Normal Idea Mafia (150/150 roles submitted, discussion thread up)

[Alianna]

Vanilla Townie

[Alianna]

Werewolf Tracker

[Alianna]

Werewolf Goon

---

Mafia Lazy Traitor Strongman

Doesn't the lazy here apply to both the traitor and the strongman? If I'm not mistaken, that would result in both the traitor and the strongman roles being disabled when they are the last scum left. Traitor can't perform the factional kill, so the strongman there does nothing. It might need to be Mafia Strongman Lazy Traitor instead.

[Alianna]

Vanilla Townie

[Alianna]

Town Even-Night Gunsmith

---

Is there any reason you haven't added it?

[Alianna]

Mafia Goon

[Alianna]

Vanilla Townie

---

I'd be willing to run one of these if Cook doesn't want to.
We would have to iron out the Encryptor thing though as I would definitely be running it with daytalk.

[Alianna]

Town Mason

---

17 is the only explicitly non-normal role that I could find, but there are a few other roles (36, 39, 75) I'm concerned about. They're technically within the letter of normality, but I'm not sure they're aligned with the spirit. I'm not sure if I've missed anything there though.

The encryptor thing is one issue, but I've also thought of another issue. What happens if you roll only one mason or neighbour card? Do you put the player in a PT by themself? Remove that piece of their role? Convert someone else to a mason or neighbour? Reroll?

[Alianna]

Werewolf Goon

---

If I were to run one of these, what game size and faction distribution would people be interested in playing?

[Alianna]

Vanilla Townie

---

also 14p with 3 of one + sk sounds good

I'll third that this sounds good. That's probably the setup I'll run.

Someone else (alianna?) offered to host. I'll comod on it.

You probably won't have much to do unless I'm V/LA, but the job is yours!

If someone wants, I can create role PMs for each post.

I prefer to write my own role PMs, but this could be useful for future runs.

I think my solution for non-normal or unclear role cards is just going to be to treat them as vanilla unless y'all want to do something else.

I'm planning to put this in the queue at some point in the next couple of days.

[Alianna]

Serial Killer Rolecop 3-Shot Commuter

---

I'm referring to 17, 36, and 39. I only intend to use the first 100 posts for this run.