the game an absolute pleasure to run. I think the suspense and mystery element to the game was more successful than the original Mystery Mafia. I hope you guys enjoyed it!

Any comments are more than welcome, and i'll answer any questions.

BM

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Nicely done to the remaining 3 Townies. I caught the missed quicklynch by Korlash, and that made the claim that much more believable - nice work Elvis!

Too bad Korts really was telling the truth lol. And he's sane? Kinda weird.

BM: Why the modkill? because Iceman posted on the wrong account?

[Battle Mage]

Nicely done to the remaining 3 Townies. I caught the missed quicklynch by Korlash, and that made the claim that much more believable - nice work Elvis!

Too bad Korts really was telling the truth lol. And he's sane? Kinda weird.

Yup, he was sane. The funny thing was, his cop result on Lawrence was screwed up by the Distorter, so he ended up getting a guilty on the investigation immune godfather, which confused him a bit. lol

BM: Why the modkill? because Iceman posted on the wrong account?

Yeh, sadly it was a term in his role pm that he would be modkilled if he posted using his real account, or the other players guessed his identity.

BM

[Korts]

Woo yay town win! Although winning with a modkill ruins it a little. And winning by me getting lynched at the end also. I guess I'm happy though that I was lynched and not Korlash like I wanted, because that would've caused my mislynch the next day and would've caused the town to lose.

[Litral]

Nicely done, town

I liked my role. Very interesting - although it was somewhat difficult. The simplest way would be to argue a lot with different players in huge quote wars, but that would probably get me lynched immediately.

[Surye]

Haha, awesome end. BTW, Korlash was the masonizer, I just got the hint and played along with him. Damn the distorter. If Iceman had killed me or korlash, elvis, what would be your first instinct? To kill me/kor since our story contradicted the revealed cop?

I think Ice could have won, had he not made ONE LITTLE TINY endgame mistake, in one post, he lost it for scum.

[Korts]

Yup, he was sane. The funny thing was, his cop result on Lawrence was screwed up by the Distorter, so he ended up getting a guilty on the investigation immune godfather, which confused him a bit. lol

Yeah, that messed with my head a little. Very nice game, though, BM, I enjoyed it very much. Pretty mindfucking, and possibly bastardesque, but definitely a fun ride all the way through

But who was the role who sloppily ate DGB and dismembered Dasquian? I assume those two kills were done by the same player.

[populartajo]

I was Jesus. I was never told that I was a day insane cop.

[Battle Mage]

I was Jesus. I was never told that I was a day insane cop.

You weren't an insane day-cop. You were indeed Jesus. If you had been lynched instead of NKed, a vanilla townie would have become a Mafia Traitor (the Ante-Christ). You were killed and your role reveal was chosen by the SCREWBALL -DGB.

BM

[Battle Mage]

Yup, he was sane. The funny thing was, his cop result on Lawrence was screwed up by the Distorter, so he ended up getting a guilty on the investigation immune godfather, which confused him a bit. lol

Yeah, that messed with my head a little. Very nice game, though, BM, I enjoyed it very much. Pretty mindfucking, and possibly bastardesque, but definitely a fun ride all the way through

But who was the role who sloppily ate DGB and dismembered Dasquian? I assume those two kills were done by the same player.

DGB was eaten by Ashmite84, the Vengeful Vig. He could only target players who had voted for him that day, which meant DGB was toast.

The Dismembering was Kison if i recall, given that he also decided to send a kill in for his group. Admittedly a little bastardish, but that'll teach you guys to take kill methods seriously!

BM

[populartajo]

DGB killed me?

[Korts]

I was Jesus. I was never told that I was a day insane cop.

You weren't an insane day-cop. You were indeed Jesus. If you had been lynched instead of NKed, a vanilla townie would have become a Mafia Traitor (the Ante-Christ). You were killed and your role reveal was chosen by the SCREWBALL -DGB.

BM

Wow, that's an evil stunt to pull... BM, I'm proud of you.

[populartajo]

That explains why BM wanted people to lynch me since he told me to claim a role in my first post.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

I was Jesus. I was never told that I was a day insane cop.

You weren't an insane day-cop. You were indeed Jesus. If you had been lynched instead of NKed, a vanilla townie would have become a Mafia Traitor (the Ante-Christ). You were killed and your role reveal was chosen by the SCREWBALL -DGB.

BM

Now THIS is a clusterfuck...

Nice game BM, thanks for running it!

[farside22]

DAMN YOU K-7.
No one even looked at me as scum. I was sad when I was killed like I was. I had bet that Lawerlot would be lynched that day two which would have give the scum two kills that night.
Oh well good game.

[Battle Mage]

DGB killed me?

Well, Lord Hur actually put the bullet in your head. DGB was the one who screwed your role up.

BM

[Battle Mage]

That explains why BM wanted people to lynch me since he told me to claim a role in my first post.

That was the mechanic of your role. I guess subconciously this game was meant to tackle some of the common assumptions of mafia. In your case, the PREMATURE POWER ROLE CLAIM. The town would have been significantly hurt if they'd have lynched you, but i wasnt specific enough when i first made your role, so sorry for that.

That said, i think the Mafia let the town off a bit at the beginning. Killing Populartajo was not a great decision, as he was definitely lynchable, and i'd liked to have seen a more wacky role reveal choice.

BM

[bionicchop2]

From: bionicchop2
To: Battle Mage
Posted: Thu Nov 06, 2008 10:59 am
Subject: MM2 - night 7
kill: no one
distort: Korts

[bionicchop2]

My first game as scum and I get to join with all my partners already dead + I get killed by other scum group.

[Korts]

How, though? Did I drop any obvious cop-tells or something?

[Korts]

My first game as scum and I get to join with all my partners already dead + I get killed by other scum group.

Hehheh. I think you did a very nice job, though. I probably wouldn't have fingered you as likely scum at that point.