But i'll note that that's NOT what Scorpion did. Instead, what he did was ask if OTHERS were interested. This is an interesting ploy. It seems to me that if he were really interested in doing this, he would do a dice roll rather than make it non-random. Because so long as it's NOT random, we're defeating the purpose of not giving the assassin information AND we potentially letting the assassin drive a lynch (though this is only bad insofar as he's not the one being lynched).
That is, of course, all essentially moot since I think we have to agree not to play this "randomly" just because our numbers would be better. Part of playing an open setup is figuring out the best way to maximize win rate, but at the same time it's not really that satisfying if you're not the town who thought of it first -- you're juts copying someone else's thoughts.
Anyway, just because we don't want to try the "breaking" strat, doesn't mean we can't play a little more optimally. By that I mean we don't want to just chat and chat and chat and give the assassin all the information he needs. So wagon=on:
vote: XScorpion
