Mini 931: Supreme Court Mafia (Game Over post 682)

[pwnman]

1) How much experience do you have playing Mafia?
2) How would you describe your playstyle?
3) What do you value the most in making decisions in Mafia?
4) Do you expect the Spanish Inquisition?
5) Do you prefer playing as mafia or as town?
6) How many games are you playing in at the moment?
7) What do you consider to be your greatest strength as town? As mafia

1) Played alot of games on another site and a few here. So I guess a good amount.
2) I'll get back to you on this one
3) Probably the arguements evidence and scumtells dropped
4) Lolwut?
5) Mafia I guess. Probably cuz you get to screw around with the town and 3rd Party
6) 6 or 7
7) As town probably finding scumtells or figuring out if someone is telling the truth( I have my ways.....but I won't tell you what they are). As mafia probably avoiding lynch or causing the town to mislynch

[pwnman]

Pwnman: How many games have you replaced out of in the last week?

1. Last Will

[pwnman]

What the hell Jack! You just copied and pasted everyone else's answers?

vote jack

[pwnman]

What the hell Jack! You just copied and pasted everyone else's answers?

vote jack

Why do you think this is suspicious?

You don't copy and paste people's answers unless you don't want to look scummy

[pwnman]

I have no idea what to think of Jack.

Also, I really don't like the way Pwnman and jason jumped on the Jack wagon. Pwnman moreso.

vote: pwnman

At this point Jack is so anti-town that he is unlikely to be scum. No scum in his right mind would openly deny information that could be helpful to the town.

What makes you so sure? And if this is the case, why are you still voting for him?

Since when is 2 people voting a bandwagon? I was the second person on because Jack copied and pasted votes. Even if he hadn't done that I'd still be on now with his refusal to answer questions

[pwnman]

Since when is 2 people voting a bandwagon? I was the second person on because Jack copied and pasted votes. Even if he hadn't done that I'd still be on now with his refusal to answer questions

1) I didn't copy and paste votes
2) I haven't refused to answer question

s

, only one question.

Vote:pwnman

Fishy: Sure,

I can produce

a scummy reason for Jack's actions. First, he is deliberately being confusing. Even if he is town, he would have had no other reason to bring up the matter in the first place. He is attempting to derail the game by his cryptic responses as well. Also, he is, I think, trying to benefit from early suspicion being cleared, which often means that the player will be looked at with less suspicion later in the game. If he establishes an extremely scummy style of play now, in the late game, if he plays in a more pro-town fashion, he will look much less like scum, regardless of his actual alignment. Thus, in a sense, it can be something of a protectionist move.

So you came up with this one just now. You're making the logic fit the conclusion, then. Let's say I started (for some reason) with the conclusion that you were scum. In that light, your starting the game with the questions would be an attempt to make yourself look pro town and to control discussion early. You didn't notice my answers were copy pasted because you were scum faking suspicion on Darox. Now you think I know something about the setup that you don't, and as scum you want to know what it is, so you threaten to lynch me unless I spill the beans.

If you are town surely you can see how far astray starting with a conclusion and then finding a scum motive for someones behavior can take you.

lol. That was answers....or it shoulda been

[pwnman]

I put an EBWOP that said "answers not votes". I am not eager to jump on any bandwagon I was the second person to vote him with reasons.

[pwnman]

Thanks for the subtance Jack.

pman5595 wrote:
jasonT1981 wrote:
pman5595 wrote:

• conjures up the idea that Jack copied and pasted VOTES. (?)


To be honest, I kinda just saw this as a typo considering Jack copying answers was a topic of discussion for a short period around the time of that post.

that isn't my main problem. My problem now is that he claims to have EBWOPed that he made a typo. but he never did.

The biggest part of the case is a gut read.



hmmm, ur right.. i did a quick Iso and nothing EBWOP

Wrong. Post 135

[pwnman]

Mafia RULES!!!!
As Mafia- 1-0

Which game was this pwnman?

Newbie 897.

I don't see it

I didn't put EBWOP but it was supposed to be