Normal Idea Mafia Discussion

[TemporalLich]

Post 47 is ambiguous, unsure if the Miller part of that role is Night-Specific or not.

[TemporalLich]

Post 47 is ambiguous, unsure if the Miller part of that role is Night-Specific or not.

If the Miller part was night specific then it'd be

Town One-shot Loyal Fruit Vendor Night Nine Vigilante Night Nine Miller

wouldn't it?

yeah, but the lack of ability text would make the role be either interpreted as a

Town One-shot Loyal Fruit Vendor Night Nine Vigilante Night Nine Miller

or a

Town Miller One-shot Loyal Fruit Vendor Night Nine Vigilante

[TemporalLich]

I would have preferred

Town Night 50 Friendly Neighbor

for

Town Earl

if you wanted the "Normal for Town only" variant of Named Townie.

then again, night 50 visitor is good at approximating the standard version of Named Townie (a role with no effect).

[TemporalLich]

I think experimental normal roles should be allowed in normal idea mafia

the idea of collaborative decks is to be experimental with role ideas, after all