Mini 973: "Bawhston" Brawl (WHAT A WIN!)

[Radical Hijinx]

Vote:Oso

Never trust a palindrome.

[Radical Hijinx]

Herm. Never been in a game with a PGO before. Let alone someone claiming PGO second post.

My head says policy lynch. My heart gets eaten by WIFOM.

unvote, Vote:Hoopla

[Radical Hijinx]

I read reckoners reaction as a throwaway joke. Delivered somewhat deadpan but the GG pretty much sold it as not serious. Happy with my Hoopla vote at least untill her motovations are made clearer.

Also did not like those who chose to ignore the Hoopla claim. Seems to me that either they genuinely missed it(in which case they cant read a few posts), felt it was not serious or did not know how to act and so chose to avoid and wait to see what way public opinion went. First two show incompetence and the last comes across as scummy.

[Radical Hijinx]

I'll conceed the False Dilemma point, perhaps there are other possabilities, I took what I felt to be the most plausible.

Dont feel that calling bad gameplay bad is Ad Hominem however. I am not attacking the person, I am attacking the method. And in this case there is no argument I am attempting to discredit. I am discussing the lack of response altogether.

[Radical Hijinx]

Also Oso. Way to STILL fail to address or react to the claim

[Radical Hijinx]

Surely you realise that if everyone adopted that viewpoint then nothing would be gained at all, everyone would be waiting for everyone else to react first anf would be too worried to respond. And since we don't know who is scum then we cannot allow anyone to be exempt.

[Radical Hijinx]

So you don't think one unconfirmed player with near immunity to night actions is a worrisome development and instead you will go after someone whos only posts have been to tell Rek to stop being "silly" and "start playing the game"?

[Radical Hijinx]

How reliable investigative roles are is not the issue. The issue is that such roles likley exist in this game and someone may have invented a senario in which they are exempt. It warrants discussion if nothing else!

[Radical Hijinx]

Policy lynch was perhaps a bit silly on my part. I can see now how claiming it can seem better than not. I saw a giant "Never target me with night actions" sign and failed to recognise the the possible protown motovations based therein. The role, particulary when claimed does spook me a bit.

[Radical Hijinx]

@RH - Why policy lynch PGO?

I felt that its dangers as a lie outshone its benifits as a truth. Since then Hoopla has acted well and I was probably too quick in calling for a policy lynch. PGO was pretty new to be and I reacted poorly.