Trifia: Town wins after Day Eight

[Bengel54321]

Category: water

[Bengel54321]

*does a little happy dance because he knows this answer*

Answer: Nitrogen Gas

[Bengel54321]

Category War

I think the life support issue if probably some kind of fail-safe integrated into the game by Fuldo...just in case we try that "strategy" Locus is proposing. We shouldn't underestimate the foreseeing capabilities of our mod.

[Bengel54321]

... though it might Doom Us All.

Any specific reason why you capped DUA Mneme? Is this a hidden cop claim (DUA means Directory User

agent

...) or am I being waaaay too investigative here?

[Bengel54321]

I agree with Raccoon here so I'll also

Vote Mastermind of sin

I don't see how a plan with only a group of people answering the question correctly can still work now, as a bunch of people already answered anyway. I am however all for discussing what to do "tomorrow".

Answer: House of York

[Bengel54321]

Mastermind has explained himself...Andrew has not.

I'm shamelessly going to jump on the bandwagon.

Unvote and vote andrews

[Bengel54321]

Category: past

Not sure what to think of the night kills. It's seems quite obvious we have 3 bad guys or groups...most likely at least 1 mafia group and 2 SK's, but probably 2 mafia groups and 1 SK. That means there are at least 4 bad guys and probably 6 bad guys left.

We can't get it wrong too many times anymore...so I'll wait for more info before I vote.

[Bengel54321]

I'll also

Vote Coron

At least we can check DMI this way.

I don't have a clue about any of the questions...

[Bengel54321]

It appears we aren't going to try a non-answering strategy this round...so I'll follow the above.

Answer Marino

[Bengel54321]

"Only" 2 deaths...1 of them bad. We've had worse nights.

Anyway:

Category: Tenille

[Bengel54321]

I have no problems with this...but do consider you could also be blocking good-people's roles.

[Bengel54321]

I agree with the above...can't find any other lynch candidates so I'll join the bandwagon (for now).

Vote Thrawn

[Bengel54321]

I do actually...

Personally I don't see why anyone should be off the list as we have no definite proof.

[Bengel54321]

Please explain why people are taken off the list because YOU believe their claims...I think this totally kills the purpose of making that list in the first place.

This is confusing me SO much.

[Bengel54321]

As long as we are agreed:

Answer: none

That should be wrong...

My vote on Thrawn stays. I don't believe for a second we have people in here with no night actions at all...that would kinda be against the whole Trivia "spirit".

[Bengel54321]

Right now I don't know who uses what method. Only the scum know for sure (though I've been in games where the scum only learned how their victim died at daybreak). I don't know what to think, and even if thought I did, it wouldn't prove anything. I just want to vote for Bengel.

Do you have a reason for that too?

Considering we still had an active mangler last night...I believe the SK freezes instead of mangles. No SK would be stupid enough to actually perform his night kill when he could just as easily shift blaim to the 3 people that answered wrongly. It could be a double bluff though...

Why not just consider the obvious? We have 1 less kill tonight...which probably means the SK didn't perform a kill...which means the SK is most likely a freezer and not a mangler.

[Bengel54321]

I agree with most of what you said, Maximum...it seems to make sense. If the SK was/is amonst those 6...he most likely wouldn't have killed tonight.

Then again, DP is confirming Qualman's story.

We also shouldn't forget there was 1 less kill...so it's POSSIBLE the mangler isn't the SK after all...

We are missing something but I can't quite figure out what...

[Bengel54321]

The ARM one is Pittsburg University...unfortunately I was assigned hammer.

[Bengel54321]

Well...it appears we can answer although I was holding off to see if there would be another no-answering tactic today.

Answer: Mickey Spillane

I would have waited for inhim's defence...but I suppose it doesn't really matter.

[Bengel54321]

Yesterday I was posting this JUST before (or after) Fuldu locked the thread so I'm going to do it now.

no reason to and just to prove it to you.


ANSWER SIDNEY SHELDON

That makes me have to

FOS Peacebringer

.

Why deliberately answer wrong?? If you are pro town...you probably have some kind of a good night action. And even if you don't...scum can now scrap you off the 'potential cop or doc' - list.

If you are bad, you probably have scum buddies able to carry out the kill...I see no reason whatsoever for you to answer wrong deliberately other than trying (and failing) to proove your innocense."



However I was posting that when we had already cast the lynchvote so now I'll update that FOS to a

Vote Peacebringer

. I reserve the right to change that vote if more info becomes available.

Meantime:

Category decker

[Bengel54321]

I'm pretty sure (being a Star Trek fan) I know the answer to the Decker question...not a clue about the hammer though.

[Bengel54321]

I think we have to try to take out the remaining Heisenberg member first.

Although I still think Peacebringer is scum, I very much agree with this so I'll...

Unvote

I'll come back to see if we can eliminate someone else from being the last Heisenberg member by looking at the last incorrect/correct answers.

[Bengel54321]

Well...I've come to the same conclusion as Jaguar after looking at the submitted answers and kills. The only possible Heisenberg Mafia left are Mastermind of Sin, Maximum and myself.

Knowing I'm not ...that leaves MOS and Maximum.

The fact that MOS just posted this:

as for suspicions, i'm not sure, but i'm not seeing the answering wrong as a valid thing anymore...i have the feeling that there is a role that can target someone, and if that person answered wrong, they get their night choice...that's how i think the sk got a kill the night he answered wrong...i agree that it would be against the spirit of the game to make the sk or any other role not dependant on answers, but if there was a role that could make your answer right? As of this time, I'm not sure who to be suspicious of, but I'm not throwing anyone out.

This amplifies my suspisions.

There has, to my knowledge, not been a single night where the SK got a kill when he answered wrongly

. This looks like a desperate attempt to try and throw suspicion onto someone else...

Vote Mastermind of Sin

[Bengel54321]

I just rechecked that last bit...on night 1, inHimshallibe was able to make a night kill despite his wrong answer on the "air" question...

This is however the only time in the entire game something like this has come up. (at least the only one I can find) Perhaps we should revise our entire strategy as I'm a bit confused now...

[Bengel54321]

Almost forgot!

Answer Collins

Don't shoot me if it's wrong...

[Bengel54321]

Not sure what's happening...but I'll choose

Category Blueberry

[Bengel54321]

Oh dear...ummm...little help please?

(being in Europe I don't watch ABC very often...)

[Bengel54321]

Not a clue either...

[Bengel54321]

Just getting us onto the next page...

[Bengel54321]

I don't know about Thoth, I don't have him on my suspect list...but do agree 100% about Peacebringer (as I already explained yesterday morning).

I'll hold my vote for now...hoping someone may have some investigative info left.

[Bengel54321]

I'm the assistant mechanical engineer. After Internet Stranger died I replaced him and became doc.

I think I've been wrong every night so far...the only night we had 1 less kill was night 4 but I couldn't answer that day.

Last night I protected Quail.

[Bengel54321]

I'm waiting a bit more for Thoth...but as it is now I plan to vote for Peacebringer tomorrow (going to bed in a minute).

He's just the only one that's very high on my scum list right now. All the other claims seem very plausible (if Thoth can elaborate his some more).

[Bengel54321]

That's exactly why I think you are scum...you always waited till the very end of the day to "answer" or not answer.

To me that appears as if you were waiting to make sure your scum buddy had answered correctly so you could claim what you are claiming now.

There's no risk involved in not answering when your scum buddy has already answered his/her question.

Still holding my vote till we hear from Thoth...

[Bengel54321]

Thoth,

Well...first of all I'd like to ask AGAIN to explain your full role.

I'm rather convinced Peacebringer is scum and that would mean you are not (as Peace answered incorrectly yesterday and you supposedly were blocked by Quail...which by process of elimination would mean Peace and Jaguar are our last scum), so I can understand why it doesn't matter to you.

I also very much disagree about us having that "many" docs. There were only 2 docs in the game. Internet Stranger and you (although we still don't know what you can do)...me replacing IS means we had only 1 "real" doc (not counting you)all the time (mind you I didn't get my ability till after IS died), so your whole reasoning of having too many docs is just way off.

Me being pirate with Jaguar doesn't make any sense at all. We always had different categories the last few days and I gave the correct answer for my category and shared it with the others twice. There was no need for me to do this if Jaguar already answered her category correctly before me (which she did if my notes are correct)...it would even be a great risk on my side if I were scum, as I'd be giving pro-town roles a night ability while I could have just as easily not answered the question. All this even fortifies my thoughts about Peace and Jag being scum together.

Vote Peace

[Bengel54321]

Thoth,

Well...first of all I'd like to ask AGAIN to explain your full role.

I'm rather convinced Peacebringer is scum and that would mean you are not (as Peace answered incorrectly yesterday and you supposedly were blocked by Quail...which by process of elimination would mean Peace and Jaguar are our last scum), so I can understand why it doesn't matter to you.

I also very much disagree about us having that "many" docs. There were only 2 docs in the game. Internet Stranger and you (although we still don't know what you can do)...me replacing IS means we had only 1 "real" doc (not counting you)all the time (mind you I didn't get my ability till after IS died), so your whole reasoning of having too many docs is just way off.

Me being pirate with Jaguar doesn't make any sense at all. We always had different categories the last few days and I gave the correct answer for my category and shared it with the others twice. There was no need for me to do this if Jaguar already answered her category correctly before me (which she did if my notes are correct)...it would even be a great risk on my side if I were scum, as I'd be giving pro-town roles a night ability while I could have just as easily not answered the question. All this even fortifies my thoughts about Peace and Jag being scum together.

Vote Peace

[Bengel54321]

Congrats town!

We were sooooo close...who would have thought Thoth would choose to resurrect Peacebringer and not Quail in the end.